Key takeaways
- A heat pump must meet the full space heating need at the design condition without counting on secondary heaters[1][2].
- Oversizing is a mistake too: systems should not be oversized, and air source units should modulate down to the typical mid-season load[1].
- Running a high flow temperature to rescue small radiators costs the customer efficiency; size emitters for 55°C or lower where feasible[3].
- Hot water sizing causes as many complaints as space heating; size the cylinder for the household, not the house.
Why sizing errors turn into complaints
When heat pumps are designed well, customers are happy. Government reports that 90% to 95% of property owners who had a heat pump installed under the Boiler Upgrade Scheme are satisfied with their heating system[4]. When they go wrong, the cause is rarely a faulty product. It is usually a design decision made on survey day: a guessed design temperature, a heat pump picked a size up to be safe, a radiator left too small or a cylinder chosen from a price list.
Problems with home maintenance and repair work are common and costly across the sector. In the 12 months to April 2021, 25% of UK adults bought home and garden maintenance and repair services, which include plumbing and central heating, and 11% of those had a consumer problem[5]. The median net cost to consumers was £109 per problem, among the ten highest of any sector[6]. A heat pump complaint usually costs far more than that, in return visits, extra radiators and reputation.
- Had a consumer problem 11%
Source: Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (GOV.UK), 2021[5]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Had a consumer problem | 11% |
Mistake 1: sizing from the old boiler
Boilers in British homes are usually much bigger than the heat loss they serve, because they were sized for fast hot water or simply replaced like for like. A heat pump sized to match the old boiler will almost always be oversized. Approved Document L's 2026 edition says plainly that sizing a replacement heating appliance from the output of the existing appliance is not appropriate, and that space heating systems should be designed from a BS EN 12831-1 heat loss calculation with a sizing method that suits the dwelling[1]. Do the calculation, every time.
Mistake 2: the wrong design temperatures
The heat loss figure depends on the outside design temperature for the location and the inside temperature for each room. Pick an outside temperature that is too mild and the system will be short on the coldest days; pick internal temperatures that do not match how the customer lives and the comfort will be wrong even when the sums are right. Use the design temperatures your design standard and tool specify for the location, and agree room temperatures with the customer, writing them on the design.
Exposed sites, homes at altitude and customers who keep some rooms very warm all deserve a second look. Record the reasons for any change from the defaults so the design can be explained later.
Mistake 3: oversizing to be safe
Adding a margin feels prudent, but it has costs. An oversized heat pump costs more, may need a bigger electricity supply and, in mild weather, can cycle on and off rather than running steadily, which hurts efficiency and wear. Approved Document L says systems should not be oversized, and that air source heat pump systems should be inverter driven and selected to modulate down to the typical mid-season heating load of the dwelling[1]. Check the selected unit's minimum output against the mid-season load, not just its maximum against the coldest day.
Mistake 4: counting on backup heaters
The opposite error is to choose a smaller unit and rely on an immersion heater, a backup element or plug-in heaters to cover the gap. Approved Document L says a primary heating system containing heat pumps, including hybrids, should be selected to meet the full space heating requirement at the design condition, and should not assume heat from additional secondary heaters[1]. For grant work, the heat pump must be sized to meet the full space heating needs of the property whether or not a supplementary appliance is fitted[2]. Undersizing breaks both rules and leaves the customer with high bills in cold spells.
Mistake 5: a high flow temperature to rescue small radiators
If the radiators are too small, it is tempting to run the heat pump at a higher flow temperature until the rooms feel warm. That works, at the cost of efficiency, every hour the system runs. Approved Document L expects new and fully replaced wet systems to be sized to run at a maximum flow temperature of 55°C or lower, and where that is not feasible, at the lowest design temperature that meets the heating need[3]. The 2026 edition adds that the heat emitter circuit flow temperature should be designed to optimise the heat pump's efficiency[1]. Size the radiators for the flow temperature, not the flow temperature for the radiators.
Mistake 6: hot water sized from the house, not the household
Space heating gets the attention; hot water gets the complaints. A heat pump reheats a cylinder more slowly than a combi heats water on demand, so the cylinder volume, the coil and the reheat strategy have to match how many people live there and how they use water. Ask how many showers are taken in the morning, whether anyone runs a deep bath, and whether the household is about to grow. Then size the cylinder and set the schedule to suit, and explain to the customer how reheating works.
Mistake 7: controls left on factory settings
A correctly sized heat pump can still disappoint if it is commissioned with default settings. Weather compensation curves, maximum flow temperatures, hot water schedules and any backup heater thresholds all need setting to the design, not to the manufacturer's out-of-box values. Customers also bring boiler habits with them, switching the heating off overnight and expecting a fast warm-up in the morning. Set the controls to match the design, show the customer why steady running suits a heat pump, and check the settings again at the first service.
Symptoms and causes
| What the customer says | Likely design cause | How to prevent it |
|---|---|---|
| The house is cold in a cold snap | Mild design temperature or undersized unit | Use the location's design temperature and size for the full load |
| It keeps switching on and off | Unit oversized for mid-season load | Check minimum modulation against the mid-season load |
| The bills are higher than promised | High flow temperature or backup heater running | Size emitters for low flow temperatures; avoid relying on backup |
| We run out of hot water | Cylinder too small for the household | Size for occupants and habits, and set a reheat schedule |
| One room never warms up | Room-level heat loss missed | Room-by-room calculation and radiator check |
A design review before every quote
Most of these mistakes are caught by a second pair of eyes. Before any heat pump quote goes out, have someone other than the surveyor check the design against a short list. It takes a few minutes and is the cheapest complaint prevention you will find.
- Heat loss calculated room by room, with design temperatures stated and justified.
- Construction assumptions recorded with evidence, especially walls, floors and extensions.
- Heat pump meets the full load at the design condition and modulates to the mid-season load.
- Every room's emitter output checked at the design flow temperature.
- Cylinder size and reheat schedule matched to the household.
- No reliance on backup or secondary heaters to meet the design load.
Example: the cold back bedroom
Example (fictional): a customer complains that their back bedroom is cold every morning, three months after a heat pump install. The installer reviews the design and finds the room was entered with the main house's wall construction, but it is over an unheated garage with a suspended floor. The room's real heat loss is much higher than designed, and the radiator is too small at the design flow temperature.
The installer fits a larger radiator at its own cost, corrects the design record and adds a garage-ceiling prompt to its survey sheet. The customer's complaint is closed within a fortnight, and the review they leave mentions how it was handled rather than the fault.
Handling the complaint when it comes
Every service supplied to a consumer includes a term that it is performed with reasonable care and skill[7]. If a design error causes a problem, the customer is entitled to have it put right. Respond quickly, visit with the design in hand, and check the actual room against the assumptions. If your design was right and the cause is how the system is being used, explain it patiently and adjust the controls with the customer. If the design was wrong, say so and fix it. Read explaining heat pump running costs honestly for the conversation about bills.
Frequently asked questions
Is it better to oversize a heat pump slightly?
No. Approved Document L says systems should not be oversized, and air source units should modulate down to the typical mid-season load.
Can I rely on the immersion heater to cover the coldest days?
No. The heat pump should meet the full space heating requirement at the design condition, and grant rules require sizing for the full space heating need.
Why do customers run out of hot water with heat pumps?
Usually because the cylinder and reheat schedule were not sized for the household's real use. Ask about occupants and habits at survey.
What flow temperature should I design for?
For new or fully replaced wet systems in England, 55°C or lower where feasible, and the lowest temperature that meets the heating need.
References
GOV.UK (Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government) (2026). Approved Document L, Volume 1: Dwellings (2026 edition) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Ofgem (2026). Boiler Upgrade Scheme (BUS): installers (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government) (2023). Approved Document L, Volume 1: Dwellings (2021 edition incorporating 2023 amendments) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Department for Energy Security and Net Zero (GOV.UK) (2026). Warm Homes Plan (opens in a new tab) ↑
Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (GOV.UK) (2021). Consumer protection study 2022: understanding the impacts and resolution of consumer problems (opens in a new tab) ↑
Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (GOV.UK) (2021). Consumer protection study 2022: understanding the impacts and resolution of consumer problems (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 49 (opens in a new tab) ↑