Key takeaways
- Most unhappy consumers go to the trader first, so a fast, fair internal procedure resolves most complaints.
- Commit to timescales: acknowledge quickly, investigate with evidence, and give a written outcome.
- If your work fell short, the customer can require you to put it right at your cost; offer that early.
- The consumer ADR rules moved into the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 from 6 April 2026, so check your ADR wording.
Why a small firm needs a written procedure
In a small plumbing and heating firm, complaints are usually handled by whoever picks up the phone, in whatever mood they are in. The engineer feels accused, the owner is busy, and the customer gets defensiveness instead of a plan. A written procedure takes the emotion out. Everyone knows what happens next, how fast and who decides.
Complaints are not rare in home services. In the government's consumer protection study, 25% of UK adults had bought home and garden maintenance and repair services, which include plumbing and central heating, in the previous year, and 11% of those buyers had a consumer problem[1]. The median net cost to the consumer was £109 per problem, among the ten highest of any sector[2]. The same study shows that people with a problem overwhelmingly start with the trader: they contacted the seller directly in 81% of the cases where they took action[1].
That is the opportunity. If the first conversation with you goes well, the complaint rarely goes anywhere else. Online reviews, dispute resolution services and legal action all come further down the list.
The procedure in six steps
Receive and log
Any complaint, however it arrives, is logged the same day with the customer's own words, the job reference and who took it. Phone, email, text, social media and a word to the engineer on site all count.
Acknowledge
Contact the customer within two working days. Thank them, say who is handling it and when they will hear next.
Make safe first
If there is a safety risk, a leak or no heating for a vulnerable household, deal with that immediately, before the investigation.
Investigate
Look at the job record, photos, readings and notes. Talk to the engineer. Visit if needed, ideally with someone other than the original engineer.
Respond in writing
Within ten working days, or explain the delay. Say what you found, whether you accept the complaint in full, in part or not at all, and what you will do.
Close and learn
Confirm the customer is satisfied or record that they are not. Tag the cause and review complaints monthly.
The timescales above are suggestions, not legal requirements. What matters is that you commit to some, publish them and meet them. A customer who hears from you when you promised is already halfway to being satisfied.
The first conversation
Most complaints are won or lost in the first two minutes. Do not argue, explain or defend. Listen, summarise and give a next step.
Script: 'Thank you for telling us. So I've got this right: since the new boiler went in, the pressure has dropped three times and you've had to top it up, and you're worried it wasn't installed properly. I'm logging that now as a complaint. I'm going to look at the job record today and I'll call you by tomorrow afternoon with what we'll do. Is there anything urgent, like a leak, I need to deal with first?'
- Use the word complaint if the customer is unhappy; it shows you are taking it seriously.
- Repeat the problem back in their words, not yours.
- Do not promise an outcome before investigating, but do promise the next contact.
- Never blame the engineer, the manufacturer or the customer on the first call.
Remedies you can offer
If your work did not meet the standard required, the law gives the customer a clear remedy. Every service contract includes a term that you perform the service with reasonable care and skill[3]. Where you fall short, the customer can require you to perform the service again, to the extent needed to put it right, within a reasonable time, without significant inconvenience to them and at your cost[4]. Offering this promptly, before the customer has to ask, is usually the quickest way to close a valid complaint.
If putting it right is impossible, or you fail to do it within a reasonable time and without significant inconvenience, the customer can instead ask for a price reduction, which may where appropriate be the full price[5]. In practice, most customers want the fault fixed, not a refund, so lead with the fix.
| Situation | Usual remedy | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Work not done with reasonable care and skill | Put it right at your cost | Within a reasonable time, without significant inconvenience to the customer |
| Putting it right is impossible or not done in a reasonable time | Price reduction, up to a full refund | Agree the amount in writing |
| Damage caused during the work | Repair or pay for the damage, via your insurer if needed | Tell your insurer promptly |
| Service issue, such as lateness or rudeness | Apology and explanation, sometimes a goodwill gesture | Be specific about what will change |
| Complaint not upheld | Clear written explanation with evidence | Offer a second look by another engineer if appropriate |
Records to keep
- The complaint log: date, channel, customer, job, summary in their words, handler.
- Every contact with the customer, with date, time and what was said or sent.
- The evidence reviewed: job sheets, photos, readings, engineer's account.
- Your written response and the remedy offered.
- The outcome: accepted, partly accepted, not accepted; customer satisfied or not.
- The root cause tag: workmanship, communication, parts, scheduling, pricing, other.
Keep the log simple enough that it actually gets used. A shared spreadsheet with one row per complaint works fine for most small firms, as long as access is restricted.
When you cannot agree: alternative dispute resolution
Some complaints will not resolve however well you handle them. Alternative dispute resolution, through an independent scheme, can help both sides avoid court. The rules changed recently: the Alternative Dispute Resolution for Consumer Disputes (Competent Authorities and Information) Regulations 2015 were revoked on 6 April 2026, with the framework now under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024[6]. If your terms, website or complaint letters mention ADR or quote the old regulations, review them against current Trading Standards guidance.
- Check whether your trade association or a scheme you belong to offers ADR, and whether you must use it.
- If you do not use ADR, be ready to say so clearly in your final response.
- For concerns about unsafe gas work, the customer can report them to the Gas Safe Register.
- For money disputes, the customer may use the county court small claims process.
Write a clear final response letter when internal handling is finished, stating your position, the remedy offered and the customer's options. That letter is what an ADR provider, Trading Standards or a court will read first.
Learning from complaints
A complaint log is only useful if someone reads it. Once a month, the owner or manager should look at every complaint closed in that month and ask three questions: what caused it, could we have prevented it, and what are we changing? Most firms find that a few causes account for most complaints, such as arrival windows missed, prices not agreed before extra work, or one type of joint or fitting that keeps failing.
- Share themes with the whole team, not just the engineer involved, and keep it blame-free.
- Turn repeated causes into a change in process, training or kit, and check whether complaints of that type fall.
- Track how long complaints take to close; slow handling is a complaint in itself.
- Note compliments in the same log, so engineers hear what is going well too.
Example: a pressure-loss complaint
Example: a fictional customer complains six weeks after a combi install that the pressure keeps dropping. The office logs it, acknowledges the same day and books a visit by a different engineer within three working days. He finds a weeping joint on the flow pipe under the floor, an installation fault. The firm repairs it, checks the system, sends a written response with photos and confirms that there is no charge. Two weeks later the office calls to check the pressure has held. The complaint is tagged 'workmanship: joints' and discussed at the next team meeting. In this example the customer's review mentions the fault, but also the speed and honesty of the fix.
A short policy to publish
Our complaints promise: if you are unhappy with our work or service, tell us by phone, email or in person. We will log it the same day, contact you within two working days and give you a written response within ten working days, or explain why we need longer. If we got something wrong, we will put it right at no cost to you. If we cannot agree, we will tell you what other options are available.
Put it on your website, your quotes and your invoices. Customers who can see how complaints work are less anxious about raising them early, and early is when complaints are cheapest to fix.
Frequently asked questions
Is a plumbing business legally required to have a complaints procedure?
There is no general legal requirement for a small trader to publish one, but trade schemes and some contracts expect it, and it is the best way to deal with complaints quickly and fairly.
How quickly should I respond to a complaint?
Acknowledge within a couple of working days and give a written response within about ten working days, or explain the delay. Deal with safety issues immediately.
Do I have to offer alternative dispute resolution?
It depends on your trade scheme and circumstances. The ADR rules moved into the DMCC Act 2024 from 6 April 2026, so check current Trading Standards guidance and your scheme's rules.
References
Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (GOV.UK) (2021). Consumer protection study 2022: understanding the impacts and resolution of consumer problems (opens in a new tab) ↑
Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (GOV.UK) (2021). Consumer protection study 2022: median net monetised detriment by sector (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 49 (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 55 (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 56 (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2026). The Alternative Dispute Resolution for Consumer Disputes (Competent Authorities and Information) Regulations 2015, regulation 19 (revoked) (opens in a new tab) ↑