Customer experience

Handling call-backs and rework without losing trust

Decide which plumbing return visits are free and which are chargeable, explain it fairly, and use a root-cause log to cut repeat visits over time.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Not every return visit is a call-back
  2. Free, chargeable or grey: a decision guide
  3. What customers want when something goes wrong
  4. How to talk about it
  5. Who should attend the return visit
  6. Goodwill: when to waive a charge anyway
  7. When a fix is not possible
  8. The root-cause log
  9. Cutting call-backs over time
  10. Example: a month of call-backs
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • Classify every return visit: our fault and free, a new fault and chargeable, or a grey area you decide openly.
  • If your work was not done with reasonable care and skill, putting it right is at your cost and within a reasonable time.
  • Customers who have a problem mostly want it fixed, an apology or an explanation; give those quickly.
  • Keep a root-cause log of every call-back and review it monthly; it is the cheapest quality system you will ever run.

Not every return visit is a call-back

Every firm has return visits. Some are genuine call-backs: the repair did not hold, a joint weeps, the boiler was not set up properly. Some are new faults that happen to appear soon after you were there. Some are the result of advice the customer chose not to take. Treating all of them the same way, either always free or always chargeable, is unfair to someone. Always free and you pay for faults you did not cause; always chargeable and you lose customers who had every right to expect a fix.

The legal starting point is clear. A trader must perform a service with reasonable care and skill[1]. If the work falls short, the customer can require you to perform it again, to the extent needed to put it right, within a reasonable time, without significant inconvenience to them, and you must bear the necessary costs, including labour and materials[2]. That covers genuine call-backs. It does not make you responsible for every later fault in an old system.

The aim of this guide is a consistent approach: a clear decision on who pays, an honest explanation to the customer, and a record that helps you make fewer return visits next year. Consistency matters as much as generosity, because customers compare notes and expect the same treatment as their neighbour.

Free, chargeable or grey: a decision guide

A starting point for deciding whether a return visit is free
SituationUsuallyWhy
Same fault returns after your repairFreeThe repair did not work as it should
Leak or fault at a joint or part you fittedFreeWorkmanship or a part you supplied
Boiler not commissioned or set up correctlyFreePart of the original job
New fault in a part you did not touchChargeableA different fault, but explain clearly
Fault you warned about and the customer declined to fixChargeableAdvice was given and recorded
Customer changed settings or controlsOften free the first time, chargeable afterEducation is part of good handover
Part you fitted fails within its guaranteeFree labour and part, or per your termsCheck your guarantee terms and the supplier's
  1. Is it the same fault?

    Compare the symptoms and the job report. Same symptom, same area: treat as a call-back until proved otherwise.

  2. Did our work cause or fail to fix it?

    If yes, it is free. If you are not sure, attend first and decide on site with evidence.

  3. Did we warn about it?

    If the report records advice that was declined, the visit is normally chargeable. Say so politely.

  4. Is a guarantee involved?

    Check parts and labour guarantees before saying anything about cost.

  5. What will the customer reasonably think?

    In grey areas, a free first visit that ends with a clear explanation often costs less than an argument.

What customers want when something goes wrong

When consumers acted on a problem, the government's consumer protection study found the most common requests were for the trader to replace or fix the product (34% of cases), give a refund (33%), apologise (27%) or explain the problem (27%)[3]. For a service like plumbing, that translates into a fix, an apology and an explanation far more often than a demand for money back.

What UK consumers asked traders to do about a problem (12 months to April 2021)Share of problems where the consumer took action; all sectors; more than one request possible
What UK consumers asked traders to do about a problem (12 months to April 2021)Bar chart. Replace or fix the product: 34%; Provide a refund: 33%; Apologise: 27%; Explain the problem: 27%.Replace or fix the productReplace or fix the product: 34%34%Provide a refundProvide a refund: 33%33%ApologiseApologise: 27%27%Explain the problemExplain the problem: 27%27%What UK consumers asked traders to do about a problem (12 months to April 2021)Bar chart. Replace or fix the product: 34%; Provide a refund: 33%; Apologise: 27%; Explain the problem: 27%.Replace or fix the productReplace or fix the product: 34%34%Provide a refundProvide a refund: 33%33%ApologiseApologise: 27%27%Explain the problemExplain the problem: 27%27%

Source: Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (GOV.UK), 2022[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
Replace or fix the product34%
Provide a refund33%
Apologise27%
Explain the problem27%

The same study found that sellers most often restored or fixed the product (48%) and apologised (42%)[3]. Those two responses cost little compared with the value of the customer relationship, and they are what most customers are hoping for when they ring.

How to talk about it

Free call-back: 'I'm sorry it's leaking again. That's the joint we made, so we'll put it right at no cost. Can we come tomorrow morning? If water is coming through the ceiling, turn off the stopcock and we'll get someone there today.'

Chargeable return: 'I've looked at your report. Last month our engineer replaced the diverter valve, and he noted the expansion vessel had lost charge and suggested replacing it. The pressure loss you're describing sounds like that vessel, which is a separate part. We can come out to confirm, and if it is the vessel, the visit and the replacement would be charged as quoted. If it turns out to be the valve we fitted, there's no charge.'

Grey area: 'We're not certain yet whether this is linked to our work. We'll come and look at no charge. If it is ours, we'll fix it free. If it's something else, we'll explain what we found and give you a price before doing anything.'

Never decide a charge on the phone when the cause is unclear. Attend, find the cause, show the customer and then talk about cost.

Who should attend the return visit

There is a reasonable case for sending the original engineer: they know the job and should see the result of their work. There is also a case for sending someone else: a fresh pair of eyes, and a customer who may have lost confidence in the first engineer. A sensible rule is to send the original engineer for straightforward call-backs where the customer is relaxed, and a different or senior engineer when the customer is upset, the fault has returned more than once, or the cause is disputed.

Either way, the original engineer should always hear what was found. Without that feedback, the same mistake gets made on the next job. Keep the conversation factual and private; the aim is to fix the process, not to embarrass anyone in front of the team.

Goodwill: when to waive a charge anyway

Sometimes a return visit is technically chargeable but charging would cost you more than it earns. A long-standing customer, a landlord with a dozen properties, an older customer who genuinely did not understand the advice, or a case where your report was unclear may all justify a goodwill waiver. Make it a conscious decision rather than a reflex.

  • Tell the customer it is a goodwill gesture, so the next chargeable visit is not a surprise.
  • Record the waiver and the reason in the job record.
  • Use the same criteria across the office so customers are treated consistently.
  • If your own unclear report caused the confusion, fix the report template as well.

When a fix is not possible

Occasionally the original work cannot be put right, or a fix cannot be done within a reasonable time. In those cases the customer can ask for a price reduction instead, which may where appropriate be the full price[4]. Agree the amount in writing and record why repeat performance was not possible. This is rare in plumbing, where most faults can be fixed, but it matters when, for example, the wrong product was specified and the customer no longer wants you back.

The root-cause log

The most valuable thing a call-back gives you is information. Log every return visit, free or chargeable, with a cause. Review the log once a month. Patterns appear quickly: one engineer's compression joints, one brand of valve, first visits that are too short to diagnose properly, handovers that leave customers confused about controls.

Example root-cause log entry (fictional)
FieldExample entry
Original job and dateRadiator valve replacement, 3 March
Return visit date and engineer17 March, different engineer
Customer's description'Still dripping under the radiator'
FindingOlive not seated on the new valve
ClassificationFree call-back: workmanship
Root cause categoryJoint making
Action takenRemade joint, tested, photos
LearningRefresher on compression joints at team meeting
  • Workmanship: joints, fixings, sealing, commissioning.
  • Diagnosis: wrong part replaced, cause missed.
  • Parts: faulty new part, wrong specification.
  • Handover: customer not shown controls or settings.
  • Customer decision: advice declined and the fault occurred.
  • New fault: unrelated to previous work.

Cutting call-backs over time

  1. Give first visits enough time to diagnose rather than guess; rushed diagnosis drives repeat visits.
  2. Carry the common parts for your area's most frequent faults, so fixes happen on the first visit.
  3. Use a short end-of-job test routine for each job type, and photograph readings.
  4. Do a proper controls handover and leave a one-page guide.
  5. Feed the monthly log into training, and pair engineers with repeat issues with a mentor.

Call-backs also have a cost to customers that is easy to forget. Consumer problems with home maintenance and repair carried a median net cost to the consumer of £109 per problem, among the highest of any sector[3]. A firm that gets the job right first time saves its customers that cost as well as its own.

Example: a month of call-backs

Example: a fictional six-engineer firm logs nine return visits in a month. Four are free call-backs: three leaking compression joints from the same engineer and one boiler not balanced after commissioning. Three are chargeable new faults, each explained with the original report. Two are grey areas where the firm attended free and found unrelated causes. The owner books a joint-making refresher for the engineer concerned and adds balancing to the commissioning checklist. The next month there is one free call-back. In this example the log turned an uncomfortable month into a measurable improvement.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to fix my own faulty work for free?

Yes. If the work was not done with reasonable care and skill, the customer can require you to put it right within a reasonable time and at your cost, including labour and materials.

Can I charge for a return visit if it is a different fault?

Yes, if the fault is genuinely unrelated to your work. Explain why with evidence, ideally from your job report, and agree the charge before doing the work.

How long after a repair is a call-back still my responsibility?

There is no fixed period. It depends on whether the fault comes from your work. Your own labour and parts guarantees should set clear periods, and you remain responsible for faulty workmanship.

References

  1. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 49 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 55 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (GOV.UK) (2022). Consumer protection study 2022: understanding the impacts and resolution of consumer problems (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 56 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo