Key takeaways
- Most payment disputes on domestic jobs start with extra work agreed verbally. Put every change in writing before you do it.
- A one-page variation form, signed or approved by text or email, is enough: what changed, why, the price and the time.
- Agree a schedule of rates in the original quote so hidden problems can be priced quickly and fairly.
- Hidden problems are common: 5% of homes in England (1.4 million) had a damp problem in 2024[1].
- What you tell a customer about the work can become part of the contract[2], so the written record protects both of you.
Why extra work causes most disputes
Ask any plumber about their worst payment dispute and it will usually involve extra work. A customer asks for an extra radiator while you are there, or the floor turns out to be rotten, and you agree a figure in the hallway. Three weeks later the invoice arrives, the customer remembers a different number or no number at all, and you are arguing about money you have already spent.
The law does not leave you without a remedy. Where no price is agreed for a service, the consumer must pay a reasonable price[3]. But ‘reasonable’ is exactly the argument you want to avoid. A written variation, agreed before the work starts, turns a likely dispute into a routine line on the invoice.
When you need a variation
Treat anything that changes the price, the time or the result of the job as a variation.
- The customer asks for something extra: another radiator, a different position for the shower, an outside tap.
- The customer changes a choice after ordering: a different tile, a bigger cylinder, a new layout.
- You find a hidden problem that has to be fixed for the job to be done properly: rotten timber, corroded pipework, a blocked drain run.
- Something outside your control changes the job: access is not available, another trade has damaged your work, the water company requires notice before a fitting is installed.
- You need to remove something from the scope, which should reduce the price.
Small courtesies, such as tightening a dripping tap in the next room, do not need a form. Anything you would expect to be paid for does.
A one-page variation form
| Field | What to write |
|---|---|
| Job reference | Customer name, address, original quote number and date |
| Variation number | V1, V2 and so on, in order |
| What has changed | Plain description: ‘Replace two joist ends under bath position, approx. 600mm each’ |
| Why | Customer request, hidden condition found, or other reason, with photo reference |
| Price | Fixed figure, or the rates from the quote and an estimate of hours and materials |
| Effect on time | Extra days, and any effect on the finish date |
| Effect on payments | Added to the next stage payment, or the final account |
| Approval | Customer signature, or a reply by text or email saying they agree |
A paper pad in the van works. So does a template in your job software or a standard text message. What matters is that the description, the price and the customer's agreement are recorded together and dated before the extra work begins.
The on-site process
Stop and make safe
If you find something that is unsafe, such as a damaged gas fitting or an active leak, make it safe first. Then stop work on the affected part.
Show the customer
Show them the problem in person or by photo. Customers accept bad news far more readily when they have seen it.
Explain the options
Fix it now at the stated price, fix it a different way, or leave it and accept the consequences in writing.
Price it
Use the schedule of rates from your quote, or give a fixed figure. If you need time to price it properly, say when you will have the figure.
Get approval in writing
A signature on the form, or a reply to a text or email: ‘Yes, please go ahead with V2 at £280.’ (Example wording.)
Record and carry on
Photograph the problem and the repair, attach both to the variation and continue.
Pricing hidden problems fairly
The fastest way to price a surprise is to have agreed how you will price it before the job starts. Put a short schedule of rates in every quote for larger jobs: your hourly or day rate for additional labour, your handling margin on extra materials and any standard items you often find, such as replacing a section of lead pipe or a corroded isolation valve.
Hidden problems are not rare. In England, 5% of dwellings, about 1.4 million homes, had a damp problem in 2024, up from 4% in 2021 and 2022[1]. Under bathrooms and kitchens, that damp often means damaged floors and timbers that nobody could see at survey.
Source: Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK), 2024[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| 2021 | 4% |
| 2024 | 5% |
Where the uncertainty was foreseeable, a provisional sum in the original quote is better than a variation, because the customer has already budgeted for it. Variations should cover what nobody could reasonably have predicted, and changes the customer asks for.
Scripts for the conversation
- Example, discovered problem: ‘I've found something under the bath I need to show you. The two joists the bath sits on have rotted at the ends. I can repair them today for £280 using the rates in the quote, or I can show you how to get a joiner in, but it will hold the job up by a few days. Which would you prefer?’
- Example, customer request: ‘Happy to add the outside tap. It's not in the quote, so I'll write it up as a variation: £150 including the valve and the fitting, about two hours. Could you reply to my text to confirm?’
- Example, reducing scope: ‘If we keep the existing radiator in the bathroom, that takes £220 off the quote. I'll put that on a variation so it shows on your final invoice.’
Always say the price out loud and then put it in writing. Customers who have heard a figure and seen it written down rarely dispute it later.
What the law expects of you
For domestic customers, the Consumer Rights Act 2015 does much of the work. Every service must be carried out with reasonable care and skill[4]. Anything said or written to the consumer about the service by the trader can be treated as part of the contract when the consumer relies on it[2]. So, for example, if you tell a customer that a repair will cost £280, that figure becomes part of the deal whether or not you wrote it down. The variation form simply makes sure you both remember the same thing.
Keep variations with the job file for at least as long as your warranty runs. If a dispute reaches a complaints process, a signed form and a photo are far more persuasive than anyone's memory.
Landlord and agency jobs need a different approval route
On rented properties the person standing next to you is often not the person who pays. A tenant can tell you about a problem, but they usually cannot approve extra spending on the landlord's property. Get this wrong and you can do the work, invoice the agent and find that nobody authorised it.
- Ask at the start of every agency job who can approve extra work and up to what value. Many agents set a spending limit above which the landlord must agree.
- Send variations to the named approver with photos, and wait for a written reply or a purchase order number before you proceed.
- If the problem is urgent and the approver cannot be reached, make safe, leave the property safe and usable where you can, and record what you did and why.
- Put the variation number and the approval reference on the invoice so the agent's accounts team can match it.
- Keep tenants informed about what has been approved and when you will return, so they are not left guessing.
Social landlords and large agencies often have strict timescales for repairs and their own forms for additional work. Use their process when they have one; it is the fastest route to being paid.
Example: one job, three variations
Example (fictional): on a bathroom refit in Swindon, the plumber raised three variations. V1 added a heated towel rail at the customer's request. V2 repaired rotten joists found under the bath, priced from the schedule of rates. V3 removed the cost of a basin the customer had decided to buy themselves. Each was approved by text before the work. The final account showed the original quote, the three variations and the total. The customer paid within a week without a single query.
Rule of thumb: if you would be annoyed not to be paid for it, write it down before you do it.
Frequently asked questions
What is a variation order on a domestic plumbing job?
A short written record of a change to the agreed work, with a description, the reason, the price, any effect on time, and the customer's approval before the work starts.
Is a text message enough to agree extra work?
It is far better than nothing. Send the description and price, and ask the customer to reply confirming. Keep the messages with the job file.
What if the customer refuses to approve a necessary repair?
Explain the consequences, record their decision in writing, and do not carry out work they have refused. If it affects safety, make safe and follow the relevant safety procedure.
Can I charge for extra work that was not agreed in writing?
Where no price was agreed, the customer must pay a reasonable price[3], but proving what is reasonable is hard. Written agreement avoids the argument.
References
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2024). English Housing Survey 2024 to 2025: Chapter 1, housing quality (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 50 (information about the trader or service to be binding) (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 51 (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 49 (opens in a new tab) ↑