Key takeaways
- An employee costs more than their salary: employer National Insurance at 15% above £5,000 a year, at least 3% pension and 5.6 weeks' paid holiday[1][2][3].
- For a firm that qualifies, Employment Allowance (up to £10,500 a year) offsets the first slice of employer National Insurance[4].
- Subcontractors cost more per day but only when you have work, which suits peaks, installs and specialist jobs.
- Control and consistency favour employees; the more you direct a subbie, the higher the status risk.
- Most growing firms end up with a core of employees and a small, well-managed bench of subcontractors.
The choice most heating firms face
Once the diary is full and the owner can no longer cover every job, the next engineer can be hired or subcontracted. The trade is split almost evenly: about 77,400 UK plumbers and heating installers were employees and 71,200 self-employed in the year to June 2026[5][6]. That means good subcontractors are available in most areas, but so is competition for the employees who want a steady job.
- Employees 77,400 52%
- Self-employed 71,200 48%
Source: Office for National Statistics (Nomis), 2026[5]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Employees | 77,400 |
| Self-employed | 71,200 |
There is no single right answer. The best choice depends on how predictable your work is, how much you need to control the customer experience, and how much risk you can carry. Hiring is hard either way: 45% of construction SME employers named recruitment and skills as an obstacle in 2025[7].
Side by side
| Factor | Employed engineer | Subcontractor |
|---|---|---|
| Cost when busy | Lower per productive day | Higher day rate or price per job |
| Cost when quiet | Paid anyway | Nothing if no work is offered |
| On-costs | Employer NI, pension, holiday, sick pay[1][2][3][8] | None directly; CIS deductions handled on payments[9] |
| Control over how jobs are done | High | Limited, by design |
| Customer experience | Consistent with training | Varies; depends on the subbie |
| Status risk | None | Rises the more you direct them |
| Availability for emergencies and on-call | Can be required in the contract | Only if they agree each time |
| Building the business | Staff grow with you; value on sale | Little lasting value to the firm |
The real cost of an employee
Salary is only the start. Employers pay 15% secondary Class 1 National Insurance on earnings above £5,000 a year[1], must pay at least 3% into a workplace pension under auto-enrolment[2], and almost all workers are entitled to 5.6 weeks' paid holiday[3]. Sick pay adds more: Statutory Sick Pay is £123.25 a week or 80% of average weekly earnings, whichever is lower, for 2026 to 2027[8]. Then there is the van, fuel, tools, phone, PPE, training and the time spent managing.
Example: on the 2026 median gross annual pay for employee plumbers of £37,794[10], employer National Insurance is 15% of £32,794, which is £4,919.10 a year. An eligible small employer can offset this against Employment Allowance of up to £10,500[4], so a firm with two or three employees may pay little or no employer NI at all. The holiday entitlement means you pay for about 28 days when the engineer is not working on jobs, which is why the productive day rate of an employee is higher than their basic rate suggests.
15%
Employer National Insurance on earnings above £5,000 a year, 2026 to 2027[1]
The real cost of a subcontractor
A subcontractor's day rate or job price covers their own van, tools, insurance, holidays and quiet weeks, so it is higher than an employee's daily cost. The saving is that you pay only for days you use. For plumbing and heating work, most payments fall under the Construction Industry Scheme, and you deduct 20% for a registered subcontractor or 30% if they are not registered or cannot be verified[9]. That is not a cost to you, but it is admin: verification, monthly returns and statements.
The hidden costs are quality and continuity. A subbie who fits a boiler and moves on is not there for the callback. Customers do not care about status; they see your name on the paperwork. Budget time for checking work, chasing certificates and handling complaints about jobs you did not do yourself.
Control, quality and status
The things that make an employee valuable, such as using your scripts, following your install standard, wearing your uniform and taking jobs from your diary, are also the things that make a subcontractor look like an employee. If you need that level of control, you probably need an employee. If you can define the output, such as a boiler swap to a written standard with a fixed price, a subcontractor can deliver it without daily direction.
- Employees suit: servicing, breakdowns, on-call rotas, landlord work and anything where the customer relationship is ongoing.
- Subcontractors suit: peaks in install work, specialist tasks such as commercial pipework or drainage, and cover for holidays.
- Be careful with: long-term, full-time subbies working only for you; this is where status risk builds.
Flexibility, seasons and on-call cover
Heating work is seasonal. The first cold spell brings a rush of breakdowns, spring and summer suit installs, and some weeks are quiet whatever you do. Employees give you guaranteed capacity in the rush, because you can require reasonable overtime and on-call duty in the contract. Subcontractors give you capacity only if they are free, and the best ones are busiest exactly when you are.
That means subcontractors are better at filling planned peaks, such as a block of boiler swaps booked weeks ahead, than unplanned ones, such as a freezing weekend. If your growth is in emergency and breakdown work, employees on a fair on-call rota usually work better. If it is in planned installs, a bench of reliable subcontractors can scale you up without fixed cost.
Cash flow and admin
Employees are a fixed monthly cost paid through payroll, with pension contributions and holiday to manage. Subcontractors are a variable cost, but they expect prompt payment, and slow payers soon find their best subbies unavailable. Under CIS you must verify each subcontractor, make the right deduction, file monthly returns and give statements. The admin is similar in size either way. The difference is that payroll costs continue in a quiet month and subcontractor costs do not.
A hybrid model that works
- Employ enough engineers to cover your steady servicing, repair and on-call workload all year.
- Keep two or three trusted subcontractors on written agreements for install peaks, specialist work and holiday cover.
- Give subcontractors a written install standard and paperwork checklist, then check the output rather than directing the method.
- Pay subcontractors on time, every time. Reliability is what keeps them available when you need them.
- Review the split every six months. If a subcontractor is working for you full time, either change the arrangement or offer employment.
Before relying on a new subcontractor, ask for their Gas Safe details and the categories they hold, their insurance certificate, two recent references from other contractors and an example of their paperwork. Fifteen minutes of checks prevents most of the problems firms report with subbies.
Decision criteria
Measure the base load
Count the engineer-days you sold in each of the last twelve months. Work that is there in your quietest months is a case for employees.
Measure the peaks
Work above the base load, such as winter breakdowns or spring install pushes, is a case for subcontractors or overtime.
Decide what customers must see
If your brand promise depends on the same engineer every year, employ.
Check your cash
An employee is a fixed monthly cost. Make sure three quiet months would not sink you.
Check your management time
Employees need one-to-ones, training and holiday planning. Subcontractors need agreements, checks and prompt payment.
Write it down
Whatever you choose, put it in a contract or a subcontractor agreement that matches how the work really happens.
Example: from two subbies to one employee
Example (fictional): an owner-led firm in Exeter uses two subcontractors for about 180 days a year between them. The owner finds that around 150 of those days are steady servicing and repair work spread across the year. She employs one engineer for that base load and keeps one subcontractor for install peaks and holiday cover. Her total labour cost rises slightly in the first year, but callbacks fall, the new engineer joins the on-call rota, and the servicing customers see the same face each year.
Signs it is time to change the mix
- You turn down servicing contracts because no subcontractor wants regular, low-value visits.
- Callbacks and complaints cluster around jobs done by people you do not manage day to day.
- The same subcontractor has worked only for you, every week, for most of a year.
- Employees are paid for quiet days while installs are sent to subbies at a premium.
- Customers ask for a named engineer you cannot guarantee.
Any two of these together are worth a proper review of who does which work, using the decision criteria above.
Frequently asked questions
Is a subcontractor cheaper than an employee?
Per day, usually not. A subcontractor's rate covers their own costs and quiet weeks. They are cheaper only when your work is uneven, because you pay for the days you use.
Do I pay National Insurance for subcontractors?
No employer National Insurance is due on genuine subcontractors. For construction work you make CIS deductions from their payments instead.
Can I put a subcontractor on my on-call rota?
You can ask, but you cannot require it in the way an employment contract can. Requiring it is also a sign of employment.
References
GOV.UK (2026). Rates and thresholds for employers 2026 to 2027 (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (2026). Workplace pensions: what you, your employer and the government pay (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (2026). Holiday entitlement (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (2026). Rates and thresholds for employers 2026 to 2027 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Office for National Statistics (Nomis) (2026). Annual Population Survey - regional - occupation (SOC2020) by sex by employment type, via Nomis (opens in a new tab) ↑
Office for National Statistics (Nomis) (2026). Annual Population Survey - regional - occupation (SOC2020) by sex by employment type, via Nomis (opens in a new tab) ↑
Department for Business and Trade (GOV.UK) (2025). Longitudinal Small Business Survey 2025: SME employers (businesses with 1 to 249 employees) (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (2026). Rates and thresholds for employers 2026 to 2027 (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (2026). What you must do as a CIS subcontractor: get paid (opens in a new tab) ↑
Office for National Statistics (2026). Annual Survey of Hours and Earnings 2026 provisional, Table 14 (occupation by 4-digit SOC 2020) (opens in a new tab) ↑