Key takeaways
- IR35, the off-payroll working rules, only applies when a worker provides services through their own intermediary, usually a limited company[1].
- A small private-sector client does not make the decision; the worker's own company does[1].
- Medium and large clients must decide status for each engagement and give a Status Determination Statement with reasons[2].
- About 95% of registered plumbing and heating enterprises are micro businesses, so most trade firms are small clients for IR35[3].
- Sole trader subcontractors are outside IR35, but their employment status still matters for tax and CIS.
What IR35 is, in plain terms
The off-payroll working rules, often called IR35, make sure that a worker who provides services through their own company pays broadly the same Income Tax and National Insurance as an employee would, if they would have been an employee had they worked for the client directly[1]. The intermediary is usually a limited company the worker controls, sometimes called a personal service company, but it can also be a partnership or another individual[1].
That definition matters for the trades. A lot of labour-only plumbing work is done by sole traders who invoice in their own name. IR35 does not apply to them, because there is no intermediary. The question for a sole trader is simply whether they are employed or self-employed for tax. IR35 comes into play when the engineer has set up a limited company and invoices through it.
Who decides: small clients versus larger ones
In most cases the client is responsible for deciding the worker's employment status. The exception is a small client outside the public sector: there, the worker's intermediary decides whether the rules apply[1]. HMRC's guidance treats a private-sector client as medium or large if it meets two or more of these conditions: annual turnover of more than £10.2 million, a balance sheet total of more than £5.1 million, or more than 50 employees[2].
Almost all plumbing and heating firms fall well below those thresholds. Of 47,910 registered enterprises, 45,370 have fewer than 10 employees[3]. So if you are a small heating firm using an engineer who trades through his own company, the status decision is his company's to make, not yours. If you work through a large main contractor, a national housebuilder or a big facilities management company, the position flips.
When you are the subcontractor working for a large client
If you trade through your own limited company and take long engagements with a medium or large client, that client must decide your status for each engagement and tell you the result in a Status Determination Statement that gives its conclusion and the reasons for it[2]. It must take reasonable care when making the decision, based on the terms and conditions and the actual working practices[2].
- If the statement says the rules apply, the fee-payer deducts tax and National Insurance from payments to your company as if you were an employee.
- If you disagree, use the client's disagreement process and set out the facts: who controls how you work, whether you can send a substitute, whether you supply your own van, tools and materials, and whether you carry financial risk.
- Keep the statement, the contract and evidence of how the work is actually done, such as quotes, invoices, and jobs you priced and fixed at your own cost.
Employment status: the question underneath
Whether IR35 applies or not, everything turns on employment status. HMRC may regard someone as self-employed for tax even if their status in employment law is different, and getting status wrong can mean unpaid tax and penalties for both sides[5]. The signs of genuine self-employment that GOV.UK lists will be familiar to anyone in the trade[5]:
| Points towards self-employed | Points towards employed |
|---|---|
| Quotes or bids for work | Paid a day rate whatever the job |
| Works without direct supervision | Told how, when and where to work |
| Sends invoices for work done | Paid through a timesheet like staff |
| Pays own tax and National Insurance | Works only for one firm, long term |
| No holiday or sick pay | Uses the firm's van, tools and uniform |
| Contract for services | Cannot send a substitute |
No single factor decides it. HMRC's Check Employment Status for Tax tool gives a view on a specific engagement and is worth running and saving for each long-running arrangement. Our guide to employment status for subcontractors goes into the employment law side, including holiday pay claims.
Where CIS fits in
CIS and IR35 are separate systems. CIS covers construction work including installing heating, water and ventilation systems[6], and decides how much a contractor deducts from a subcontractor's payments: 20% if registered and verified, 30% if not[7]. Being registered for CIS does not make someone self-employed, and paying through CIS does not protect you if the person is really an employee.
On each monthly CIS return the contractor declares that the subcontractors listed are not employees. If you are not confident about that for someone you use every week, act on the doubt rather than signing the declaration each month. Moving them onto payroll costs more, as our guide to what an employee really costs shows, but it is cheaper than a status dispute with HMRC.
Decision guide for a small plumbing firm
Is the worker a sole trader or a company?
If they invoice in their own name, IR35 does not apply; check employment status directly. If they invoice through a limited company, go to the next step.
Are you passing the work up to a large client?
If you supply the engineer to a larger client through your firm, that client's rules and its status statement may come into play. Ask before the job starts.
Check the reality, not the paperwork
Whatever the contract says, look at how the work is done: control, substitution, equipment and financial risk.
Record what you decided
Keep a short note, the status tool result and the contract on file, and review it if the arrangement changes.
Example: one engineer, two engagements
Example (fictional): Ravi is a gas engineer who trades through his own limited company. On Mondays to Wednesdays he works for a three-van heating firm in Reading, pricing his own boiler swaps, using his own van and tools and correcting faults at his own cost. The heating firm is a small client, so Ravi's company decides whether the rules apply, and it concludes they do not.
Example: on Thursdays and Fridays he works on a long refurbishment contract for a national facilities company, which is a large client. It issues a Status Determination Statement. Ravi works set hours under a supervisor, on a day rate, with no right to send a substitute, and the statement concludes the rules apply to that engagement. Payments for that work are made after deductions of tax and National Insurance, while his small-client work is unaffected.
If your own company makes the call
When you work through your own limited company for small clients, your company decides whether the rules apply to each engagement. That is a responsibility, not a formality. If the rules apply, your company has to account for the extra tax and National Insurance through a deemed employment payment, so the decision affects real money.
- Review each engagement separately. A fixed-price install for one firm and a rolling day-rate arrangement for another can reach different answers.
- Write down your reasoning when the engagement starts, with the facts about control, substitution, equipment and risk.
- Rerun the check if the arrangement drifts, for example when a three-week job becomes a nine-month placement.
- Ask your accountant to review any engagement where you are unsure, before you invoice rather than after the year end.
Practical tips
- Write contracts that reflect how the work is really done, and then do the work that way.
- Price jobs, not days, where you can. Fixed-price work with responsibility for putting faults right is a strong sign of being in business on your own account.
- Use your own van, tools and insurance if you want to be treated as independent.
- Avoid one-client arrangements that last years unless you are comfortable with the status position.
- Keep cash flow in mind: deductions under IR35 or at the higher CIS rate change what lands in your account. See cash flow for plumbing firms.
Frequently asked questions
Does IR35 apply to sole trader plumbers?
No. IR35 applies when a worker provides services through an intermediary such as their own limited company. A sole trader's position is decided by the normal employment status rules.
Who decides IR35 status for a small building firm?
If the client is a small private-sector business, the worker's own company decides whether the off-payroll rules apply. Medium and large clients make the decision themselves.
Does paying someone under CIS mean they are self-employed?
No. CIS sets the deduction rate; it does not decide employment status. Look at how the work is actually done.
What is a Status Determination Statement?
The written decision a medium or large client must give on whether the off-payroll rules apply to an engagement, with its reasons, passed to the worker and the party it contracts with.
References
HM Revenue & Customs (GOV.UK) (2026). Understanding off-payroll working (IR35) (opens in a new tab) ↑
HM Revenue & Customs (GOV.UK) (2024). Off-payroll working rules for clients (opens in a new tab) ↑
Office for National Statistics (Nomis) (2026). UK Business Counts - enterprises by industry and employment size band (SIC 2007 class 43.22), via Nomis (opens in a new tab) ↑
Office for National Statistics (Nomis) (2026). UK Business Counts - enterprises by industry and employment size band (SIC 2007 class 43.22), via Nomis (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (2026). Employment status: self-employed and contractor (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (2026). What is the Construction Industry Scheme (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (2026). What you must do as a CIS subcontractor: get paid (opens in a new tab) ↑