Staffing training

Employee, worker or self-employed: getting status right

How to tell whether a plumbing subbie is an employee, a worker or genuinely self-employed, the rights at stake, the CIS link and the paperwork to keep.

Ava research teamPublished 6 min read

On this page
  1. Why status matters more in plumbing than most trades
  2. The three categories
  3. The questions a tribunal or HMRC would ask
  4. Status and CIS are different questions
  5. Where firms get caught
  6. What getting it wrong can cost
  7. Paperwork that matches genuine self-employment
  8. Reviewing your current subbies
  9. Example: the subbie who became an employee
  10. Getting help
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • Status depends on how the relationship works in practice, not on what the paperwork calls it.
  • Workers get the minimum wage, paid holiday and rest breaks, but not unfair dismissal protection or redundancy pay[1].
  • Being registered for CIS settles how tax is deducted, not whether someone is self-employed[2].
  • Close to half of UK plumbers and heating installers are self-employed, so most firms deal with this question every week[3].
  • Review long-standing subbies once a year: a two-day arrangement can drift into a full-time job without anyone noticing.

Why status matters more in plumbing than most trades

Plumbing and heating has an unusually large self-employed workforce. About 71,200 UK plumbers and heating and ventilating installers were self-employed in the year to June 2026, against about 77,400 employees[3][4]. Across the whole economy, 74% of private sector businesses had no employees besides the owners at the start of 2026[5]. Many firms grow by bringing in subbies on day rates or price work, and many engineers prefer it that way.

UK private sector businesses by whether they employ staff, start of 2026
UK private sector businesses by whether they employ staff, start of 2026Donut chart. No employees besides the owners: 74%; With employees: 26%.No employees besides the owners: 74%With employees: 26%5.6 million businesses
  • No employees besides the owners 74%
  • With employees 26%

Source: Department for Business and Trade (GOV.UK), 2026[5]

Show the data
ItemValue
No employees besides the owners74%
With employees26%

The trouble is that status is decided by what really happens, not by the label on an invoice. A subbie who works only for you, five days a week, in your van, on jobs your office books, wearing your uniform, may legally be a worker or even an employee. If that is the case, they may be owed holiday pay, the minimum wage for all hours worked and other rights, and you may face tax and National Insurance questions.

The three categories

Employment status in brief
StatusTypical signsMain rights
EmployeeWorks under a contract of employment, set hours, your control, no right to send a substituteAll worker rights plus unfair dismissal protection, statutory notice, redundancy pay and family leave rights
WorkerMust do the work personally, limited right to send someone else, you must have work for them while the arrangement lasts[1]Minimum wage, paid holiday, rest breaks, 48-hour average limit, protection from discrimination and for whistleblowing[1]
Self-employedIn business on their own account, takes financial risk, can send a substitute, works for several clientsFew employment rights; protected by their own contracts and health and safety law

GOV.UK says someone is generally a worker if they have a contract or other arrangement to do work or services personally for a reward[1]. Workers usually do not get minimum notice periods, protection against unfair dismissal, the right to request flexible working, time off for emergencies or statutory redundancy pay[1]. Employees get those too.

The questions a tribunal or HMRC would ask

  1. Personal service: must this person do the work, or could they send another qualified engineer in their place and pay them?
  2. Control: who decides how, when and where the work is done? Do you set their hours and allocate their jobs day by day?
  3. Obligation: are you expected to offer work and are they expected to accept it?
  4. Financial risk: do they price jobs, fix mistakes at their own cost and risk losing money?
  5. Equipment: whose van, tools and test equipment do they use?
  6. Integration: do customers see them as part of your firm, in your uniform and livery?
  7. Other clients: do they work for anyone else, advertise their own business and carry their own insurance?

No single answer decides it. A subbie who uses their own van but works only for you under daily direction may still be a worker. One who wears your branded polo on your jobs but quotes each job, works for three other firms and can send a colleague is probably self-employed. Look at the whole picture, and look at it as it is now, not as it was when the arrangement started.

Status and CIS are different questions

The Construction Industry Scheme covers installing systems for heating, lighting, power, water and ventilation, so most plumbing and heating subcontract work falls under it[2]. Contractors deduct 20% from a registered subcontractor's payments and 30% if the subcontractor is not registered or cannot be verified[6]. Many owners treat CIS registration as proof of self-employment. It is not. CIS decides how tax is deducted from payments for construction work; employment status decides what rights the person has and whether they should be on PAYE.

20% / 30%

CIS deduction for registered and for unregistered or unverified subcontractors[6]

Verify each subcontractor with HMRC before the first payment, keep the verification reference and issue monthly statements. If you have decided someone is really an employee, take them out of CIS and put them on the payroll.

Where firms get caught

  • The permanent subbie: same person, same days, every week, for years.
  • The 'self-employed apprentice': a trainee on a day rate who is told where to be and what to do.
  • Day rates with no right to refuse: if turning work down means losing the arrangement, obligation looks mutual.
  • Firm-supplied everything: van, fuel card, phone, uniform, tools, stock and certificates in your name.
  • Holiday never paid: if the person is a worker, they have built up paid leave entitlement for every period worked.

Other duties do not wait for a status ruling. Since April 2022, PPE duties have covered limb (b) workers as well as employees[7], and health and safety law protects everyone on your jobs whatever their status.

What getting it wrong can cost

If someone you treated as self-employed is found to be a worker, the usual claim is for holiday pay. A worker builds up paid leave for every period they work, and if it was never offered or paid, the backlog can be large. Minimum wage is the next risk: if a day rate is spread across long days including travel between jobs, the effective hourly rate may fall below the legal minimum for some weeks. If the person is found to be an employee, unfair dismissal, notice and redundancy rights come into play when the arrangement ends.

Tax is a separate exposure. If HMRC decides that someone paid gross or through CIS should have been on PAYE, the firm can be asked for the income tax and National Insurance that should have been deducted, plus interest. The engineer may also have paid tax through self-assessment, which makes the unwinding complicated. None of this happens often to firms that review status honestly, which is the point of doing it.

Paperwork that matches genuine self-employment

  • A written agreement for each job or programme of work, with a price or day rate and a clear scope.
  • A right to send a suitably qualified substitute, which the subcontractor has actually used or could use.
  • Invoices from the subcontractor's own business, with their own business name and details.
  • Their own public liability insurance, tools, test equipment and, ideally, van.
  • Evidence that they work for other clients and can turn work down without penalty.
  • CIS verification records and monthly statements for every payment.

Paperwork that does not match reality does not help. A substitution clause that nobody would ever use, or a business name invented for the invoice, will not survive a close look. Make the arrangement real first, then document it.

Reviewing your current subbies

  1. List everyone you pay through CIS

    Include days worked per month over the last year and whether they worked for anyone else.

  2. Apply the questions

    Go through the questions above for each person and note the answers honestly, with evidence.

  3. Sort into three groups

    Clearly self-employed, unclear, and probably worker or employee.

  4. Fix the unclear group

    Either change how you work with them, so they genuinely run their own business, or offer them a contract of employment.

  5. Paper the genuine ones

    Use a subcontractor agreement that reflects reality: job-by-job quotes, substitution rights, their own insurance and tools.

  6. Repeat yearly

    Arrangements drift. Put a review date in the diary and repeat it every year.

Example: the subbie who became an employee

Example (fictional): Dan has invoiced a heating firm in Norwich every week for three years. He works Monday to Friday, drives a liveried firm van, takes jobs from the office diary and has never sent anyone in his place. After a review, the owner offers Dan employment on a salary that matches his average day-rate earnings less the costs he no longer carries. Dan accepts because he gets paid holiday, sick pay and a pension. A second subbie, who quotes per job and works for two other firms, keeps his arrangement under a fresh subcontractor agreement.

Getting help

HMRC's online employment status tool gives a view for tax purposes, and Acas can explain employment rights. For anything borderline, or a claim already made, speak to an employment solicitor. Status cases turn on facts, and a short conversation early is cheaper than a tribunal claim or an HMRC enquiry later. If you are weighing up which model to grow with, our comparison of subcontractors and employees sets out the costs side by side.

Frequently asked questions

Does a CIS registration make someone self-employed?

No. CIS sets how tax is deducted from payments for construction work. Employment status depends on how the relationship works in practice.

What rights does a worker have?

Workers get the minimum wage, paid holiday, rest breaks, the 48-hour average limit and protection against discrimination, but usually not unfair dismissal protection or redundancy pay.

Can a subbie wear our uniform and still be self-employed?

Possibly. Uniform is one factor among many. Control, personal service, financial risk and other clients matter more.

References

  1. GOV.UK (2026). Employment status: worker (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. GOV.UK (2026). What is the Construction Industry Scheme (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Office for National Statistics (Nomis) (2026). Annual Population Survey - regional - occupation (SOC2020) by sex by employment type, via Nomis (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Office for National Statistics (Nomis) (2026). Annual Population Survey - regional - occupation (SOC2020) by sex by employment type, via Nomis (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Department for Business and Trade (GOV.UK) (2026). Business population estimates for the UK and regions 2026: statistical release (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. GOV.UK (2026). What you must do as a CIS subcontractor: get paid (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. Health and Safety Executive (2022). Personal Protective Equipment at Work (Amendment) Regulations 2022 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo