Staffing training

Right to work checks for new hires: a guide for heating firms

How to run a right to work check on a new engineer or office hire: manual, share code and ID service checks, what to keep, and the penalties.

Ava research teamPublished 6 min read

On this page
  1. What the law expects
  2. Three ways to check
  3. The manual check, step by step
  4. Where the check fits in your hiring process
  5. Asking for the check without causing offence
  6. What it costs to get wrong
  7. Follow-up checks and good records
  8. Common mistakes in small firms
  9. Example: the Monday start that nearly went wrong
  10. Subcontractors, agency labour and trial days
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • Check every new starter before they start work, not on day three when the paperwork turns up[1].
  • A correct check gives you a defence: you will not pay the civil penalty if you can show you made it[2].
  • The civil penalty can reach £60,000 for each illegal worker, and knowingly employing one is a crime[2].
  • Keep a dated copy for the whole employment and for 2 years after it ends[1].
  • Check everyone the same way. Picking people out by accent or name is discrimination.

What the law expects

You must check that a job applicant is allowed to work for you in the UK before you employ them[1]. That applies to an apprentice, an office coordinator and a gas engineer alike. The check is not only a duty, it is your protection: if you can show you made the correct checks, you will not have to pay the civil penalty, even if the person later turns out not to have had the right to work[2].

Small firms are exposed because hiring is hard and starts are rushed. In 2025, 45% of construction SME employers said recruitment and skills were an obstacle to their business[3], and in a sector where about 95% of plumbing and heating enterprises have fewer than ten employees[4], there is rarely an HR department to catch a missed step. Build the check into the offer process so it cannot be skipped.

Three ways to check

Pick the method that fits the candidate's documents
MethodBest forWhat you keep
Manual check of original documentsAnyone, including British and Irish citizensA copy of each document and the date you checked[1]
Online check with a share codePeople with digital immigration status, such as a visa or settled statusThe online result, saved with the date
Identity service provider (IDVT)British and Irish citizens with a valid passport, when you hire remotelyThe provider's report, saved with the date

British and Irish citizens cannot get an online share code to prove their right to work[1]. For them you either check original documents or use an identity service provider. Candidates with digital status give you a share code instead, and you check it online. Ask candidates which applies to them in the offer letter so nobody turns up on day one with the wrong thing.

The manual check, step by step

  1. Obtain the originals

    Ask to see the applicant's original documents from the acceptable list. Photocopies, phone photos and scans sent by email do not count.

  2. Check them with the applicant present

    Check the documents are valid while the person is with you[1]. Compare photos with the person, dates of birth across documents and any expiry dates.

  3. Copy and date

    Make a clear copy of each document and record the date you made the check[1]. For a passport, copy the photo page. Write 'Right to work checked on [date] by [name]' on the copy or in the file note.

  4. Store it securely

    Keep copies during the employment and for 2 years after the person leaves[1]. Store them with the HR file, not in the shared job folder engineers can see.

  5. Diary any follow-up

    If the permission is time-limited, put the expiry date in the diary with a reminder at least a month ahead.

Where the check fits in your hiring process

  1. Advert and interview: say in the advert that all offers depend on a right to work check, so it is no surprise later.
  2. Conditional offer: send the offer with the standard script and a list of what to bring or send.
  3. Check: complete it at least two working days before the start date, so a problem can be sorted without cancelling jobs.
  4. File: save the copy, the date and the checker's name in the person's HR folder the same day.
  5. Release to the diary: only then add the new starter to the job schedule, van rota and engineer app.
  6. Diary the expiry: if the permission is time-limited, set the follow-up reminder before you close the file.

Putting the check before diary access matters more than it sounds. In a busy week the temptation is always to let someone start and sort the paperwork later. If the diary system or the office manager simply cannot add an engineer without a filed check, the shortcut disappears.

Asking for the check without causing offence

Most problems with right to work checks are not legal ones. They are awkward conversations where a candidate feels singled out. The answer is a standard script used for everyone, written into your offer email.

Script: 'Before anyone starts with us we check their right to work in the UK. We do this for every new starter. Please bring your original passport, or if you have a visa or settled status, send us a share code from the GOV.UK service. We will take a copy and keep it securely with your employment records.'

You must not discriminate against anyone because of where they are from[1]. Do the check at the same stage for every applicant, normally after the conditional offer. Never refuse to consider someone because they have time-limited permission, and never ask only the candidates you think are foreign.

What it costs to get wrong

£60,000

Maximum civil penalty for each illegal worker[2]

The penalty is set per worker, so two people on an install gang means two penalties. Knowingly employing someone without the right to work is a criminal offence that can lead to 5 years in prison and an unlimited fine[2]. To put the civil penalty in context, it is more than a year and a half of pay for the median employee plumber, whose gross annual pay was £37,794 in 2026[5].

Penalty for one illegal worker against a year's payPenalty from GOV.UK; pay from ONS ASHE 2026 provisional (reference R5).
Penalty for one illegal worker against a year's payComparison. Maximum civil penalty per illegal worker: £60,000; Median annual pay, employee plumber (2026): £37,794.£60,000Maximum civil penalty per illegal workerMaximum civil penalty per illegal worker: £60,000£37,794Median annual pay, employee plumber (2026)Median annual pay, employee plumber (2026): £37,794Penalty for one illegal worker against a year's payComparison. Maximum civil penalty per illegal worker: £60,000; Median annual pay, employee plumber (2026): £37,794.£60,000Maximum civil penalty per illegalworkerMaximum civil penalty per illegal worker: £60,000£37,794Median annual pay, employee plumber(2026)Median annual pay, employee plumber (2026): £37,794

Source: GOV.UK (Home Office), 2026[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
Maximum civil penalty per illegal worker£60,000
Median annual pay, employee plumber (2026)£37,794

Follow-up checks and good records

If your employee's right to work is time-limited, you must check their documents again when it is due to expire[1]. This is where small firms slip, because the expiry may be two or three years after the start date, long after anyone remembers. Put every expiry date in the same place as van MOT and insurance renewals, where somebody looks every week.

  • One HR folder per person with the check, the date and who did it.
  • A single list of time-limited permissions with expiry dates and reminder dates.
  • A rule that nobody starts, even for a trial day, until the check is filed.
  • A named person responsible, with a deputy for holidays.
  • A note of the method used, so a later reviewer can see the check was the right one.

Common mistakes in small firms

  • Accepting a photo of a passport sent by text message instead of seeing the original.
  • Checking the document but not recording the date, so the check cannot be proved later.
  • Keeping copies only in an engineer's email or on a personal phone.
  • Re-hiring a former employee without doing a fresh check.
  • Assuming that a CSCS, JIB or Gas Safe card proves the right to work. Trade cards prove competence, not immigration status.
  • Doing a check on some new starters and not others, which invites a discrimination complaint.

None of these needs software to fix. A one-page checklist in the HR folder, signed by whoever did the check, covers most of them.

Example: the Monday start that nearly went wrong

Example (fictional): a heating firm in Bristol takes on an improver for a busy fortnight of boiler swaps. He is asked to start on Monday and bring his passport. On Monday the van leaves at 7.15 and the passport is forgotten. The owner lets him go out anyway, planning to check on Wednesday. If the improver had no right to work, the firm would have no statutory excuse for those days.

The fix the owner adopted: the offer email now asks for documents or a share code before the start date, the office does the check at least two working days before the first shift, and the diary software will not release a job to a new name until a box marked 'RTW filed' is ticked. The cost of the change was one email template and ten minutes a hire.

Subcontractors, agency labour and trial days

The duty described here applies to people you employ. Trial days count: if someone is working for you, check first. For agency workers, the agency is usually the employer, but ask in writing what checks they have done. If you use labour-only subcontractors, read the current GOV.UK guidance on who must be checked, and consider asking for evidence anyway as a condition of your subcontractor agreement. It costs little and protects you if the person's status is ever questioned, which matters given how many engineers work as subcontractors.

Frequently asked questions

When must I do a right to work check?

Before the person starts working for you, including any paid trial day. A check done after the start does not protect you for the days already worked.

Can British citizens give me a share code?

No. British and Irish citizens cannot get a share code. Check their original documents or use an identity service provider.

How long should I keep the copies?

For the whole employment and for 2 years after the person stops working for you.

Do I need to check again later?

Yes, if the person's permission is time-limited. Check again before it expires and keep the new copy.

References

  1. GOV.UK (Home Office) (2026). Check a job applicant's right to work (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. GOV.UK (Home Office) (2026). Penalties for employing illegal workers (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Department for Business and Trade (GOV.UK) (2025). Longitudinal Small Business Survey 2025: SME employers (businesses with 1 to 249 employees) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Office for National Statistics (Nomis) (2026). UK Business Counts - enterprises by industry and employment size band (SIC 2007 class 43.22), via Nomis (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Office for National Statistics (2026). Annual Survey of Hours and Earnings 2026 provisional, Table 14 (occupation by 4-digit SOC 2020) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo