Key takeaways
- Public liability pays for injury and damage. A system that simply fails to heat the house as promised is a design claim, which is what professional indemnity covers.
- Heat pumps raise the stakes: the median installed cost of an air-to-water heat pump under the Boiler Upgrade Scheme was £12,826 in mid-2026[1].
- If you carry out heat loss calculations, size emitters or give running cost estimates, you are giving professional advice that customers rely on.
- Avoid fitness-for-purpose clauses where you can. PI policies are built around a duty of reasonable skill and care.
Where design liability comes from
Most plumbers think of liability in terms of leaks and fires. Those are public liability risks: physical damage to someone else's property or injury to a person. Design liability is different. It arises when a customer relies on your advice or calculations and loses money because they were wrong, even though nothing was damaged.
A like-for-like boiler swap carries little design risk. The old boiler showed what the house needed, and a modern condensing boiler has plenty of headroom. Heat pumps change that. The installer usually surveys the house, calculates room-by-room heat loss, chooses a unit size, sets a design flow temperature, checks or replaces emitters, sizes the cylinder and often gives the customer an estimate of running costs. Each step is a professional judgement the customer cannot check for themselves.
When the system underperforms, the complaint is rarely that a joint leaked. It is that the bedrooms never reach temperature, the bills are higher than forecast, or the unit was too small for the house. Those are claims for financial loss caused by negligent advice or design. Every service contract includes a duty to act with reasonable care and skill[2], and a design that falls below that standard is a breach.
Why heat pumps raise the stakes
The work is growing fast, and each job is large. By the end of September 2026 there had been 160,874 Boiler Upgrade Scheme voucher applications, 98% of them for air-to-water heat pumps[3]. The median installed cost of an air-to-water heat pump under the scheme was £12,826 in July to September 2026[1], against a standard grant of £7,500[4]. A customer who has put several thousand pounds of their own money into a system that does not work has every reason to pursue the installer.
Most of these jobs are replacing fossil fuel systems. More than half of scheme-funded installations replaced gas, and nearly a fifth replaced oil[5]. That means the customer has a clear before-and-after comparison: they know what their old system cost to run and how warm the house felt.
The workforce designing these systems is also new. Just under 10,000 people completed a recognised heat pump training qualification in 2024, 15% more than the year before[6]. MCS notifications made up 60% of UK heat pump sales that year[7], so a large share of installs are designed by firms working under a certification scheme for the first few years.
Which policy answers which claim
| What went wrong | Type of loss | Policy that usually responds |
|---|---|---|
| Pipe joint fails and floods the kitchen | Damage to property | Public liability |
| Engineer trips a customer over a hose | Injury | Public liability |
| Heat pump too small, rooms never reach temperature | Financial loss from design | Professional indemnity |
| Running cost estimate far too low | Financial loss from advice | Professional indemnity, if the estimate was negligent |
| Emitters undersized, customer pays to replace them | Financial loss from design | Professional indemnity |
| Apprentice injured on site | Injury to an employee | Employers' liability |
| Installer's tools stolen from the van | Your own property | Tools or van cover |
Some trade insurance packages include a small amount of PI cover, often limited to advice given alongside your installation work. Read the wording. Look for whether it covers design you carry out yourself, design you sub-contract, and calculations made in software, and whether the limit is per claim or for the whole year.
Deciding whether you need PI
- You probably need it if you produce heat loss calculations, choose unit sizes, design hot water systems, or sign off designs under a certification scheme.
- You probably need it if you give written running cost or savings estimates as part of a quote.
- You need it if a contract demands it. Housing associations, councils, developers and main contractors often ask for PI as well as public liability on design-and-install packages.
- Your exposure is lower if a manufacturer, consultant or main contractor produces the design and you install exactly to it. Keep that design on file and check the contract does not make you responsible for it.
- Your exposure is lowest on like-for-like boiler and cylinder replacements where you give no performance promise.
PI is written on a claims-made basis. The policy in force when the claim is made responds, not the one in force when you did the design. If you stop designing or retire, ask about run-off cover.
Cut design risk before it becomes a claim
Survey properly and record it
Measure rooms, note wall, floor and roof construction, glazing and ventilation, and photograph anything you have assumed. A claim often turns on whether the survey was done or guessed.
Use the recognised method
Follow the calculation method required by your certification scheme and keep the full output, not just the summary figure.
Write down your assumptions
Design outdoor temperature, target room temperatures, flow temperature, occupancy and hot water use. Give the customer a copy in plain language.
Present running costs as a range
Base estimates on stated tariffs and usage, say what would change them, and avoid promising savings.
Get sign-off on compromises
If the customer refuses a larger radiator or a cylinder location, record that you advised it and they declined.
Commission and hand over
Record flow temperatures and settings, explain controls, and leave written guidance. Many underperformance complaints are about controls, not design.
Questions to put to a PI insurer or broker
PI wordings vary more than public liability wordings, and a cheap policy that excludes the work you actually do is worth very little. Ask these questions in writing before you buy, and keep the replies with the schedule.
- Does the policy cover design I carry out myself, design I sub-contract to a consultant, and design produced by manufacturer software that I sign off?
- Are heat pumps, hybrid systems, underfloor heating and hot water design all named or clearly within the description of my business?
- Is the limit per claim or in the aggregate for the year, and are defence costs inside or on top of it?
- What is the excess, and does it apply to defence costs as well as settlements?
- Is there retroactive cover for designs I produced before this policy started?
- Are claims under fitness-for-purpose clauses, liquidated damages or collateral warranties excluded?
- What happens if I stop designing or close the business, and what does run-off cover cost to arrange?
Tell the insurer about any complaint you already know about. Failing to disclose a known problem when you buy the policy is one of the surest ways to have a later claim refused.
Watch the contract wording
Design-and-install contracts sometimes say the system must be fit for purpose or achieve stated temperatures in all conditions. That is a stricter promise than the reasonable care and skill the law normally implies[2], and many PI policies exclude liability you take on by contract beyond that standard. Ask to change absolute wording to a duty of reasonable skill and care, and make sure any performance figures are tied to your stated design assumptions.
Be careful too with collateral warranties and net contribution clauses on larger commercial jobs. If you are asked to sign one, send it to your broker before you sign. A clause you cannot insure is a risk you carry personally.
Example: the cold back bedroom
Example. An installer fits an air source heat pump in a 1930s semi. The survey records cavity walls as filled, based on what the owner said. In the first cold snap, the rear bedroom struggles to pass 16°C. A surveyor instructed by the owner finds the cavity was never filled on that elevation and that the existing radiator in that room was kept because the installer judged it large enough.
The owner claims the cost of a larger radiator, extra pipework and redecoration. The installer's PI insurer reviews the file. The survey notes show the cavity fill was taken from the customer's word, not checked, and the radiator was not re-sized. The insurer settles on a modest sum. The installer adds a borescope check of wall construction to every survey and now re-sizes every emitter rather than relying on judgement. Public liability would not have paid this claim, because nothing was damaged.
Putting it together
For a firm doing repairs and like-for-like replacements, public liability plus employers' liability for any staff is the core. Once you design systems, especially heat pumps, PI moves from optional to sensible. Compare the cost against the value of a single failed design, not against your annual premium for other covers.
Keep your design files for as long as a claim could be brought. If a dispute does arise over performance, a calm written response backed by your survey and calculations is your best defence, and our guide to using the small claims court explains what happens when a customer withholds the final payment over a performance complaint. If your vans carry expensive kit and test equipment, also look at van and tools cover.
Frequently asked questions
Does public liability insurance cover heat pump design mistakes?
Usually not. Public liability covers injury and damage to property. A system that is undersized or costs more to run than forecast is a financial loss from design or advice, which is professional indemnity territory.
Is professional indemnity insurance compulsory for heating installers?
No law requires it, but contracts and frameworks often do. If you design systems or give performance estimates, it is sensible cover even where nobody asks for it.
What does claims-made mean on a PI policy?
The policy in force when the claim is first made against you responds, not the one in force when you did the design. If you stop trading, ask your broker about run-off cover for past work.
How do I reduce the risk of a heat pump design claim?
Survey thoroughly, use the method your certification scheme requires, record every assumption, give running costs as a range, get written sign-off when customers decline your advice, and hand over clearly.
References
Department for Energy Security and Net Zero (2026). Boiler Upgrade Scheme (BUS) monthly statistics: England and Wales, September 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 49 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Department for Energy Security and Net Zero (2026). Boiler Upgrade Scheme (BUS) monthly statistics: England and Wales, September 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (2026). Apply for the Boiler Upgrade Scheme: what you can get (opens in a new tab) ↑
Department for Energy Security and Net Zero (2026). Boiler Upgrade Scheme (BUS) monthly statistics: England and Wales, September 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Heating and Hotwater Industry Council (HHIC) (2024). Bumper year for UK heat pumps (opens in a new tab) ↑
Heating and Hotwater Industry Council (HHIC) (2024). Bumper year for UK heat pumps (opens in a new tab) ↑