Regulation compliance

Employers' liability insurance: the legal requirement

When employers' liability cover is compulsory for a plumbing firm, how apprentices and labour-only subcontractors count, the minimum cover and the fines.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. The rule in plain terms
  2. Who counts as your employee
  3. Labour-only subcontractors: the trade's grey area
  4. Apprentices, family, students and directors
  5. How much cover and what the certificate must show
  6. Penalties, and why old certificates matter
  7. If an employee is injured at work
  8. First hire checklist
  9. Example: the busy winter and the borrowed mate
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References

Key takeaways

  • Once you employ anyone under a contract of service or apprenticeship, employers' liability insurance of at least £5 million is compulsory[1].
  • Tax status does not decide it. A labour-only subcontractor you control, equip and pay by the day may count as your employee for this law[1].
  • You can be fined up to £2,500 for every day without proper cover, and up to £1,000 for not displaying the certificate[2].
  • Keep old certificates even though the law no longer requires it: industrial disease claims can surface decades later.

The rule in plain terms

The Employers' Liability (Compulsory Insurance) Act 1969 requires employers to insure against their liability for injury or disease suffered by their employees at work. The insurer must be authorised, the cover must be at least £5 million, and you must display a copy of the certificate where staff can read it[1]. The Health and Safety Executive enforces the law and inspectors can ask to see your certificate.

Many plumbers never need it, because they work alone. Around 48% of UK plumbers and heating and ventilating installers, about 71,200 people, were self-employed in the year to June 2026[3]. The rest are employees of someone, and most of those employers are small: about 95% of registered plumbing and heating enterprises have fewer than 10 employees[4]. The moment a sole trader takes on a first apprentice, improver or mate, the question becomes real.

Plumbers and heating installers by employment typeUK, July 2025 to June 2026, approximate shares
Plumbers and heating installers by employment typeDonut chart. Self-employed: 48%; Employees: 52%.Self-employed: 48%Employees: 52%71,200 self-employed
  • Self-employed 48%
  • Employees 52%

Source: Office for National Statistics (Nomis), 2026[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
Self-employed48%
Employees52%

Who counts as your employee

The law is about the real relationship, not the label. The HSE guide says it does not matter whether you call someone employed or self-employed, or what their tax status is[1]. What matters is how much control you have over the work and the nature of the arrangement. You may need cover for someone where:

  • you deduct tax and National Insurance from what you pay them;
  • you decide where and when they work and how they do it;
  • you supply their materials and equipment;
  • you keep the profit from the work they do;
  • they must do the work themselves and cannot send a substitute;
  • they are treated the same as your other staff.

You may not need cover where the person works for other firms too, brings most of their own tools and materials, is clearly in business on their own account and can send a substitute[1]. Even then, the HSE warns that someone self-employed for tax purposes may still be an employee for this law.

Labour-only subcontractors: the trade's grey area

Plumbing and heating firms rely on labour-only help when work is busy. These workers are usually paid under the Construction Industry Scheme, with 20% deducted if they are registered and 30% if they are not[5]. Being paid under CIS tells you how to handle their tax. It does not tell you whether your employers' liability policy has to cover them.

How common trade arrangements usually fall under the employers' liability rules, based on the HSE guide.
ArrangementLikely positionWhat to do
Mate paid a day rate, uses your van and tools, follows your instructionsLikely an employee for EL purposesDeclare them to your insurer and include them in your EL cover
Experienced plumber on CIS, brings own tools, sets own method, works for several firmsLikely independentGet a copy of their own public liability and EL certificates
Subcontract firm sending its own staffTheir employer insures themCheck their EL certificate before work starts
Apprentice on a formal apprenticeshipCovered by the ActMust be insured
Family member helping out, business not a limited companyMay be exemptCheck the exemption applies to every person you employ

Most insurers ask about labour-only workers at quote stage and price for them. Tell the truth. Undeclared labour is a common reason for a dispute over cover when someone is injured.

Apprentices, family, students and directors

  • Apprentices: the Act covers anyone employed under a contract of apprenticeship, so a plumbing apprentice must be insured from day one[1].
  • Family businesses: if everyone you employ is a close relative, such as a spouse, civil partner, parent, child or sibling, you may be exempt. The exemption does not apply if the business is a limited company[1].
  • One-person companies: a company that employs only its owner, where that person owns 50% or more of the shares, does not need cover[1]. Take on a second employee and that changes.
  • Students and work experience: unpaid students and school pupils on work experience are usually covered by an existing policy without telling the insurer, but talk to your insurer for long placements or unusual work[1].
  • Staff based abroad: the GOV.UK guidance says cover is not needed if you only employ someone based outside England, Scotland and Wales[2].

How much cover and what the certificate must show

The legal minimum is £5 million, and that figure includes legal costs, so a serious claim can eat into it quickly. In practice, the HSE notes, most insurers offer at least £10 million[1]. If a main contractor or framework asks for a higher figure, that becomes your working minimum.

Your insurer issues a certificate when you take out or renew the policy. It must state the level of cover and the companies covered. Since October 2008 you have been allowed to display it electronically, as long as staff know where to find it and can reach it easily[1]. For a firm whose engineers are always out, a copy in the shared job app or staff portal works, with a printed copy in the office or the van.

Penalties, and why old certificates matter

You can be fined up to £2,500 for each day you are not properly insured, and up to £1,000 if you fail to display the certificate or refuse to show it to an inspector[2]. Those are criminal penalties on top of the bigger risk: paying an injured employee's claim yourself.

There has been no legal duty to keep expired certificates since 2008, but the HSE strongly advises keeping a full record[1]. Some diseases appear decades after exposure. Asbestos is the obvious one in a trade that opens up old buildings, and a former employee may claim against the policy that was in force at the time. Keep every certificate, in digital form, for the life of the business and beyond.

If an employee is injured at work

How you act in the first few days affects both the injured person and the outcome of any claim. Write down what happened while it is fresh, and keep it factual.

  1. Get first aid or medical help and make the area safe before anything else.
  2. Record the date, time, place, task, who was there and what equipment was in use. Photograph the scene if it is safe to do so.
  3. Check whether the injury must be reported to the HSE under RIDDOR, for example a specified injury or an absence from normal work beyond the reporting threshold, and report within the time allowed.
  4. Enter it in your accident book, which must be kept by employers in most workplaces.
  5. Tell your insurer promptly, even if no claim has been made yet. Late notification can affect cover.
  6. Do not promise compensation or admit fault on behalf of the business. Let the insurer handle any claim.
  7. Review the risk assessment for that task and change the method if needed, then brief the rest of the team.

Look after the person as well as the paperwork. Keep in touch while they are off, plan a return to lighter duties if appropriate, and pay any Statutory Sick Pay they are entitled to on time.

First hire checklist

  1. Arrange cover before the start date

    Tell your insurer the role, expected wages and whether the person will do gas work, work at height or use power tools.

  2. Display the certificate

    Put it where the new starter can read it, or share it in your staff system and tell them where it is.

  3. Review your risk assessments

    Manual handling, hot works, confined spaces, asbestos awareness and lone working all matter more once someone else is on site.

  4. Check how you will pay them

    Set up PAYE for employees or verify CIS status for subcontractors. Do not let the tax route decide the insurance question.

  5. Diary renewals and keep records

    File every certificate permanently and update your insurer when headcount or wage roll changes.

Example: the busy winter and the borrowed mate

Example. A self-employed heating engineer with no staff takes on a friend for six weeks during the winter rush, paying a day rate under CIS. The friend travels in the engineer's van, uses his tools and does what he is told on each job. On week three, he injures his back lifting an old cast-iron boiler down a flight of stairs.

The engineer has public liability cover but no employers' liability, because he thought a CIS subcontractor did not need it. Looking at the HSE tests, the friend was controlled, equipped and paid by the day, so he was very likely an employee for this purpose. The engineer now faces the claim personally and a possible fine. A phone call to his insurer before week one would have added the cover.

Employers' liability sits alongside your other policies rather than replacing them. Your public liability insurance covers customers and the public, professional indemnity covers design and advice, and van and tools cover protects the kit your team relies on. If staff will be on call at night, also read our guide to working time rules for on-call engineers.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need employers' liability insurance if I only use subcontractors?

It depends on the real relationship. If you control their work, supply tools and materials and they cannot send a substitute, they may count as employees for this law even if they are paid under CIS. Ask your insurer and check the HSE guide.

Is employers' liability insurance compulsory for an apprentice?

Yes. The Act covers people employed under a contract of apprenticeship, so arrange cover before the apprentice starts.

What is the minimum employers' liability cover?

At least £5 million, including legal costs. Most insurers offer £10 million or more as standard.

Can I display my employers' liability certificate online?

Yes. Since October 2008 you can display it electronically, provided employees know where to find it and can access it easily.

References

  1. Health and Safety Executive (2012). Employers' Liability (Compulsory Insurance) Act 1969: a brief guide for employers (HSE40) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. GOV.UK (2026). Employers' liability insurance (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Office for National Statistics (Nomis) (2026). Annual Population Survey - regional - occupation (SOC2020) by sex by employment type, via Nomis (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Office for National Statistics (Nomis) (2026). UK Business Counts - enterprises by industry and employment size band (SIC 2007 class 43.22), via Nomis (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. GOV.UK (2026). What you must do as a CIS subcontractor: get paid (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo