Key takeaways
- ADR lets an independent body settle a complaint without court, usually faster and at lower cost for both sides.
- Since 6 April 2026, the DMCC Act 2024 requires you to tell a customer about any ADR you are obliged to use when you give them your answer to their complaint[1].
- The older 2015 ADR information rules were revoked on the same date[2], so update any complaints letters that still quote them.
- Decide in advance whether you will offer ADR, put it in your complaints procedure and use the same wording every time.
What ADR means for a plumbing or heating firm
Alternative dispute resolution, or ADR, covers any process where an independent person helps you and a customer settle a disagreement without going to court. For trades it usually means a scheme run by a trade association, a quality mark or a consumer code, or an independent mediation or adjudication service you choose to use.
Unlike energy suppliers or banks, plumbers and heating engineers have no single statutory ombudsman. That leaves each firm to decide how disputes end when its own complaints process has run out. Some firms have already made that decision without noticing: membership of certain trade bodies and renewable consumer codes commits members to use a named dispute service, so read your membership terms before assuming you are free to choose.
Disputes are not rare in this sector. A quarter of UK adults bought home maintenance and repair services in a year, and 11% of those buyers had a problem[3]. The median loss per problem, once time and stress were valued, was £109[4].
Source: Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (GOV.UK), 2021[3]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Adults who bought home maintenance and repair services | 25% |
| Of those buyers, share who had a problem | 11% |
What changed on 6 April 2026
For a decade, the information rules came from the 2015 ADR Regulations, which made traders name an ADR body when a complaint could not be settled. Those regulations were revoked on 6 April 2026 by the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024[2]. A new chapter of the DMCC Act now governs consumer ADR.
The duty that matters most to a small firm is in section 308[1]. When you tell a customer the outcome of your consideration of their complaint, you must also tell them about any ADR or other arrangement available to them if they are unhappy with that outcome. It applies where you are obliged to take part in that arrangement, whether by law, by your contract terms or by another agreement such as scheme membership. A trader who breaks the duty can be served with an enforcement notice.
Check your templates. Complaints letters, terms and website pages written before April 2026 may still quote the 2015 Regulations. Replace the old wording with a plain sentence about the scheme you actually use.
The main types of ADR
| Type | How it works | Is the outcome binding? | Where it suits a trade dispute |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mediation | A neutral mediator helps both sides reach their own agreement, often by phone | Only if both sides sign an agreement | Disagreements about price, delays or making good |
| Conciliation | Like mediation, but the conciliator may suggest terms | Only once both sides accept | Workmanship disputes where both sides want a quick end |
| Adjudication or expert determination | An independent expert reviews evidence and decides | Depends on the scheme rules | Technical questions about whether work was done properly |
| Arbitration | An arbitrator decides on the papers or at a hearing | Yes, under the Arbitration Act | Larger disputes where both sides agree to give up court |
| Ombudsman-style scheme | The scheme investigates and makes a finding | Often binding on the trader if the customer accepts | Firms whose trade body or code runs one |
Mediation is the most common starting point for small domestic jobs because it keeps both sides talking and is quick. An expert decision suits a genuine technical disagreement, such as whether a system was balanced properly or a pipe failed because of the installation.
Should your firm commit to a scheme?
There is no general legal requirement for a plumber to join an ADR scheme. If you are not obliged to use one, section 308 does not make you sign up[1]. Customers will still ask what happens next if they disagree with you, so decide your answer before the first difficult complaint lands.
- Join, or confirm you already belong, if you install renewables under a consumer code, sell to vulnerable customers, take large deposits or work on high-value refits.
- Consider it if your main competitors advertise an independent complaints route and customers compare you on trust.
- A one-off mediation offer can be enough for a small firm doing mostly repairs, as long as you state it clearly and keep to it.
- Check cost and process before you commit: who pays, how long it takes, whether you can respond in writing, and whether decisions bind you.
- Check your insurance. Some policies expect to be told before you accept liability or agree a settlement, so read the conditions on your public liability policy.
Putting ADR into your complaints process
Acknowledge quickly
Confirm you have the complaint, who is handling it and when the customer will hear from you. A short written acknowledgement on the day calms most situations.
Investigate with the job file
Read the quote, job sheet, photos and messages. If needed, offer a return visit by a different engineer so the customer sees a fresh pair of eyes.
Offer a remedy where it is due
Most service failures are settled by putting the work right or a partial refund. The law already expects reasonable care and skill[5], so start from that test.
Send a written outcome
Say what you found, what you will do and why. This is the point at which section 308 bites, so include the ADR paragraph if you are obliged to use a scheme.
Log it
Record dates, outcome and any ADR referral in your complaints log, then fix the cause. Your complaints handling procedure should say who does each step.
Sample wording for the outcome letter: "If you are not happy with this response, you can refer your complaint to [scheme name], an independent dispute resolution service we are a member of. It costs you nothing to use. Contact them at [website] or [phone], quoting reference [number]." Only include the cost sentence if it is true for your scheme.
Example: the radiator balancing dispute
Example. A heating firm fits a new system boiler and three radiators. The customer says two upstairs rooms never get warm and refuses to pay the final third of the invoice. The firm revisits, finds the system balanced to its own readings and sends a written outcome explaining the results, offering one more visit, and naming the mediation service its trade body provides.
The customer refers the case. The mediator speaks to both sides by phone. It emerges that the customer keeps the upstairs doors open with a fan heater in the hall, and that the firm never explained how the new controls work. They settle: the customer pays the balance less a small amount, and the firm books a 30-minute visit to show them the controls. Both sides are spared a court claim, and the firm adds a handover checklist to every install.
Preparing your side of an ADR case
ADR is less formal than court, but the side with the clearer paperwork still tends to do better. Treat the referral as a chance to show the work was done properly and that you behaved reasonably when the customer complained.
- A one-page timeline: enquiry, quote, start, completion, complaint, each visit and each letter, with dates.
- The quote and terms the customer accepted, including anything they signed on the day.
- Photos taken before, during and after the work, labelled with the date and room.
- Test results and commissioning records, such as flue gas readings, pressure tests or balancing figures.
- Every message with the customer, in date order, including texts and notes of phone calls.
- A short statement of what you have offered and why you think it is fair.
Keep the tone factual. Mediators and adjudicators deal with frustrated people every day, and a calm, well-organised trader is easier to agree with than one who attacks the customer. If you think you got something wrong, say so early: a partial concession often settles the rest.
What ADR does not do
- It does not replace your own complaints process. Most schemes expect the customer to have given you a fair chance first.
- It does not deal with safety. Dangerous gas work goes to the Gas Safe Register, and patterns of unfair trading may reach Trading Standards.
- It does not stop a customer going to court if the outcome is not binding on them.
- It does not cover your own unpaid invoices by default. For that you may need a letter before action and a small claim.
- It does not fix vague promises. Clear guarantee wording prevents many disputes in the first place.
Treat ADR as the last step in a process that mostly ends earlier. The firms that use it least are the ones that answer complaints in writing within days, offer a remedy when one is due and explain their reasoning plainly. Where a dispute is genuinely about facts or technical judgement, an independent route protects your time and your reputation.
Frequently asked questions
Is ADR compulsory for plumbers in the UK?
No general law makes plumbers join an ADR scheme. If your trade body, consumer code or contract terms oblige you to use one, the DMCC Act 2024 requires you to tell customers about it when you give them the outcome of their complaint.
Who pays for ADR?
It depends on the scheme. Many consumer-facing schemes are free for the customer and funded by member firms or case fees. Check the cost to you before you commit, and never tell customers it is free unless that is true.
Can a customer still take me to court after ADR?
Often yes, if the outcome is not binding on them. Arbitration is the main exception, because both sides agree to accept the arbitrator's decision instead of going to court.
What should my final complaint letter include?
What you investigated, what you found, what you will do and why, and, where you are obliged to use a scheme, its name, how to contact it and any reference the customer needs.
References
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2024). Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, section 308 (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). The Alternative Dispute Resolution for Consumer Disputes (Competent Authorities and Information) Regulations 2015, regulation 19 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (GOV.UK) (2021). Consumer protection study 2022: understanding the impacts and resolution of consumer problems (opens in a new tab) ↑
Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (GOV.UK) (2021). Consumer protection study 2022: understanding the impacts and resolution of consumer problems (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 49 (opens in a new tab) ↑