Key takeaways
- The CMA's Green Claims Code sets six principles: claims must be truthful, clear, complete, fairly compared, consider the full life cycle and be substantiated[1].
- The code rests on consumer protection law, and the CMA, Trading Standards and the ASA can all act on misleading claims[1].
- Swap vague words like eco-friendly and zero carbon for specific, checkable statements about the product and the job.
- Keep a claims file: for every number or comparison you publish, the source, the date and the assumptions.
- Reviews and marketing messages have their own rules: fake or incentivised reviews are banned[2][3], and marketing texts and emails need consent or the soft opt-in[4].
Why green claims are a risk for heating firms
Low-carbon heating is easy to oversell. Heat pumps really can cut a home's emissions, solar really can reduce bills, and grants really are available. The trouble starts when those truths get compressed into a slogan: zero-carbon heating, no more energy bills, the eco choice. Each one is either vague or only true in some homes, and customers who feel misled tell other people.
There is a legal side too. The Competition and Markets Authority's Green Claims Code is based on the Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations 2008, and it also refers to the Business Protection from Misleading Marketing Regulations 2008[1]. The guidance notes that businesses may have to pay redress to consumers harmed, that the CMA and Trading Standards can bring court proceedings, and that the Advertising Standards Authority can act against misleading adverts[1].
The six principles in practice
| Principle | What it means for you | Instead of | Try |
|---|---|---|---|
| Truthful and accurate | The claim must be correct for the product or service as sold | Zero-carbon heating | Uses electricity, which gets cleaner as the grid decarbonises |
| Clear and unambiguous | Customers must understand what is being claimed | Eco-friendly installs | We design each system from a room-by-room heat loss calculation |
| Not omit or hide important information | Include conditions that change the picture | Free heat pumps | Grant of up to the scheme amount, subject to eligibility; customer pays the balance |
| Fair and meaningful comparisons | Compare like with like, and say what with | Cheaper than gas | Running cost estimate for your home, with the tariffs and efficiency we assumed |
| Consider the full life cycle | Do not cherry-pick one stage | Green product | Specific facts about refrigerant type, efficiency and end-of-life recovery |
| Substantiated | Have evidence before you publish | Customers save hundreds | Example running cost comparison, labelled as an example, with assumptions |
The six principles come straight from the code[1]. Most heating firms do not break them on purpose. They break them by copying manufacturer slogans, by rounding a single good result into a general promise, or by leaving out the conditions that make a claim true.
Words to handle with care
- Green, eco, sustainable, environmentally friendly: too vague on their own. Say what, specifically, is better and compared with what.
- Zero carbon, carbon neutral, net zero home: almost never true for a heat pump running on grid electricity. Avoid unless you can prove it for that home.
- Renewable: a heat pump uses ambient heat, but the electricity it runs on may not be renewable. Be precise.
- Save, cheaper, lower bills: only with a stated comparison and assumptions, and never as a guarantee.
- Free: rarely true. Grants usually cover part of the cost and depend on eligibility.
- Government approved or endorsed: only for the specific scheme you are registered with, named correctly.
If a claim needs an asterisk to be true, put the condition in the main sentence instead.
Using data honestly
Data makes marketing more persuasive and more defensible, provided you use it accurately. For example, the median installed cost of an air-to-water heat pump under the Boiler Upgrade Scheme in 2026 was 14% lower after inflation than in 2022[5]. That supports a claim that typical grant-scheme installation costs have fallen in real terms. It does not support a claim that your prices are 14% lower than last year.
Be equally careful with claims about popularity. At the 2021 Census only 0.9% of households with central heating in England and Wales used any renewable energy source[6]. Uptake has grown since, but phrases like everyone is switching or the most popular choice are hard to substantiate.
- Used a renewable energy source 0.9%
Source: Office for National Statistics, 2021[6]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Used a renewable energy source | 0.9% |
Name the source and date whenever you quote a number, and update or remove it when newer data appears. A two-year-old statistic presented as current is misleading even if it was true when you wrote it.
Honest marketing that still sells
Accurate claims do not have to be dull. The most effective low-carbon marketing from small heating firms tends to lean on what they can prove about their own work rather than on big environmental statements.
- Show your process: a photo of a heat loss survey, a marked-up radiator plan, a commissioning sheet. It signals care without making a claim.
- Tell real local stories, with permission, that include the house type and what the owner says about comfort, not just bills.
- Explain one thing well per post: how a cylinder works with a heat pump, what a compensation curve does, why flow temperature matters.
- Be open about who a technology does not suit. It makes everything else you say more believable.
- Answer common questions in plain English on your website, and link to the official scheme pages for grant details.
Customers considering a large, unfamiliar purchase are looking for someone they can trust. Specific, modest and checkable claims build that trust faster than slogans.
Build a claims file
List every claim
Go through your website, leaflets, van livery, social posts and quote templates. Write down every claim about savings, carbon, efficiency, grants and quality.
Find the evidence
For each claim, note the source, its date and the assumptions. Manufacturer data counts only for what it actually tests.
Fix or remove
Rewrite claims you cannot support, add missing conditions, and delete the rest.
Set a review date
Grants, tariffs and statistics change. Review the file every six months and whenever a scheme changes.
Brief the team
Make sure surveyors and office staff say the same things on the phone and in homes as your marketing does.
Reviews, testimonials and case studies
Customer stories are your most persuasive marketing, and they have their own rules. Every trader that publishes consumer reviews is responsible for preventing and removing fake reviews, concealed incentivised reviews and misleading review information[2]. Under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, submitting or commissioning a fake review, or one that hides an incentive, is treated as unfair in all circumstances[3].
- Only publish case studies with the customer's written permission, and keep the permission.
- If a case study quotes running costs or savings, include the property type, the tariff and the period, and say results vary.
- Do not offer discounts or prize draws in return for positive reviews.
- Publish negative reviews as well as positive ones, and reply calmly to both.
Getting the message to people lawfully
Even a perfectly worded message can break the rules if it is sent the wrong way. Direct marketing emails and texts to individuals need prior consent, unless the soft opt-in applies to existing customers[4]. Unsolicited marketing calls must not be made to numbers on the Telephone Preference Service register unless the subscriber has said they do not object[7]. Keep records of where each contact's permission came from.
What your team says counts too
Marketing rules apply to what is said on the phone and in the customer’s kitchen, not only to what is printed. A surveyor who tells a customer they will definitely save money, or that the grant covers everything, undoes a careful website in a sentence. Give surveyors and office staff a short list of approved phrases for the questions they hear most, such as running costs, grants and noise, and the phrases to avoid. Review it when schemes change, and include it in induction for every new starter.
Worked Example: rewriting a leaflet
Example (fictional): a firm's leaflet reads: Go green with a free heat pump and slash your bills. Zero-carbon heating for your home. Each phrase is a problem: free hides the customer contribution, slash your bills is unsupported, and zero-carbon is not true on grid electricity.
In the Example, the rewritten leaflet reads: Thinking about a heat pump? We design each system from a room-by-room survey, explain any grant you may be eligible for and give you a written running cost estimate for your home, with every assumption shown. It is less punchy, but every word can be defended, and the firm finds it attracts more serious enquiries. For related guidance on promises, see our pieces on response time promises and solar thermal.
Before you publish: a checklist
- Is every environmental claim specific about what is better and compared with what?
- Does every number have a named, dated source in your claims file?
- Are grant conditions and the customer's contribution stated in the main text?
- Are savings shown as an example with assumptions, not a promise?
- Do any logos or scheme names match registrations that are current and relevant?
- Do reviews and case studies have permission and no hidden incentives?
- Will the message be sent only to people who have agreed to receive it?
Frequently asked questions
What is the Green Claims Code?
CMA guidance setting six principles for environmental claims: truthful and accurate, clear and unambiguous, not hiding important information, fair comparisons, full life cycle, and substantiated[1].
Can I call a heat pump zero carbon?
Usually not. A heat pump on grid electricity still has emissions from that electricity. Describe the specific benefits you can prove instead.
Can I advertise free heat pumps?
Only if they genuinely are free for the customers you are addressing. Grants usually cover part of the cost and depend on eligibility, so say so in the main text.
Who enforces green claims rules?
The CMA and Trading Standards can bring court proceedings, and the Advertising Standards Authority can act against misleading adverts[1].
References
Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) (2021). Green claims code: environmental claims on goods and services (opens in a new tab) ↑
Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) (2025). Short guide for businesses: publishing consumer reviews and complying with consumer protection law (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2025). Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, Schedule 20 (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2003). The Privacy and Electronic Communications (EC Directive) Regulations 2003, regulation 22 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Department for Energy Security and Net Zero (2026). Boiler Upgrade Scheme (BUS) monthly statistics: England and Wales, September 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Office for National Statistics (2021). Housing, England and Wales: Census 2021 (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2003). The Privacy and Electronic Communications (EC Directive) Regulations 2003, regulation 21 (opens in a new tab) ↑