Key takeaways
- Hourly pricing puts the overrun risk on the customer; fixed pricing puts it on you. Choose based on how predictable the job is.
- Fault-finding, leaks and old systems suit hourly or capped pricing; swaps, installs and repeat job types suit fixed prices.
- Whatever you say about the price becomes a term of the contract if the customer relies on it[1], and changes need the customer's express agreement.
- If no price or method of calculation is agreed, the customer only has to pay a reasonable price[2].
- Hybrids, such as a fixed diagnosis fee followed by a fixed repair price, often suit both sides best.
Two ways to charge, two ways to share risk
Every plumbing job carries some uncertainty: a seized valve, corroded pipework behind a bath panel, a fault that takes three tests to find. The way you charge decides who pays for that uncertainty. With an hourly rate, the customer pays for the time the job actually takes, so they carry the risk of it running long. With a fixed price, you carry it: if the job overruns, you absorb the cost; if it runs short, you keep the difference.
Neither is better in general. Hourly pricing suits work you cannot fully see in advance. Fixed pricing suits work you have done many times and can scope properly. Most firms end up using both, plus a few hybrids, and the skill lies in matching the method to the job.
Side by side
| Factor | Hourly rate | Fixed price |
|---|---|---|
| Who carries overrun risk | Customer | You |
| Customer certainty before work | Low, unless you give a time estimate or cap | High |
| Your margin on a good day | Steady | Higher if you are quicker than expected |
| Your margin on a bad day | Steady | Can disappear |
| Admin | Time must be recorded and shown on the invoice | Scope, inclusions and exclusions must be written down |
| Common disputes | How long it took and what counted as working time | What the price included |
| Best for | Fault-finding, leaks, old or unknown systems, small mixed jobs | Boiler swaps, radiator and cylinder replacements, installs, repeat job types |
Where an hourly rate fits
Charge by the hour when you cannot know how long the job will take until you start it. That covers most diagnostic work and a lot of repair work in older homes:
- Tracing leaks, especially under floors or behind tiling.
- Intermittent boiler faults that need testing over time.
- Old systems where pipework condition is unknown.
- Small mixed lists, such as 'a dripping tap, a running toilet and a stiff stopcock'.
- Emergency call-outs where the cause is not yet known.
Hourly pricing only feels fair if the customer knows the rules before you start. State the rate, the minimum charge, the units after the first period (for example per half hour), whether travel and collecting parts count, and a rough estimate of how long you expect it to take. Where no time has been agreed, the law expects the work to be done within a reasonable time[3], so a sensible estimate protects both of you.
Where a fixed price fits
Quote a fixed price when you can see the whole job and have done it often enough to know the range of times it takes. Like-for-like boiler swaps, radiator and cylinder replacements, bathroom first and second fix, and standard installs all fit. A fixed price is easier for customers to compare and accept, and it rewards efficient firms.
Large projects are almost always sold this way. Under the Boiler Upgrade Scheme in England and Wales, for example, the median installed cost of an air-to-water heat pump was £12,826 in July to September 2026, and £34,630 for a ground source heat pump, including the grant[4]. Nobody signs up to a sum like that on an open hourly rate.
Source: Department for Energy Security and Net Zero, 2026[4]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Air-to-water heat pump | £12,826 |
| Ground source heat pump | £34,630 |
The protection for you is in the scope. Write down exactly what the price includes and what it does not, the assumptions behind it (such as 'existing pipework in serviceable condition') and how any extra work will be priced. A fixed price without a written scope is an invitation to argue.
What the law expects of each
For consumer work, the trader must give the total price inclusive of taxes or, where it cannot reasonably be calculated in advance, the manner in which it will be calculated[5]. An hourly rate with clear rules is a manner of calculation; a fixed price is a total. Either satisfies the requirement if it is clear.
Two other rules matter. Anything you say or write about the price that the customer takes into account when deciding to go ahead is treated as a term of the contract, subject to any qualification you gave at the same time[1]. And where no price was agreed at all, the customer only has to pay a reasonable price[2]. In practice, the firms that get into disputes are the ones that gave a loose figure on the phone and then charged differently.
Hybrid models that share the risk
- Fixed diagnosis, then a fixed repair price: charge a set fee to find the fault, then quote the repair before doing it. Common for boiler breakdowns.
- Fixed price with an hourly rate for extras: the agreed scope is fixed, anything outside it is charged at a stated rate, with the customer's agreement before you start it.
- Capped hourly: hourly rate with a ceiling you will not exceed without asking first. Customers like the certainty; you keep protection on simple jobs.
- Fixed price per stage: for bathrooms and larger installs, a price for each stage with a check-in between them.
- Fixed price with a stated allowance: for a known unknown, such as a set number of hours for freeing seized valves, charged only if used.
Decision criteria
- Can you see all of the work before you start? If not, lean hourly or hybrid.
- Have you done this job type many times, and do you know your fastest and slowest times? If yes, fixed.
- How wide is the range between a good day and a bad day? A wide range favours hourly or a capped rate.
- Is the customer comparing quotes from several firms? Fixed prices are easier to compare.
- Is the customer a landlord or agent with an approval limit? A cap or fixed price fits their process.
- Would an overrun hurt your cash flow? If a bad day on this job would wipe out a week's profit, do not fix the price without an allowance.
Keep a record of how long each fixed-price job actually took against the hours you allowed. After a few months, you will know which job types you price accurately and which keep overrunning. Move the overrunning ones to a hybrid or adjust the allowance, rather than absorbing the loss every time.
Scripts for explaining each
- Hourly: 'Because we can't see where the leak is until we start, we charge by the hour: the first hour, then each half hour after. Most jobs like this take one to two hours. If it looks like going beyond that, the engineer will stop and talk to you first.'
- Fixed: 'For swapping the cylinder like for like, the price is fixed. That includes removing the old one, fitting the new one, refilling and testing. If we find something outside that, we'll explain and price it before doing anything.'
- Capped: 'We'll charge for the time it takes, but it won't go over the figure we've agreed without your say-so.'
Example: the same leak, priced two ways
Example: a fictional firm in Manchester is asked to fix a leak under a kitchen floor. On an hourly basis, the engineer finds it in 70 minutes and the customer pays for one and a half hours plus parts. On a fixed price set to cover a typical three-hour leak trace, the customer would have paid twice as much for the same work, and might not have accepted the quote. A week later the same firm quotes a fixed price for a like-for-like combi swap. The fitter's previous dozen swaps took between six and eight hours, the scope is clear, and the customer accepts the fixed figure the same day.
When the job changes halfway through
However you price, things change on site. If the information you gave about the price was a term of the contract, a change to it needs the customer's express agreement[1]. Stop, explain what you have found, give the new price or rate for the extra work, and get a clear yes, ideally in a text or email, before carrying on. Note it on the job sheet. That one habit removes most invoice disputes, whichever pricing model you use. For building the underlying figures, see how to price plumbing jobs and working out your true labour rate.
Frequently asked questions
Is it better for a plumber to charge hourly or per job?
Charge hourly when you cannot see the whole job in advance, such as leak tracing and fault-finding, and fixed per job when the work is predictable, such as like-for-like swaps and installs. Many firms use hybrids such as a fixed diagnosis followed by a fixed repair price.
Do I have to give a price before starting a job?
For consumer work you must give the total price inclusive of taxes, or the way it will be calculated where it cannot reasonably be worked out in advance[5]. If no price is agreed, the customer only has to pay a reasonable price[2].
Can I charge more than my fixed price if the job takes longer?
Not without agreement. What you told the customer about the price is treated as a term of the contract if they relied on it, and changes need their express agreement[1]. Build allowances and exclusions into the scope instead.
References
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 50 (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 51 (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 52 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Department for Energy Security and Net Zero (2026). Boiler Upgrade Scheme (BUS) monthly statistics: England and Wales, September 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2013). The Consumer Contracts (Information, Cancellation and Additional Charges) Regulations 2013, Schedule 1 (opens in a new tab) ↑