Key takeaways
- Reply publicly, briefly and calmly within a day or two, then take the detail offline. Approved replies appear publicly under the review[1].
- Never threaten legal action or make a fix conditional on removing the review; the CMA lists both as ways of interfering with negative reviews[2].
- Flag only reviews that break the platform's policies, such as fake or abusive content, not reviews you simply disagree with[1].
- Use complaints to improve: under the Consumer Rights Act 2015, services must be performed with reasonable care and skill[3].
Why the reply matters more than the review
A one-star review feels personal, especially when you know the engineer worked late in the cold to get the job done. But the review is written for one reader and your reply is read by everyone who looks at your profile afterwards. Future customers rarely expect a perfect record. What they look for is how you behave when something goes wrong.
Problems are not rare in home repair work. In a government study, 25% of UK adults had bought home and garden maintenance and repair services (including plumbing and central heating) in the previous year, and 11% of those had a consumer problem[4]. The median net cost to consumers per problem in this sector was £109, among the ten highest of any sector[5]. A calm, fair reply shows you take that seriously.
Source: Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (GOV.UK), 2021[4]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Bought these services in the past 12 months (share of adults) | 25% |
| Had a consumer problem (share of those buyers) | 11% |
First, decide what kind of review it is
| Type of review | Example | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Fair criticism | Engineer arrived two hours late without warning | Apologise, explain briefly, say what you have changed, offer to talk |
| Partly fair | Price was higher than expected, though the work was good | Thank them, explain what was included and how quotes work, offer to go through the invoice |
| Misunderstanding | Complains you did not fix a fault that was outside the job agreed | Explain politely what was agreed, offer to help with the other fault |
| Not a customer | No record of the name, job or address | Reply neutrally that you cannot find a record and invite contact; flag if it breaks policy |
| Abusive or fake | Offensive language, competitor posing as customer, wrong business | Flag through the platform's process; reply briefly if appropriate |
Check your job records before replying. Knowing the date, the engineer and what was agreed lets you respond accurately rather than defensively.
A reply routine
Wait an hour, not a week
Do not reply in anger. Do reply within a day or two, so readers see you are responsive.
Find the facts
Look up the job: who went, when, what was agreed, what was charged and any notes.
Thank and acknowledge
Thank them for the feedback and acknowledge the specific problem in their words.
Apologise where it is due
If you got something wrong, say so plainly. If you did not, you can still be sorry about how they feel.
Explain briefly, without blame
One or two sentences of context are enough. Do not argue the detail in public.
Move it offline
Give a named person and a direct phone number or email to sort it out.
Follow up and record
Call or email the customer, resolve what you can and record the complaint and outcome.
Reply templates
Fair criticism: 'Hi Mark, thank you for taking the time to write this, and I'm sorry we didn't let you know Dan was running late on Tuesday. That isn't the service we aim for. We've changed how we message customers when an earlier job overruns. I'd like to talk it through; please call me on 01632 960000. Ruth, Harper Heating.'
Price concern: 'Hi Jess, thank you for your review and I'm glad the heating is working well. I'm sorry the final cost was more than you expected. The invoice included a replacement diverter valve, which we found was faulty during the repair. I'd be happy to go through it with you; please call me on 01632 960000. Ruth.'
No record: 'Hello, thank you for your feedback. We can't find a job matching your name or address, and we'd like to look into this. Please contact me on 01632 960000 with the date and address so I can check. Ruth, Harper Heating.'
Keep replies free of customer details beyond what they have already shared. Never post addresses, invoice amounts they have not mentioned or comments about the customer's home.
Who replies, and keeping it consistent
Decide who replies to reviews before the next bad one arrives. In most small firms it should be the owner or the office manager, not the engineer named in the review, who is often too close to the job to reply calmly. Agree a few house rules and write them down.
- Sign replies with a real first name and role, so readers know a person is listening.
- Use the same phone number or email for follow-up in every reply, ideally one that reaches the person who handles complaints.
- Never name or blame an individual engineer in public, even when they made the mistake.
- Keep a short log of each negative review, the reply, the follow-up call and the outcome, so nothing slips.
What you must not do
Consumer protection law now treats interference with genuine reviews seriously. The CMA's guidance says traders should not interfere with reviewers' ability or willingness to leave negative reviews, including through threats of harm or legal action, or by making an offer of dispute resolution contingent on a consumer not leaving a negative review[2]. Suppressing genuine negative reviews, for example by editing or removing them from your own website, is also a problem[2].
- Do not threaten to sue or to report the customer for a review that reflects their genuine experience.
- Do not offer a refund or free work in exchange for deleting or changing the review. You can resolve the complaint and leave it to the customer whether to update their review.
- Do not post fake positive reviews to bury the negative one.
- Do not delete or hide negative reviews from testimonials on your own website while keeping the positive ones.
If a review contains false statements of fact that seriously harm your business, take proper legal advice before acting. Defamation is a specialist area, and a heavy-handed response can do more reputational damage than the review.
After you have resolved it
When you have spoken to the customer and put things right, it is reasonable to add a short second reply under the review, if the platform allows it, saying that you have been in touch and resolved the issue. Keep it factual and do not include details the customer has not shared publicly.
Some customers will update their review of their own accord once the problem is fixed. That is their choice. You may tell them that they can edit their review if they wish, but do not press them, and do not link any refund, discount or extra work to a change in the review. If the customer is still unhappy after a fair offer, explain your complaints process and any independent route available to them, and leave the review in place.
Example: after resolving a lateness complaint, a fictional firm adds: 'Update: thank you for speaking with me, Mark. I'm glad we could sort out the return visit. Ruth.' Readers see the whole story without either side arguing in public.
When to flag a review
Google lets you flag a review that you believe breaks its content policies[1]. Use this for reviews that are fake, abusive, about the wrong business, posted by a competitor or former employee, or contain personal information. Do not flag reviews simply because they are negative or because you disagree with the customer's view; flagging genuine reviews wastes time and, if done as a pattern, looks like suppression.
If you suspect a campaign of fake reviews, keep a record of dates, wording and any links to competitors, and see fake reviews and review gating: what's now illegal for your options.
Fix the cause, not just the review
Every negative review is free consultancy. Group them by cause each quarter: arrival times, communication, price surprises, workmanship, mess, follow-up. The law sets the baseline: services must be performed with reasonable care and skill[3], and where no time is agreed, within a reasonable time[6]. Most reviews, though, are about communication rather than workmanship.
Example: a fictional firm in Burnley gets three critical reviews in a month, all mentioning engineers arriving later than the slot given. The owner switches to a two-hour arrival window, adds a call or text when an earlier job overruns, and mentions the change in replies. Over the next quarter, lateness disappears from new reviews. The fix took one process change; the replies made it visible.
A written process makes this consistent; see writing a complaints handling procedure. Keep a steady flow of genuine reviews with review request messages customers actually answer, and keep replies consistent on every platform with managing your reputation across review platforms.
Frequently asked questions
Should I reply to every negative review?
Yes, briefly and calmly, unless the review is abusive or clearly fake, in which case flag it and keep any reply short. Future customers read your replies as much as the reviews.
Can I ask a customer to remove a bad review?
You can resolve their complaint and let them decide whether to update the review. Do not make a refund or fix conditional on removing it; the CMA flags that as interfering with negative reviews[2].
How do I get a fake review removed from Google?
Flag it through your Business Profile if you believe it breaks Google's content policies[1]. Keep evidence, such as no matching job record, and reply neutrally in the meantime.
How quickly should I respond to a bad review?
Within a day or two. Take an hour to calm down and check the job record, but do not leave it for weeks.
References
Google Business Profile Help (2026). Manage customer reviews (opens in a new tab) ↑
Competition and Markets Authority (2025). Fake reviews guidance (CMA208) (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 49 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (GOV.UK) (2021). Consumer protection study 2022: understanding the impacts and resolution of consumer problems (opens in a new tab) ↑
Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (GOV.UK) (2021). Consumer protection study 2022: understanding the impacts and resolution of consumer problems (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 52 (opens in a new tab) ↑