Key takeaways
- Choose a primary review platform, usually Google, and a short list of secondary ones; do not chase reviews everywhere at once.
- Monitor every platform weekly with alerts, and reply on a set routine. Replies are public and read by future customers[1].
- Customers are right to be wary: research estimated 11% to 15% of reviews in common product categories were fake[2]. Consistent, genuine reviews across sites build trust.
- If you republish reviews on your own website, you take on duties to prevent fake and misleading review content[3].
Why reputation is spread across many sites
A homeowner choosing a plumber might see your Google rating in search results, read comments about you in a local Facebook group, check a trade directory where you are listed and look at the testimonials on your website, all in ten minutes. Each of those is a piece of your reputation. If they tell a consistent story, trust builds. If one platform shows a run of unanswered complaints or an out-of-date phone number, it can undo the rest.
Customers are sceptical for good reason. Research commissioned by government estimated that 11% to 15% of all reviews for three common product categories on e-commerce platforms were fake[2]. In home repair, problems are common enough to make people careful: 11% of people who bought home maintenance and repair services had a consumer problem[4]. Seeing the same pattern of genuine reviews on several independent sites is one of the ways customers decide whom to believe.
Source: Department for Business and Trade (GOV.UK), 2023[2]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Lower estimate | 11% |
| Upper estimate | 15% |
Decide where you want reviews
| Platform | Role | Effort |
|---|---|---|
| Google Business Profile | Primary: seen in search and maps | Ask every customer; reply to every review |
| Facebook page and local groups | Community recommendations and word of mouth | Monitor and reply; take part in local groups politely |
| Trade directories you belong to | Trust signal for customers comparing trades | Keep profile current; ask only where membership depends on it |
| Vetting schemes | Badge plus verified reviews | Follow the scheme's process |
| Manufacturer installer finders | Reviews shown to brand-led customers | Encourage reviews from those customers |
| Your own website | Your choice of reviews, with legal duties | Show fairly and link to full profiles |
Ask customers to review you in one place per request, usually Google. Spreading requests across three platforms in one message gets fewer reviews on each. If a directory membership depends on reviews there, send those customers a separate request for that platform, using the same wording and timing for all of them.
Set up monitoring once
List every profile
Search your firm name, trading names and phone number. Note every platform where you have a profile, including old ones.
Claim and secure them
Claim each profile with a shared business email, and make sure at least two people can sign in.
Turn on alerts
Switch on email or app notifications for new reviews on each platform.
Close or merge duplicates
Report duplicate or outdated profiles through each platform's own process so reviews are not split.
Create a reviews log
Keep a simple sheet: date, platform, rating, customer, job, reply sent, follow-up done.
Make sure the name, phone number, website and service area match on every profile. Mismatched details make it harder for customers and search engines to connect reviews to the right business.
A weekly reply routine
Set aside 20 minutes, on the same day each week, to work through the log. Replies to Google reviews appear publicly under the review once approved[1], and the same is true on most platforms, so treat each one as a message to future customers.
- Positive reviews: thank the customer by first name, mention the job or engineer, keep it to two lines. Vary the wording.
- Mixed reviews: thank them, acknowledge the issue they raised and say what you have done about it.
- Negative reviews: reply calmly, take it offline with a named contact, and log the follow-up.
- Reviews that look fake or abusive: flag through the platform's process with your evidence, and reply neutrally if at all.
- Comments in local groups: answer questions helpfully and briefly; do not argue in community spaces.
Urgent problems, such as a review describing a safety concern, should not wait for the weekly slot. Ask whoever sees the alert to pass it to the owner the same day. For detailed wording, see responding to a bad review.
Local community groups
Neighbourhood Facebook groups and similar forums are where many people ask 'Can anyone recommend a plumber?'. They are not review platforms, but they shape reputation just as much, and the rules are different: the group belongs to its members and its admins, not to you.
- Read the group rules before posting. Many ban business posts except on set days or in a dedicated thread.
- When someone recommends you, thank them briefly and let the recommendation stand. Do not follow it with a sales pitch.
- Answer genuine questions helpfully, such as how to bleed a radiator or what to do about a gas smell, even when there is no job in it.
- If someone complains about you in a group, reply once, politely, with a way to contact you, and then take it offline.
- Never ask friends or staff to pose as customers recommending you; that is a fake endorsement.
Your own website: show reviews fairly
Testimonials on your website are within your control, which brings responsibility. A trader that publishes consumer reviews is responsible for preventing and removing fake reviews, concealed incentivised reviews and false or misleading review information[3], and must take reasonable and proportionate steps to do so rather than relying entirely on a third-party tool[5].
- Show recent reviews chosen by date, not only your favourites, and link to your full Google profile.
- Keep the source and date of each review you display.
- Never edit a customer's words beyond fixing an obvious typo, and never combine quotes.
- Remove reviews from customers who ask, and anything you discover is not genuine.
- Publish a short reviews policy explaining how reviews are collected and shown.
Example: one owner, five platforms, one routine
Example: the owner of a fictional heating firm in Bolton found profiles on Google, Facebook, two directories and an old listing under a previous trading name. Reviews on one directory had gone unanswered for a year, including two complaints about missed appointments that had long since been resolved.
She claimed every profile with a shared email, closed the old listing, turned on alerts and replied to the backlog, adding a short update to the old complaints explaining what had changed. She then set a Friday-morning slot for the reviews log. Within a couple of months every profile was current and every review had a reply, and new customers began mentioning that they had read the replies.
When a complaint spreads
Occasionally a complaint moves beyond one review: a long post in a community group, the same story on several platforms, or a local news enquiry. The worst responses are silence and anger. A short plan helps.
Get the facts first
Check the job record, speak to the engineer and look at any photos or messages before saying anything public.
Reply once, in one voice
Post a short, calm reply that acknowledges the concern and gives a named contact. Use the same wording on each platform where it appears.
Contact the customer directly
Call or email to resolve it. Most escalations calm down once a person engages.
Fix and record
Put right what went wrong, note what you changed and add a brief update to your public reply if appropriate.
If the claims are false and damaging, keep records and take advice before responding further, rather than arguing point by point in public.
Learn from the pattern
Once a quarter, read every review from the period in one go, across all platforms. Group comments by theme: punctuality, communication, tidiness, price, workmanship, follow-up. The themes that come up on several platforms are your real reputation, and the best guide to what to fix next. Reviews also only capture customers who choose to write; measuring customer satisfaction covers how to hear from the rest.
Share the quarterly summary with the whole team, including the engineers. Point out the compliments as well as the complaints, and agree one change for the next quarter. When customers later mention that change in a review, such as arrival-time texts or dust sheets, tell the team; it shows the routine is worth the effort.
A strong reputation also opens other channels. Letting and estate agents check reviews before recommending a trade, as covered in estate agent partnerships, and happy customers are your best source of referrals, as in running a customer referral scheme. Keep every part of it within the rules set out in fake reviews and review gating: what's now illegal.
Frequently asked questions
Which review site matters most for plumbers?
For most firms, Google, because it appears in search results and maps. Keep a short list of secondary platforms (Facebook, the directories and schemes you belong to) and keep them all current.
How often should I check my reviews?
Turn on alerts so you see new reviews quickly, and work through replies in a set weekly slot. Pass anything urgent, such as a safety concern, to the owner the same day.
Should I reply to positive reviews?
Yes, briefly and personally. Replies are public[1], so a short, specific thank-you shows future customers that a real person reads the reviews.
References
Google Business Profile Help (2026). Manage customer reviews (opens in a new tab) ↑
Department for Business and Trade (GOV.UK) (2023). Fake online reviews research: executive summary (opens in a new tab) ↑
Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) (2025). Short guide for businesses: publishing consumer reviews and complying with consumer protection law (opens in a new tab) ↑
Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (GOV.UK) (2021). Consumer protection study 2022: understanding the impacts and resolution of consumer problems (opens in a new tab) ↑
Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) (2025). Short guide for businesses: publishing consumer reviews and complying with consumer protection law (opens in a new tab) ↑