Marketing leads

Fake reviews and review gating: what's now illegal

What the DMCC Act 2024 and CMA guidance mean for plumbing and heating firms: fake and incentivised reviews, review gating, staff reviews and fake attacks.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. What changed in 2025
  2. What counts as a fake or concealed incentivised review
  3. Review gating and cherry-picking
  4. If you show reviews on your own website
  5. Dealing with fake reviews about you
  6. A quick compliance checklist
  7. Example: auditing a review routine
  8. Referral schemes and other incentives
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References

Key takeaways

  • Since 6 April 2025, submitting or commissioning a fake review, or one that hides an incentive, is treated as unfair in all circumstances[1].
  • A fake review is one that purports to be, but is not, based on a person's genuine experience[2]; that covers reviews from staff, family and paid writers.
  • Asking only satisfied customers, suppressing genuine negative reviews or making a fix conditional on no bad review can all break the rules[3].
  • If you publish reviews on your own website, you must take reasonable and proportionate steps to prevent and remove fake ones[4][5].

What changed in 2025

The Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 (the DMCC Act) added fake reviews to the list of commercial practices that are banned outright. Since 6 April 2025, submitting or commissioning a fake consumer review, or one that conceals that it was incentivised, is treated as unfair in all circumstances[1]. There is no need for anyone to show that a particular customer was misled; the practice itself is banned.

The Competition and Markets Authority published guidance in April 2025 setting out what businesses that write, commission or publish reviews must do. For a plumbing and heating firm, the rules touch three things you probably do already: asking customers for reviews, showing reviews on your website and dealing with reviews you think are unfair.

The problem the law targets is real. Government-commissioned research estimated that 11% to 15% of all reviews for three common product categories on e-commerce platforms were fake, and that fake review text on products alone causes £50 million to £312 million of annual harm to UK consumers[6].

Estimated annual harm to UK consumers from fake product review textFake online reviews research, Department for Business and Trade, 2023
Estimated annual harm to UK consumers from fake product review textComparison. Lower estimate: £50,000,000; Upper estimate: £312,000,000.£50MLower estimateLower estimate: £50,000,000£312MUpper estimateUpper estimate: £312,000,000Estimated annual harm to UK consumers from fake product review textComparison. Lower estimate: £50,000,000; Upper estimate: £312,000,000.£50MLower estimateLower estimate: £50,000,000£312MUpper estimateUpper estimate: £312,000,000

Source: Department for Business and Trade (GOV.UK), 2023[6]

Show the data
ItemValue
Lower estimate£50,000,000
Upper estimate£312,000,000

What counts as a fake or concealed incentivised review

The Act defines a fake consumer review as one that purports to be, but is not, based on a person's genuine experience[2]. The CMA adds that a review is not fake just because the trader does not like or agree with it, as long as it reflects the reviewer's genuine experience[3]. In practice, for a trade business, the following are banned:

  • Writing reviews of your own business, or asking family and friends who have not used you to do so.
  • Asking staff to review the business. The CMA says commissioning can include a trader requesting a member of staff to write a review of the trader's product[3].
  • Paying a company or individual to post reviews.
  • Offering money, discounts, vouchers or free work in exchange for a review and not making that clear. The CMA's examples of commissioning include money, commissions, discounts or vouchers and products given free of charge[3].
  • Posting fake negative reviews of a competitor.

Platform rules can be stricter than the law. Google's policy prohibits offering incentives of any kind in exchange for a review and bans reviews based on a conflict of interest, including current or former employment[7]. A disclosed incentive may be lawful in some settings but will still break Google's rules.

Review gating and cherry-picking

Review gating means sending customers a quick satisfaction question first, then inviting only the happy ones to post a public review while steering unhappy ones to a private form. It used to be a common feature of review software. Under the CMA guidance it is risky: cherry-picking positive reviews can be done by encouraging just those who are satisfied to leave reviews[3], and Google's policy separately prohibits selectively soliciting positive reviews[7].

The CMA also lists ways of interfering with negative reviews that traders should avoid[3]:

  1. Threatening harm or legal action against reviewers.
  2. Preventing genuine customers from leaving reviews.
  3. Arbitrarily stopping and starting review invitations, for example pausing requests after a bad week.
  4. Making an offer of dispute resolution contingent on the customer not leaving a negative review.
  5. Editing, withholding or removing genuine negative reviews to limit their impact.

If you show reviews on your own website

Many plumbing firms display reviews or testimonials on their website. If you publish consumer reviews, you are responsible for preventing and removing fake reviews, concealed incentivised reviews and false or misleading review information[4]. You must take reasonable and proportionate steps, and you cannot pass this duty entirely to a third-party monitor[5].

  1. Publish a short reviews policy

    State that you do not allow fake or incentivised reviews, how reviews are collected and how you handle them. The CMA's short guide expects a published policy that clearly prohibits fake reviews, backed by a risk assessment and processes to detect and act on them[5].

  2. Assess your risks

    Think about where fake or misleading reviews could come from in your business, and repeat the assessment regularly rather than once.

  3. Show reviews fairly

    Do not display only the best reviews if they do not reflect your reviews overall. Link to your full Google profile so visitors can see everything.

  4. Keep records

    Keep a note of where each displayed review came from and the job it relates to.

  5. Remove what breaks the rules

    If you discover a review on your site is fake or concealed incentivised, remove it and note what you did.

Dealing with fake reviews about you

Fake negative reviews from competitors or people who were never customers are also covered by the ban, and the CMA notes that suppressing fake negative reviews is important, while suppressing genuine ones is a problem[3]. What you can do:

  • Check your job records for the name, address and date. If there is no match, note it.
  • Reply neutrally in public: say you cannot find a record and invite the reviewer to contact you.
  • Flag the review through the platform's own reporting process, with your evidence.
  • If you see a pattern, such as several reviews in a short period with similar wording, keep screenshots and dates.
  • Do not retaliate with reviews of the suspected competitor, and do not post positive fake reviews to compensate.

For calm public replies, see responding to a bad review.

A quick compliance checklist

Run through this list once a year, and whenever you change review software or start showing reviews somewhere new.

  • Every customer receives the same review request, sent at the same stage of the job.
  • No incentive of any kind is offered for a review, and referral rewards are never tied to reviews.
  • No owner, family member, employee or former employee has reviewed the business.
  • Your review software has no satisfaction filter that decides who is sent the public link.
  • Reviews on your website are chosen fairly and link to the full profile.
  • A short reviews policy is published on your site.
  • Someone knows how to flag suspected fake reviews on each platform, and records what was flagged and why.

Example: auditing a review routine

Example: a fictional plumbing firm in Ipswich reviews its practices after reading the guidance. It finds three problems. Its review software asked customers to rate the job out of five and only sent the Google link to those who chose four or five. Two engineers had left reviews for the firm years ago. And the website showed a hand-picked carousel of five-star quotes.

The owner switches off the gating step so every customer gets the same Google link, asks the engineers to delete their reviews, replaces the carousel with a link to the full Google profile plus a few recent reviews chosen by date rather than rating, and publishes a short reviews policy. None of it costs money, and the profile becomes more credible.

Referral schemes and other incentives

Rewarding customers for referring friends is a different thing from paying for reviews, and is generally fine if run fairly. Keep the two separate: never make a referral reward depend on a review, and do not ask referred customers to review you as part of claiming a reward. The guide to running a customer referral scheme covers the rules. For pricing claims that sit alongside reviews in your marketing, see emergency job pricing transparency, and for the wording of requests that stay inside the rules, review request messages customers actually answer. To keep all of this consistent across sites, read managing your reputation across review platforms.

This article summarises the rules for general information and is not legal advice. For a specific situation, read the CMA's full guidance or take advice.

Frequently asked questions

Is it illegal to write fake reviews in the UK?

Yes. Since 6 April 2025, submitting or commissioning a fake consumer review, or one that conceals an incentive, is a banned practice under the DMCC Act 2024[1].

Is review gating illegal?

Inviting only satisfied customers to post public reviews can amount to cherry-picking under the CMA's guidance[3], and Google's policy prohibits selectively soliciting positive reviews[7]. Ask every customer in the same way.

Can my employees review my business?

No. The CMA says commissioning can include asking a member of staff to write a review[3], and Google bans reviews based on a conflict of interest, including employment[7].

What should I do about a fake negative review from a competitor?

Check your records, reply neutrally, flag it through the platform with your evidence and keep a record. Do not retaliate with reviews of your own.

References

  1. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2025). Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, Schedule 20 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2024). Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, Schedule 20 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Competition and Markets Authority (2025). Fake reviews guidance (CMA208) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) (2025). Short guide for businesses: publishing consumer reviews and complying with consumer protection law (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) (2025). Short guide for businesses: publishing consumer reviews and complying with consumer protection law (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Department for Business and Trade (GOV.UK) (2023). Fake online reviews research: executive summary (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. Google (2026). Prohibited and restricted content: Maps user generated content policy (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo