Boilers heating

Recommending magnetic filters without the hard sell

How to explain magnetic system filters honestly: what they do, when they are a warranty condition, scripts, doorstep cancellation rules and records.

Ava research teamPublished 6 min read

On this page
  1. Why a good recommendation can sound like a sales pitch
  2. What a filter does, in plain words
  3. When it is a condition, not a choice
  4. Know who you are talking to
  5. A three-sentence explanation
  6. Answering the usual objections
  7. Doorstep rules if you agree the work there
  8. Worked Example: two service visits
  9. Pricing and presentation
  10. Choosing the filter itself
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • A filter is part of protecting the system, alongside the cleaning and inhibitor that Approved Document L already expects; it does not replace them[1].
  • Explain it in three sentences: what it catches, why it matters for this boiler and what it needs each year.
  • Many customers expect to be upsold; consumer problems with home repair services are common enough to make them wary[2].
  • If you agree extra work in the customer's home, the 14-day cancellation rules for off-premises contracts apply[3].

Why a good recommendation can sound like a sales pitch

Customers have heard of magnetic filters mainly as an extra on a quote. Some have been told they are essential, others that they are a gimmick. When an engineer mentions one on the doorstep, a fair share of customers hear 'upsell' before they hear 'protection'.

That wariness has a basis. In the government's consumer protection study, 25% of UK adults had bought home maintenance and repair services, including plumbing and central heating, in the previous year, and 11% of those buyers reported a consumer problem[2]. Your job is to give a recommendation that survives that scepticism: specific, honest about limits and easy to check.

What a filter does, in plain words

Heating water picks up black iron oxide, usually called magnetite, from the inside of steel radiators and pipes, along with other debris. A magnetic filter on the return to the boiler pulls magnetite out of the water as it passes, and many units also trap non-magnetic particles. The engineer empties and cleans it at each service.

It works alongside, not instead of, the other steps. Approved Document L expects circuits to be thoroughly cleaned and flushed before a new boiler is fitted, inhibitor added and the system commissioned to BS 7593[1]. Cleaning removes what is already there; inhibitor slows new corrosion; the filter catches what is left and what still forms.

Never present a filter as a substitute for cleaning a dirty system. If the water is black, the honest recommendation is to clean it first.

When it is a condition, not a choice

For many new boilers the question is already answered. Most manufacturers make an in-line filter a condition of their longer warranty terms, and accredited installer schemes often specify a filter brand or type. Check the conditions for the boiler you are quoting before you speak to the customer, so you know whether you are recommending or explaining a requirement.

  • New boiler with an extended warranty that requires a filter: include it in the installation price and say it is a warranty condition.
  • New boiler without that condition: recommend it as protection for the heat exchanger and price it as a clear line.
  • Existing boiler at service with dirty water: recommend cleaning, then a filter, and explain the order.
  • Existing boiler with clean water and inhibitor in range: a filter is optional; say so.

Know who you are talking to

Condensing combis are common in every tenure. In 2024 they were in 67% of social rented homes, 64% of privately rented homes and 61% of owner-occupied homes in England[4]. The argument that lands differs by customer.

Homes in England with a condensing combination boiler, by tenure, 2024English Housing Survey 2024 to 2025
Homes in England with a condensing combination boiler, by tenure, 2024Bar chart. Social rented: 67%; Private rented: 64%; Owner occupied: 61%.Social rentedSocial rented: 67%67%Private rentedPrivate rented: 64%64%Owner occupiedOwner occupied: 61%61%Homes in England with a condensing combination boiler, by tenure, 2024Bar chart. Social rented: 67%; Private rented: 64%; Owner occupied: 61%.Social rentedSocial rented: 67%67%Private rentedPrivate rented: 64%64%Owner occupiedOwner occupied: 61%61%

Source: Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK), 2024[4]

Show the data
ItemValue
Social rented67%
Private rented64%
Owner occupied61%
  • Owner-occupiers care about the boiler lasting and the warranty staying valid.
  • Private landlords care about avoiding breakdown call-outs, tenant complaints and void periods, and about a clean audit trail.
  • Housing providers usually have a specification already; follow it and record compliance.
  • Older or vulnerable customers need time and a written summary, not a quick decision on the doorstep.

A three-sentence explanation

Keep it short enough that the customer can repeat it to someone else. One version that works: 'Your radiators slowly shed a black sludge into the water. This filter catches it before it reaches the boiler's heat exchanger, which is the part most likely to block. I empty it at each service, so you can see what it has caught.'

Then stop talking and let them ask questions. If they decline, record that it was offered and move on. A customer who feels pressured remembers the pressure, not the filter.

Answering the usual objections

  • 'My last engineer said I didn't need one.' Agree that some systems are fine without one, then show the water sample or the warranty condition that makes this case different.
  • 'Is this just a way to charge more?' Point to the line on the quote, say exactly what it does, and tell them they can decline without affecting anything else you do.
  • 'The boiler has worked for years without it.' That may be true, and the old boiler may have had larger waterways. The new heat exchanger is less forgiving of debris.
  • 'Can I fit it later?' Yes, although it is simpler during an installation when the system is already drained.
  • 'Will it save energy?' Do not promise that. Say it helps keep the system clean, which helps the boiler and radiators work as designed.

Notice that none of these answers involves pressure. The aim is to leave the customer with accurate information and a decision they are comfortable with, whichever way it goes.

Doorstep rules if you agree the work there

If the customer agrees extra work in their own home, such as fitting a filter during a service visit, the contract is usually an off-premises contract. The cancellation period for service contracts made off premises ends 14 days after the contract is made[3], and you must not start the service within that period unless the customer expressly asks you to, on a durable medium for off-premises contracts[5].

  1. Give the information

    Provide written details of the work, price and the cancellation right before the customer agrees.

  2. Ask how they want to proceed

    Explain they can wait 14 days, or ask you to start now in writing.

  3. Get the request in writing

    If they want it fitted today, record their express request on a durable medium, such as a signed form or an email.

  4. Explain what happens if they cancel

    Tell them how cancellation would affect payment for work already done, as the regulations allow.

Following the process takes a few minutes and removes any later suggestion that the customer was rushed.

Worked Example: two service visits

Example. An engineer services a seven-year-old combi in an owner-occupied semi. The water sample is dark, the inhibitor is low and two radiators have cold bottoms. The engineer explains that the system needs cleaning before a filter would help, leaves a written quote for a clean, inhibitor and filter, and does not fit anything that day.

Example. At a landlord's flat, the boiler is three years old and the water is clean, with inhibitor in range and no filter. The engineer tells the landlord the system is in good condition, that a filter is optional and would mainly give an early warning of corrosion, and leaves the decision to them. The landlord asks for it at the next visit, and the engineer confirms the request by email.

Pricing and presentation

  • On new installations, include the filter in the package if it is a warranty condition and say so on the quote.
  • As an optional extra, list it on its own line with a one-line description of what it does.
  • Do not bundle it into a vague 'system protection pack' that hides what the customer is paying for.
  • Avoid claims you cannot support, such as a specific energy saving or years added to boiler life.

After fitting, record the make, model and position on the commissioning or service record, show the customer where it is, and set a reminder to clean it at the next service. See BS 7593 water treatment and recommending extra work without pressure.

Choosing the filter itself

Match the filter to the pipe size and the space available, and check whether the boiler manufacturer or your installer scheme specifies one. Units that can be cleaned without draining down and without tools are quicker at service, which matters when you are cleaning dozens a month.

Fit it on the return, before the boiler, in a position where it can be opened over a towel without moving a kitchen unit. Check the flow direction arrow and leave the isolating valves accessible. A filter that is awkward to reach is a filter that does not get cleaned.

Frequently asked questions

Do magnetic filters actually work?

They capture magnetite circulating in the system and many also trap other debris. They work best on a system that has been cleaned and correctly dosed with inhibitor.

Is a filter required by building regulations?

Approved Document L requires cleaning, inhibitor and commissioning to BS 7593. Filters are widely recommended and often a manufacturer warranty condition; check the boiler's terms.

Can I fit a filter at a service visit the same day?

Yes, if the customer expressly asks you to start within the cancellation period and you record that request on a durable medium, after giving them the cancellation information.

How often should a filter be cleaned?

At least at every annual service, and after any system cleaning.

References

  1. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2023). Approved Document L, Volume 1: Dwellings (2021 edition incorporating 2023 amendments) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (GOV.UK) (2021). Consumer protection study 2022: understanding the impacts and resolution of consumer problems (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2013). The Consumer Contracts (Information, Cancellation and Additional Charges) Regulations 2013, regulation 30 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2024). English Housing Survey 2024 to 2025: Chapter 2, energy efficiency (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2013). The Consumer Contracts (Information, Cancellation and Additional Charges) Regulations 2013, regulation 36 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo