Key takeaways
- Your own plan keeps the customer and the margin, but you carry any risk you promise to cover. Insurance-backed cover moves the repair risk to an insurer.
- A plan that promises to pay for repairs whatever they cost can become a contract of insurance, and regulated activities need authorisation or an exemption[1].
- If you sell an insurer's product, you usually do so under an authorised firm's responsibility, for example as an appointed representative[2].
- Customers want certainty: 11% of people who bought home maintenance and repair services reported a problem[3].
- For most small firms, a service-only plan plus an introduction to authorised cover is the lowest-risk combination.
The choice in plain terms
Heating firms that want recurring income from boiler customers usually face a choice. They can run their own plan, where the firm promises a service and some benefits for a monthly or annual fee, or they can offer cover backed by an insurer, where a regulated provider takes on the cost of repairs and the firm is paid to service, repair or sell the product.
Neither is automatically better. The right answer depends on how much risk you are willing to carry, how much paperwork you are willing to take on and how much you want to own the customer relationship. The one thing you cannot do is drift into selling insurance by accident.
How the two models compare
| Factor | Your own service plan | Insurance-backed cover |
|---|---|---|
| Who carries repair risk | You, for anything you promise | The insurer, within the policy terms |
| Regulation | Consumer law; must stay a service contract | Financial services rules apply to the insurer and to anyone selling it |
| Customer relationship | Yours entirely | Shared with the provider; claims may be handled by them |
| Income | Plan fees and the repair work you win | Commission or fees, plus repair work if you are the approved engineer |
| Admin | Collection, reminders, terms | Provider's processes, plus your servicing and claims work |
| Complaints | Handled by you | May go through the provider and the financial services complaints route |
| Price control | Yours | Set by the provider |
When a plan turns into insurance
The line is about risk. A service contract promises a defined service for a defined price: an annual service, a safety check, a discount on labour. Insurance promises to pay for, or deal with, something uncertain in return for a premium: ‘we will repair any breakdown at no further cost’. The more your plan looks like the second, the more likely it is to be treated as a contract of insurance.
- Warning sign: unlimited repairs, parts and labour included for a fixed monthly fee.
- Warning sign: replacement of the boiler if it cannot be repaired.
- Warning sign: cover for parts of the system you have not inspected.
- Lower risk: a fixed annual service, a set number of labour hours, a percentage discount on repairs, free diagnostic visits.
- Lower risk: a priority response promise with no promise about the cost of the repair itself.
Under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000, no person may carry on a regulated activity in the UK, or claim to, unless they are authorised or exempt[1]. If there is any doubt about your plan wording, take specialist advice before you sell it, and keep the advice on file.
Offering insurance the right way
If your customers want breakdown cover and you want to offer it, there are legitimate routes. The common ones for small firms are:
Partner with an authorised provider
Work with an insurer or intermediary that is authorised to sell boiler cover, and agree your role: servicing, repairs, or introductions.
Act under a principal's responsibility
Some firms sell cover as an appointed representative, which carries on regulated activity under the responsibility of an authorised firm; the principal must make sure the representative is fit and proper and follows the rules[2].
Introduce only
Pass interested customers to an authorised provider without advising or arranging the cover yourself. Check with the provider exactly what you may and may not say.
Become authorised
Rarely worth it for a small heating firm, but an option for larger businesses with the compliance resource.
Whichever route you take, get the arrangement in writing and check the provider's register entry yourself.
What customers care about
Customers buy plans and cover because they want to avoid a nasty surprise. Their caution is justified: a quarter of UK adults bought home maintenance and repair services in a year, and 11% of them reported a consumer problem[3]. The median financial loss per problem was £109[4].
- Had a problem 11%
Source: Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (GOV.UK), 2021[3]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Had a problem | 11% |
Whichever model you choose, the customer wants three things answered clearly: what is covered, who they ring when the heating fails, and what they will pay at that moment. A plan that answers those in one paragraph will sell better than one with a long list of benefits.
Decision criteria
- Choose your own service-only plan if you want to own the customer and are happy to keep repairs as separately quoted work.
- Add insurance-backed cover through a partner if many customers ask for breakdown protection and you would rather not carry repair risk.
- Avoid writing your own repair cover unless you have taken specialist advice and have the data to price it.
- Check how the provider handles claims: if their approved engineer is not you, your customer may meet another firm at the worst moment.
- Compare total income over three years, including repair work you would win, not just the commission per sale.
Working through the money
Comparisons based on the fee per customer miss most of the picture. Model both options over three years for, say, a hundred customers, and include the work each one brings you.
- Own service-only plan: plan fees less your servicing cost and admin, plus the margin on repairs quoted separately to plan members, plus replacement boilers you are likely to fit for them.
- Insurance-backed cover through a partner: any commission or introduction fee, plus payment for servicing and repairs if you are the provider's engineer, less the time spent on the provider's paperwork and claims process.
- In both: the cost of cancellations, and the value of customers who would have left you without a plan.
Example: in a fictional model, a firm found that its own plan earned more per customer each year, but the partner route won it more repair work on older boilers it would otherwise have avoided covering. Running both, for different customers, gave the steadiest result. Your figures will differ; the point is to count the repair and replacement work, not just the fees.
What your team should and should not say
Most compliance problems with plans start in conversation, not in the written terms. An engineer trying to be helpful says ‘don't worry, the plan covers that’ about a repair it does not cover, and the customer relies on it.
- Say what the plan includes in the same words every time, ideally from a short card in the van.
- Never describe your own plan as insurance, cover or a guarantee against repair costs.
- If a customer asks about breakdown cover, explain that it is a separate product from an authorised provider and pass them the provider's information, unless your arrangement allows you to do more.
- Never estimate whether a provider's policy will pay a claim; direct the customer to the provider.
- Record what was said in the job notes if a customer asks detailed questions about cover.
Example: one firm, both models
Example (fictional): a four-engineer firm in Northampton ran a service-only plan for 600 customers and was regularly asked for breakdown cover. Rather than adding repair promises to its own plan, it agreed to introduce interested customers to an authorised provider that used the firm as its local engineer. Its own plan stayed simple and low-risk; customers who wanted cover could have it; and repair work on covered boilers still came to the firm.
Questions to ask a cover provider
- Are you authorised, and what exactly is my role under the arrangement?
- Who handles claims, and will my firm be the engineer for my customers?
- What are the exclusions, such as pre-existing faults, sludge damage or boiler age limits?
- How are complaints handled, and what is my responsibility?
- What training, records and disclosures do you need from my staff?
- What happens to my customers if the arrangement ends?
Keep your own plan a service contract. If you want to offer protection against repair costs, let an authorised firm carry that risk.
Keeping your own plan on the right side
Write the plan as a list of defined services. Say what the annual service includes, the response promise, any labour discount and the fact that repairs are quoted separately. Every service you provide under the plan must still be carried out with reasonable care and skill[5]. Avoid words such as ‘cover’, ‘protection’ or ‘peace of mind guarantee’ if they suggest you are paying for repairs, and review the wording whenever you change the benefits.
Frequently asked questions
Is a boiler service plan the same as boiler insurance?
No. A service plan provides defined services for a fee. Insurance promises to deal with uncertain repair costs for a premium. A plan that promises unlimited repairs may be treated as insurance.
Do I need FCA authorisation to sell boiler cover?
Carrying on a regulated activity requires authorisation or an exemption[1]. Many small firms sell or introduce cover under an authorised firm's responsibility instead[2]. Take specialist advice.
Can my plan include a discount on repairs?
A defined labour discount is generally lower risk than a promise to pay for repairs, but have your wording checked.
Which model earns more?
It depends on your customers. Compare income over several years, including the repair work each model brings you, not just the fee or commission per sale.
References
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2000). Financial Services and Markets Act 2000, section 19 (the general prohibition) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Financial Conduct Authority (2025). Responsibilities and how to oversee your appointed representatives (opens in a new tab) ↑
Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (GOV.UK) (2021). Consumer protection study 2022: understanding the impacts and resolution of consumer problems (opens in a new tab) ↑
Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (GOV.UK) (2021). Consumer protection study 2022: understanding the impacts and resolution of consumer problems (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 49 (opens in a new tab) ↑