Key takeaways
- Three options turn a yes-or-no decision into a choice, but only if every option is a complete, compliant installation.
- Build the tiers from one shared scope and change only a few clearly named items between them.
- Recommend one option and say why; customers value clarity and being easy to deal with[1].
- If you offer a heat pump as the top tier, be accurate: the Boiler Upgrade Scheme gives £7,500 towards one, but nothing towards a hybrid[2].
- Everything you say about each option can become a term of the contract[3], so describe the differences precisely.
Why three options work, and when they do not
A single boiler quote asks the customer one question: yes or no? Two or three options change the question to 'which one?', which is easier to answer and keeps the conversation going with you rather than with the next firm on the list. Customers also get a clearer picture of what drives the price. When they can see that a longer warranty or better controls costs a set amount more, the headline figure makes more sense.
Options backfire when they are padding. A 'good' option stripped of essentials so it looks cheap, or a 'best' option stuffed with things the customer does not need, makes the whole quote feel like a sales trick. The structure below avoids both.
What each tier should be
| Tier | Typical differences | Who it suits |
|---|---|---|
| Good | Reliable boiler sized correctly; standard programmer and thermostat; system clean suited to the system; filter; manufacturer's standard warranty | Customers who want a sound, compliant replacement at the lowest sensible price |
| Better | Same scope plus a longer warranty or higher-spec model, smart or load-compensating controls, a more thorough system clean | Most customers; usually the one you recommend |
| Best | Longest warranty, weather compensation, upgraded radiator valves or system improvements; or a low-carbon alternative such as a heat pump | Customers planning to stay long term, or interested in lower running costs and emissions |
All three tiers share the same base scope: removal and disposal, flue, condensate, gas and water connections, commissioning, notification and warranty registration. If the base scope differs between tiers, customers cannot compare them, and you risk the cheapest option being non-compliant or under-specified.
Rules for building the tiers
- Every tier must be an installation you would be happy to put your name to. No tier leaves out a filter, an adequate system clean or anything needed for the warranty.
- Change only three or four items between tiers, and name them the same way in each column.
- Keep the price steps proportionate to what changes. A large jump for a small upgrade looks like a mark-up, not a choice.
- Recommend one tier, usually the middle one, and give a one-line reason based on what the customer told you at the survey.
- Stop at three. A fourth option rarely helps and often stalls the decision.
- Keep optional extras, such as a towel rail or an extra radiator, as separate add-ons rather than building them into a tier.
Choosing the differences that matter to this customer
The best tiered quotes are built around what the customer said at the survey, not a fixed menu. Ask a few questions before you leave the house, and let the answers decide which items change between the tiers:
- How long do you expect to stay in the property? Longer stays justify longer warranties and better controls.
- Who is at home during the day? People working from home value room-by-room control and quieter running.
- How much hot water do you use at once? Busy households may need a higher-output combi or a system boiler with a cylinder.
- Are running costs or upfront cost the bigger worry right now?
- Have you thought about a heat pump or other low-carbon heating, or would you rather stick with gas for now?
- Do you already use smart home devices, or would app control be one more thing to manage?
Note the answers on the survey sheet and refer to them in the recommendation line on the quote. A customer who sees their own priorities reflected in the options is far more likely to trust the recommendation, and far less likely to see the higher tiers as upselling.
Including a low-carbon option honestly
Many heating firms now use the best tier to show a heat pump alternative. That is useful for customers, provided the facts are accurate. In England and Wales, the Boiler Upgrade Scheme gives £7,500 towards an air source or ground source heat pump, but no grant is available for a hybrid system that combines a gas boiler with an air source heat pump[2]. Heat pumps are already replacing gas boilers in large numbers: 55% of heat pump and biomass installations funded by the scheme replaced gas systems, and 18% replaced oil[4].
- Gas heating 55%
- Oil heating 18%
- No previous heating system 13%
- All other previous heating 14%
Source: Department for Energy Security and Net Zero, 2026[4]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Gas heating | 55% |
| Oil heating | 18% |
| No previous heating system | 13% |
| All other previous heating | 14% |
If you are not set up to install heat pumps, do not add one as a token option. Instead, give the customer a short note explaining that the alternative exists and where to find out more. A gas boiler remains the right choice for many homes in the near term, and an honest quote says so. Combis already dominate the stock, with 63% of homes in England having a condensing combination boiler in 2024[5], so for most customers the choice is about which combi installation, not whether to replace it.
Presenting the options on the quote
- Put the three options side by side in a short comparison table, with the shared scope listed once underneath.
- Mark your recommended option and give the reason in the customer's terms: 'Recommended because you said you want lower bills and plan to stay at least ten years.'
- Show the difference in price between tiers as well as the totals, so customers can see what each upgrade costs.
- Use plain names for the differences: 'twelve-year warranty' rather than a manufacturer's programme name.
- Keep the VAT treatment the same across tiers, with VAT-inclusive totals for domestic customers.
- Give one acceptance line per option, so the customer's choice is recorded clearly.
Describe every difference precisely
The more options you offer, the more statements you make about what each includes. Anything you say or write about the service that the customer takes into account when deciding is treated as a term of the contract[3]. If the better option says 'smart controls with app', the installation must include them. If the warranty depends on annual servicing, say so next to the warranty, not on page four. Customers increasingly weigh good value, quality and being easy to deal with when choosing who to buy from[1], and precise descriptions are part of being easy to deal with.
Scripts for walking through the options
- Opening: 'I've given you three options. They all include everything you need for a safe, compliant installation with a proper system clean and a filter. The differences are the warranty, the controls and how thorough the clean is.'
- Recommending: 'Based on what you told me, I'd go for the middle one. The longer warranty and the better controls are worth it if you're staying put.'
- If they pick the cheapest: 'That's a perfectly good installation. If you'd like the smart controls later, we can add them on a separate visit.'
- If they ask about the heat pump: 'It's a different kind of system, so it needs its own survey. I can book that, and explain the grant and what it would involve.'
Mistakes that undermine tiered quotes
- A decoy top tier priced so high nobody would choose it, which customers spot immediately.
- Removing the filter or system clean from the cheapest tier to make it look competitive.
- Different flue, condensate or gas work assumptions between tiers, so they are not comparable.
- Too many small differences that make the table hard to read.
- Engineers or office staff describing the tiers differently on the phone than on paper.
- Pressing the customer to upgrade after they have chosen; it costs more goodwill than the upgrade earns.
Track what customers choose
Record the tier on every accepted quote
Note which option was accepted and, for lost quotes, which was closest to being accepted if the customer told you.
Review every quarter
If almost everyone picks the cheapest tier, your steps may be too large or the benefits unclear. If nobody picks it, it may be too stripped back to be credible.
Adjust one thing at a time
Change the warranty, the controls or the price step, not all three, so you can see what made the difference.
Example: one survey, three options
Example: a fictional heating firm in Cheltenham surveys a three-bedroom semi with an ageing combi. The good option is a like-for-like combi with a chemical flush, filter and a standard programmable thermostat. The better option adds a longer manufacturer warranty and load-compensating smart controls. The best option is a premium combi with the longest warranty, weather compensation and new thermostatic radiator valves throughout. The quote recommends the better option because the customer works from home and wants to control heating by room. The customer chooses it, and adds an outside tap as a separate extra.
Frequently asked questions
Should I give customers options on a boiler quote?
Two or three complete options usually help customers decide, as long as each is a compliant installation and the differences are few and clearly named. Recommend one and explain why.
Can a hybrid heat pump get the Boiler Upgrade Scheme grant?
No. The scheme gives £7,500 towards an air source or ground source heat pump, but no grant is available for a hybrid system combining a gas boiler with an air source heat pump[2].
What should differ between good, better and best options?
Usually the warranty length, the controls, the thoroughness of the system clean and sometimes the boiler model. The base scope, such as flue, condensate, gas work and commissioning, should be the same in every option.
References
The Institute of Customer Service (2026). The UK Customer Satisfaction Index (UKCSI): July 2026 key findings (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (2026). Apply for the Boiler Upgrade Scheme: what you can get (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 50 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Department for Energy Security and Net Zero (2026). Boiler Upgrade Scheme (BUS) monthly statistics: England and Wales, September 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2024). English Housing Survey 2024 to 2025: Chapter 2, energy efficiency (opens in a new tab) ↑