Key takeaways
- Never match a number. Match a scope: compare the two quotes line by line before you decide anything.
- Some cheaper quotes are lower for legitimate reasons, such as a firm below the £90,000 VAT registration threshold[1].
- Others are lower because something is missing: flue, system clean, filter, notification or warranty registration.
- Around half of UK plumbers and heating installers are self-employed[2], so you are often comparing against a very different cost base.
- Decide in advance which of four responses you will use: match, part-match, re-scope or walk away.
Start with a decision, not a reaction
When a customer says someone else will do it for less, the instinct is either to drop the price on the spot or to bristle. Both cost money. The first gives away margin you may not need to give; the second loses a customer who might have chosen you once they understood the difference.
Before you look at the other quote, ask yourself three questions. Do you want this job at your price? Would you want it at a lower one? Is the customer worth more than this job, through repeat servicing, landlord portfolios or referrals? If the honest answer to the first is no, you can be generous with your time and relaxed about the outcome.
Then ask the customer, politely, if you can see the other quote or at least hear what it includes. Most will share it. Those who refuse are often using an imaginary number to negotiate, and that tells you something too.
The like-for-like checklist
Go through the rival quote with the customer, ideally with both documents on the table. The aim is not to find fault but to make sure the comparison is fair.
| Check | What to look for | Why it changes the price |
|---|---|---|
| Appliance | Exact make, model and output | Ranges differ in warranty, parts and efficiency |
| Flue | New or reused, horizontal or vertical, extensions | Flue changes can add materials and hours |
| System clean | Power flush, chemical clean or none | Dirty systems shorten a new boiler's life and can affect warranty |
| Filter and inhibitor | Included or not | Often required by manufacturer warranty terms |
| Gas supply | Pipework checked and upgraded if needed | Undersized pipes are a common hidden extra |
| Condensate | Route and protection from freezing | Poor routes cause winter breakdowns |
| Controls | Basic, programmable or smart | Big difference in parts and setting-up time |
| Notification and paperwork | Building regulations notification, commissioning record, warranty registration | Missing paperwork saves time today and causes problems at resale |
| Making good | Plastering, decorating, disposal of the old unit | Often silently excluded |
| Payment terms | Deposit, stages, balance due | Affects the customer's risk, not just the total |
Two quotes that look far apart frequently end up close once the missing items are priced in. When that happens, your job is simply to make the gap visible and let the customer decide.
Legitimate reasons a rival can be cheaper
Some cheaper quotes are perfectly honest. The plumbing and heating trade is made up of very different business models, and a firm's costs shape its price.
- Self-employed 71,200 48%
- Employees 77,400 52%
Source: Office for National Statistics (Nomis), 2026[2]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Self-employed | 71,200 |
| Employees | 77,400 |
- Tax status. A business only has to register for VAT once its taxable turnover goes over £90,000 in 12 months[1]. Thousands of plumbing and heating firms turn over between £50,000 and £99,000[3], so some rivals can quote without adding VAT at all.
- Structure. About 71,200 of the UK's 148,600 plumbers and heating installers are self-employed[2]. A sole trader working from home with one van has a different cost base from a firm with an office, staff and a showroom.
- Diary. A firm with a gap next week may price to fill it. That is a short-term offer, not a market rate.
- Supplier terms. Larger installers sometimes buy boilers on better terms, and some fit one brand only.
If the difference is explained by one of these, matching may mean working for less than your business needs. You can still win by being clear about what your structure gives the customer: someone to answer the phone, cover when an engineer is ill, and a business that will still be there for the warranty.
Reasons that should worry the customer
Other gaps come from cutting corners. Work on a gas fitting must, by law, be done by someone in a class of persons approved by HSE, which in practice means Gas Safe registration[4]. Installing or replacing a heating system can need building regulations approval[5]; when the installer is registered with a competent person scheme, the homeowner does not have to arrange that approval themselves[6]. A quote that does not mention notification may leave the customer to sort it out.
Point these out factually. ‘Their quote doesn't mention notification. It's worth asking them who handles that, because otherwise it falls to you.’ That sentence is fair to the other firm and useful to the customer.
Example: two combi quotes side by side
Example (fictional figures): a customer in Bristol has your quote and a rival's for a combi replacement. On the surface the rival is £600 lower. Line by line, the picture changes.
| Item (Example) | Your quote | Rival quote |
|---|---|---|
| Boiler and standard flue | Included | Included |
| Flue extension to clear a new window | Included | Not mentioned |
| Chemical clean and magnetic filter | Included | Filter only |
| Gas pipe upgrade from meter | Included after survey | Not mentioned |
| Notification and warranty registration | Included | Not mentioned |
| Warranty | 10 years | 7 years |
In this Example, the owner priced the three missing items for the customer and showed that the real gap was under £150, with a longer warranty on his side. He did not reduce his price; he offered to hold the date for a week. The customer accepted two days later.
Four responses, and when to use each
Match
Only when the scope is genuinely identical, you have capacity, and the customer has clear long-term value, such as a landlord with several properties. Match once, in writing, and say why.
Part-match
Meet the customer partway in exchange for something that helps you: a flexible date, a full payment on completion, a review, or a service contract.
Re-scope
Offer a lower-cost version that removes optional items, such as smart controls, while keeping everything needed for safety and warranty.
Walk away
When the only way to hit the number is to remove something essential, or the margin left would not cover a call-back.
Whatever you decide, put it in writing. Under the Consumer Rights Act 2015, a consumer who has not agreed a price only has to pay a reasonable one[7], so a revised figure agreed on the doorstep and never written down is an argument waiting to happen.
Head off the comparison before it starts
The best time to handle a cheaper quote is before the customer has one. Most homeowners getting a boiler or bathroom priced will ask two or three firms, and they will compare the totals unless you give them a better way to do it.
- Write your quote in the same order as the checklist above, so that every item has a line and a customer can tick across to another quote.
- Add a short ‘What to check in any quote’ box at the end. It looks helpful rather than defensive, and it does the comparison for you.
- Name your exclusions clearly. ‘Not included: decorating after the flue move’ is better than silence, because silence reads as a hidden extra later.
- Explain any item a customer might see as optional, such as a system clean, in one plain sentence about what goes wrong without it.
- State how long the price is held and what happens if the survey finds something unexpected.
Quotes written this way still lose sometimes, but they lose on real differences, and the customer usually comes back to you with a specific question instead of a bare number.
Track how often matching would really be needed
Keep a simple record each time a customer mentions a cheaper quote: the job type, the gap they quoted, the gap after a like-for-like comparison, what you offered and the outcome. After a few months the pattern is usually clear. Many firms find that the true gap is small on most jobs, and that the occasional large gap comes from the same one or two rivals who leave items out.
That record also tells you whether your prices have drifted. If the like-for-like gap is consistently large on one type of job, and you lose most of them, it may be time to look at your costs or your materials for that work rather than arguing quote by quote.
Saying no without losing the customer
Refusing to match is easier with a script you have practised:
‘I've been through both quotes and I think theirs leaves out the flue extension and the system clean. If they'll include those for their price, it's a good deal and you should take it. If not, I'd rather keep my price and do the job properly. Either way, I'm happy to answer any questions.’
Customers who go elsewhere after a conversation like that often come back for the next job or recommend you to someone else, because you treated them as an adult. Keep a note of the outcome in your quote log so you can see over time how often matching would actually have been necessary.
Frequently asked questions
Should I always ask to see the other quote?
Yes, politely. It is the only way to compare like for like. If the customer prefers not to share it, ask them to read out what it includes.
Is it legal for a competitor to quote without VAT?
Yes, if their taxable turnover is below the registration threshold, which is £90,000 over 12 months[1]. It is a legitimate reason for a lower price.
When is matching a cheaper quote a good idea?
When the scope is identical, you have spare capacity, and the customer brings longer-term value. Even then, ask for something in return, such as a flexible date or a service plan.
How do I point out missing items without sounding negative?
Stick to facts and questions: ‘Their quote doesn't mention notification; it's worth asking who handles it.’ Never comment on the other firm's competence.
References
GOV.UK (2026). When to register for VAT (opens in a new tab) ↑
Office for National Statistics (Nomis) (2026). Annual Population Survey - regional - occupation (SOC2020) by sex by employment type, via Nomis (opens in a new tab) ↑
Office for National Statistics (Nomis) (2026). UK Business Counts - enterprises by industry and turnover size band (SIC 2007 class 43.22), via Nomis (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (1998). The Gas Safety (Installation and Use) Regulations 1998, regulation 3 (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (2026). Building regulations approval (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (2026). Building regulations approval (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 51 (opens in a new tab) ↑