Key takeaways
- Completing the Benchmark checklist is a recognised way of meeting the commissioning requirements in Part L[1].
- The paper booklet is no longer maintained; the record now lives online and in the Benchmark apps[2].
- The combustion and gas readings mirror what the Gas Safety Regulations already require you to examine after working on an appliance[3].
- A complete record is the first thing a warranty assessor or a later engineer looks for, so fill every field with a real reading or a reason.
What the checklist is for
Benchmark has promoted quality in installing, commissioning and servicing domestic heating and hot water systems since 1999, and its own guidance describes completing the checklist as a means of meeting the commissioning requirements within Part L[1]. Approved Document L makes the same link: after setting out how heating circuits should be cleaned, treated and commissioned, it notes that the Benchmark checklist can be used to show commissioning was carried out satisfactorily[4].
That gives the checklist three jobs at once. It is evidence for building control that the system was commissioned, it is the record most manufacturers look at before accepting a warranty claim, and it is the starting point for every engineer who services or repairs the boiler afterwards. A half-completed checklist fails all three.
The paper Benchmark booklet is no longer maintained. The record has moved online and to the Benchmark apps[2], so check that every engineer has access before their next install, not on the day.
Commissioning notice: how it fits with the deadlines
Part L also expects a notice confirming commissioning has been carried out. Where the work is done by someone registered with a competent person scheme, that notice must reach building control within 30 days of completion, and the registered installer may give it themselves[4]. If the job went through a local authority building notice or an approved inspector instead, the guidance gives just five days[4].
Source: Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK), 2023[4]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Local authority building notice or full plans | 5 days |
| Approved inspector | 5 days |
| Competent person scheme | 30 days |
For most boiler replacements the competent person route applies and your scheme's notification covers it. The practical point is that the commissioning record needs to be finished at the same time as the notification, not weeks later when someone asks for it.
Customer, property and installer details
These fields look like admin, but they cause more rejected warranty claims than any reading. Use the customer's full address including postcode, the appliance serial number from the data badge, and the installer's registration number. If the property is tenanted, record both the occupier and the owner's contact.
- Serial number: copy it from the badge, not the carton, which can belong to a swapped unit.
- Install date: the day commissioning was completed, which is the date warranties and notification deadlines run from.
- Engineer and company: the person who did the commissioning, with their registration number.
- Notification reference: add it once the notification is submitted so the two records can be matched.
System preparation: cleaning, inhibitor, filter and scale
This section records whether the system was prepared as Approved Document L expects: circuits thoroughly cleaned and flushed before the new appliance went in, a suitable inhibitor added, hard water treated, and the system prepared and commissioned to BS 7593[4]. Assessors read it closely because most premature heat exchanger failures trace back to dirty or untreated water.
- Cleaning method: state which method you used and the cleaner product, not just 'flushed'.
- Inhibitor: product name and how you confirmed the dose, ideally with a test result.
- Filter: make and model, and where it is fitted on the return.
- Scale protection: the hardness you found and the device fitted, or the reason none was required.
- Photos: inhibitor bottle, filter and scale reducer, attached to the digital record where the app allows.
Controls
Record which time and temperature controls are fitted, the thermostatic room controls in each room, and, for a combi in England, which of the additional energy efficiency measures you installed. The controls field is also where you note a boiler interlock, since Approved Document L expects one whenever work is done on a system that includes a boiler[4].
Be specific. 'Smart thermostat' is not enough; give the model and confirm whether the functions that count for compliance, such as weather or load compensation, are actually enabled. A controls field that names a product but does not say how it was set up is a common gap.
Gas, combustion and safety readings
After work on a gas appliance the Gas Safety (Installation and Use) Regulations already require you to examine the effectiveness of the flue, the supply of combustion air, the operating pressure or heat input, and the appliance's operation to ensure it functions safely[3]. The Benchmark readings are the written evidence that you did.
Gas rate and pressure
Measure the working pressure at the appliance and clock the gas rate at maximum output where the meter allows, and record both.
Combustion analysis
Use a calibrated analyser at maximum and minimum rate as the manufacturer instructs, and record carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide and the ratio.
Flue checks
Record that flue integrity, terminal position and any flue gas spillage tests required for the appliance type have been completed.
Safety devices
Confirm the operation of safety devices and that the condensate trap was filled before firing.
Analyser details
Note the analyser model and its calibration date, which some assessors ask for.
If a reading is outside the manufacturer's range, do not leave the field blank or write a normal-looking number. Record what you found, what you adjusted and the final reading. The history is often useful to the next engineer.
Hot water, condensate and handover
For combis, record the hot water flow rate and outlet temperature you measured, and the cold inlet temperature on the day. Those three numbers answer most later complaints about hot water. For cylinder systems, record the cylinder type and the temperature and controls setting.
Record how condensate is disposed of: internal connection to a stack or waste, external run, soakaway or pump, and how any external section is protected from freezing. Then confirm handover: that the customer was shown how to use the controls, given the user instructions and told when the first service is due.
Worked Example: a record that saved a dispute
Example. Eighteen months after an install, a customer reports noisy heating and the manufacturer's engineer finds sludge in the heat exchanger. The manufacturer initially queries whether the system was cleaned.
Example. The installer's digital record shows a chemical clean with a named product, a photo of the inhibitor bottle, an inhibitor test result at commissioning and a magnetic filter. The service record shows the first annual service was missed. The question shifts from installation to maintenance, and the installer is not asked to pay for the repair. Without the record the installer would have had no answer.
The gaps that come up again and again
If you audit a sample of your own records, the same weaknesses tend to appear. Fixing them is mostly about habit, so pick the three most common in your firm and focus on those for a month.
- Readings copied from the previous job or from the manufacturer's typical values rather than measured on the day.
- Water treatment recorded as 'yes' with no product, method or test result.
- Controls recorded by type only, with no note of whether compensation or optimisation functions were switched on.
- Hot water flow rate missing on combis, which leaves nothing to compare with when a customer later reports poor flow.
- Condensate route not described, so nobody knows whether an external section was insulated.
- Handover section left blank because the customer was not home when the engineer finished.
- Records completed days later from memory, with the wrong install date.
A quick monthly check of five random records by the owner or a senior engineer catches most of these before an assessor does, and it shows engineers that the record is read, which is usually enough to raise the standard.
Service record: the part that keeps warranties alive
Every service after commissioning should be logged in the same record: the date, the engineer, the combustion readings, the inhibitor check and any parts replaced. Many manufacturer warranties require an annual service, and the service record is how the customer proves it happened.
- Log every service, even on boilers you did not install.
- Record inhibitor test results and any top-up, not just 'checked'.
- Note advice you gave, such as a recommendation to replace a filter or fit scale protection.
- Remind customers that the record follows the boiler when they sell the house.
For the steps that come after commissioning, see notifying a boiler install and registering boiler warranties.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Benchmark checklist a legal requirement?
The law requires commissioning and notice to building control. Benchmark is a recognised way of showing commissioning was done and is widely expected by manufacturers for warranties.
Can I still use the paper booklet?
The paper checklist and service record are no longer maintained. Use the online record or the Benchmark apps.
What combustion readings should I record?
Follow the manufacturer's instructions, usually carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide and the ratio at maximum and minimum rate, plus gas pressure and rate.
Who fills in the service record?
The engineer who carries out each service, whoever installed the boiler.
References
The Benchmark Scheme (2026). Benchmark: quality in domestic heating and hot water (opens in a new tab) ↑
Heating and Hotwater Industry Council (HHIC) (2026). Benchmark goes digital - what homeowners need to know (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (1998). The Gas Safety (Installation and Use) Regulations 1998, regulation 26 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2023). Approved Document L, Volume 1: Dwellings (2021 edition incorporating 2023 amendments) (opens in a new tab) ↑