Tax finance admin

HMRC compliance checks: what trades should expect

What happens when HMRC opens a compliance check on a plumbing business: common triggers, the records to have ready, penalties and how to respond calmly.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. What a compliance check is
  2. Why small trade firms get checked
  3. Common triggers in plumbing and heating
  4. When the letter arrives: a calm response
  5. What happens during the check
  6. Penalties and how to reduce them
  7. The records that make a check easy
  8. After the check
  9. Professional help and the cost of a check
  10. Example: a CIS mismatch resolved
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • HMRC can check any tax you pay, your accounts, your Self Assessment or Company Tax Return and your PAYE records[1].
  • Small businesses account for 62% of the UK tax gap, which is why HMRC's compliance work focuses on them[2].
  • Penalties for careless errors range from 0% to 30% of the extra tax, and telling HMRC about an error yourself reduces them[3].
  • If you owe more after a check you are normally asked to pay within 30 days, with interest from the original due date[1].
  • Good weekly records are the best defence: they turn a check into a paperwork exercise rather than an argument.

What a compliance check is

A compliance check is HMRC making sure you are paying the right amount of tax. It can cover any tax you pay, your accounts and tax calculations, your Self Assessment or Company Tax Return, and your PAYE records if you employ people[1]. HMRC will write or phone to say what it wants to check. If you use an accountant who is authorised to act for you, HMRC contacts them instead[1].

Most checks are narrow. HMRC may ask about one figure on a return, one VAT period or one expense category. Some are wider and look at several years. Either way, a check is not an accusation. Many end with no change, or with a small adjustment, and the outcome depends heavily on how organised your records are and how you respond.

Why small trade firms get checked

HMRC estimates the UK tax gap, the difference between the tax that should be paid and what is actually paid, at 6.4% of total theoretical liabilities, or £59.2 billion, in 2024 to 2025[2]. Small businesses make up the largest share of that gap by customer group, at 62%[2]. That is why compliance work spends so much time on sole traders and small companies, including construction trades.

Share of the UK tax gap by customer group, 2024 to 2025Provisional estimates; shares may not sum to 100 because of rounding
Share of the UK tax gap by customer group, 2024 to 2025Bar chart. Small businesses: 62%; Large businesses: 12%; Criminals: 8%; Mid-sized businesses: 7%; Wealthy individuals: 6%; Individuals: 4%.Small businessesSmall businesses: 62%62%Large businessesLarge businesses: 12%12%CriminalsCriminals: 8%8%Mid-sized businessesMid-sized businesses: 7%7%Wealthy individualsWealthy individuals: 6%6%IndividualsIndividuals: 4%4%Share of the UK tax gap by customer group, 2024 to 2025Bar chart. Small businesses: 62%; Large businesses: 12%; Criminals: 8%; Mid-sized businesses: 7%; Wealthy individuals: 6%; Individuals: 4%.Small businessesSmall businesses: 62%62%Large businessesLarge businesses: 12%12%CriminalsCriminals: 8%8%Mid-sized businessesMid-sized businesses: 7%7%Wealthy individualsWealthy individuals: 6%6%IndividualsIndividuals: 4%4%

Source: HM Revenue & Customs (GOV.UK), 2026[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
Small businesses62%
Large businesses12%
Criminals8%
Mid-sized businesses7%
Wealthy individuals6%
Individuals4%

None of that means a plumbing firm is presumed to be doing anything wrong. It means checks are a normal part of running a small business, and that being able to show your workings quickly matters.

Common triggers in plumbing and heating

  • CIS figures that do not match. Contractors report what they paid you and what they deducted. If your return shows different income or deductions, expect questions. Deductions are taken at 20% or 30%, so the figures are easy to cross-check[4].
  • Turnover sitting just under the VAT threshold year after year. Registration is compulsory once taxable turnover for the last 12 months goes over £90,000[5], and HMRC looks at businesses that appear to manage around it.
  • Cash jobs. Cash is legal, but income that appears in your lifestyle and not in your records is a classic issue. Bank all cash and record it against an invoice.
  • Large or unusual expense claims, such as a van claimed as entirely business use while it is clearly the family car, or home costs out of line with the business.
  • Labour-only subcontractors who look like employees. HMRC can query whether the people you pay are genuinely self-employed.
  • Late or missing returns, which suggest the books are not under control.

When the letter arrives: a calm response

  1. Read it carefully

    Note exactly which tax, which period and which documents HMRC wants, and the deadline. Do not send more than is asked for.

  2. Call your accountant

    Send them a copy the same day. If you do not have one, consider getting help now; you can have an accountant or legal adviser with you at any visit[1].

  3. Gather the records

    Pull together the bank statements, invoices, receipts, CIS statements and mileage logs for the period. Check them before they go.

  4. Look for errors yourself

    If you find a mistake, tell HMRC through your adviser. Disclosure can reduce any penalty[3].

  5. Reply on time

    Meet the deadline or ask for more time before it passes. Ignoring an information notice can itself lead to a penalty[1].

  6. Keep a log

    Record every call and letter with dates and names. It helps if anything is disputed later.

What happens during the check

HMRC may ask to visit your home, business premises or your adviser's office, or ask you to visit them[1]. Visits are usually arranged in advance. Expect questions about how the business works: how you price, how customers pay, who does the books, how you record cash and how the van is used.

If HMRC sends an inspection or information notice and you do not provide the information or you refuse a visit, you may have to pay a penalty, unless you have a reasonable excuse such as serious illness or a bereavement[1]. If you think HMRC should stop the check, you can write to the office that sent the letter with your reasons. You can apply for alternative dispute resolution at any time if you disagree with HMRC's decision or what it is checking[1].

Penalties and how to reduce them

If a check finds a mistake in a return, HMRC links any penalty to the reason for the error. The more serious the behaviour, the higher the possible penalty[3].

Penalty ranges for inaccuracies in returns or documents, as set out by HMRC[3].
Reason for the errorPenalty range, as a share of the extra tax
Lack of reasonable care (careless)0% to 30%
Deliberate20% to 70%
Deliberate and concealed30% to 100%

Penalties can be reduced if you tell HMRC about the error, and HMRC may reduce them further depending on the quality of your disclosure: telling, helping and giving access to records[3]. A genuine mistake despite taking reasonable care should not attract a penalty at all. That is the practical value of tidy books: they show reasonable care.

The records that make a check easy

  • Bank statements for every business account, matched to invoices and bills.
  • Sales invoices in number order, with cash and card payments recorded against them.
  • Merchant invoices and statements, with credit notes.
  • CIS payment and deduction statements, and your own CIS returns if you pay subcontractors.
  • A mileage log separating business and private use of each vehicle.
  • Payroll records, if you employ anyone, and evidence of subcontractors' status checks.
  • Digital records and quarterly updates if you are in Making Tax Digital for Income Tax, which began for sole traders with qualifying income over £50,000 in April 2026[6].

Our guide to setting money aside for your tax bill covers the other half of being ready: having the money if a check finds extra tax.

After the check

HMRC writes to tell you the result. If you have paid too much, you are repaid and may get interest. If you owe more, you are normally asked to pay within 30 days, with interest from the date the tax was originally due, and you may also have to pay a penalty[1]. HMRC looks at why the tax was underpaid, whether you told it as soon as you could and how helpful you were during the check.

If you have problems paying, tell the officer dealing with the check. If you disagree with the decision, you can appeal[1]. Then fix the cause: a new bookkeeping routine, a different van policy or a proper status check for subcontractors. Our guide to Self Assessment deadlines helps you stay on top of the dates that often trigger checks in the first place.

Professional help and the cost of a check

Even a short check takes time: finding records, answering questions and meeting deadlines in the middle of a working week. Accountants usually charge for this work separately from the annual accounts unless it is included in your engagement. Some offer fee protection insurance, which covers their fees for dealing with a check. Ask what is covered, what is excluded and whether it applies to checks that are already open before you sign up.

Whether or not you insure, the cheapest protection is the same: books kept weekly, records filed by tax year, and an accountant who already understands CIS and VAT for trades, so a check starts from a clear set of figures.

Example: a CIS mismatch resolved

Example (fictional): HMRC writes to a sole trader heating engineer in Leicester asking why the CIS deductions on his return are higher than the figures his contractors reported. His accountant asks for his monthly statements and finds that one builder issued a statement for a payment that was later reversed after a dispute.

Example: the accountant sends HMRC the statements, the builder's credit note and a corrected figure within the deadline. The difference is small, the error was not careless, and the check closes with a minor adjustment and no penalty. The engineer now ticks every statement against his invoices each month.

Frequently asked questions

How far back can HMRC check a plumber's tax?

It depends on the check and the reason for any error. That is one reason HMRC requires sole traders to keep business records for at least 5 years after the 31 January filing deadline. Ask your accountant about your specific case.

Will HMRC visit my home?

It may ask to visit your home, business or your adviser's office, or ask you to visit them. You can have an accountant or legal adviser with you.

Do I have to pay a penalty if I made an honest mistake?

Not if you took reasonable care. Careless errors can bring a penalty of up to 30% of the extra tax, reduced if you tell HMRC and help with the check.

Should I get an accountant if HMRC opens a check?

It is usually worth it. An adviser can deal with HMRC for you, keep the check to its proper scope and present your records clearly.

References

  1. GOV.UK (2026). Tax compliance checks (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. HM Revenue & Customs (GOV.UK) (2026). Measuring tax gaps 2026 edition: tax gap summary (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. HM Revenue & Customs (GOV.UK) (2026). Penalties: an overview for agents and advisers (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. GOV.UK (2026). What you must do as a CIS subcontractor: get paid (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. GOV.UK (2026). When to register for VAT (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. GOV.UK (2026). Check if you're eligible for Making Tax Digital for Income Tax (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo