Key takeaways
- Claim decline and claim delay were the top reasons for buildings insurance complaints to the Financial Ombudsman in early 2024/25[1].
- Your report answers three questions for the insurer: what failed, when it probably started, and what you did to stop it.
- Keep trace and access work (finding the leak and making good) separate from the repair of the pipe or fitting on every invoice.
- Write only what you saw and tested. Never guess dates or causes to help a claim through.
Why your paperwork decides how the claim goes
When a pipe bursts or a fitting fails, the customer's first call is usually to you and the second to their insurer. The claims handler then asks for something most plumbers have never been trained to write: a report that explains the cause of the escape of water in terms a policy can be tested against. A vague note such as "leak fixed" leaves the handler with nothing to work from, and gaps in evidence are where declines and delays start.
The Financial Ombudsman Service saw 2,001 buildings insurance complaints in April to June 2024/25, 13% more than the same quarter a year earlier[1]. Claim decline accounted for 41% of those complaints, claim delay 23% and claim value 8%[1]. You cannot control an insurer's decision, but a clear engineer's report removes one common reason for both.
It also protects you. Households already report problems with home repair trades: 11% of people who bought home and garden maintenance and repair services in a year had a consumer problem[2]. When the customer, the insurer and a loss adjuster all read your report, it is your record of what you found and that you worked with reasonable care and skill, which the Consumer Rights Act 2015 requires[3].
On site: evidence in the first half hour
- Make safe first. Isolate water and, if water has reached electrics, keep everyone away from wet sockets and fittings until the supply is isolated by someone competent.
- Photograph before you touch anything: the failed item in place, water marks, the ceiling or floor below, and the stop tap position.
- Note the time you arrived, what the customer says they noticed and when, and when water was isolated.
- Record the cause as you find it: split pipe, failed compression joint, perished flexible hose, cracked cistern, seized valve. Keep the failed part in a labelled bag if it is removable.
- Write down signs of how long the leak has been running, such as staining, rot, corrosion or mould, without putting a date on it you cannot support.
- Photograph the repair and the area after drying has started, then give the customer a copy of every photo the same day.
Keep the failed part. Loss adjusters and manufacturers often want to see a burst hose or failed valve, and a part thrown in the van bin cannot be inspected later.
The report insurers can actually use
A one-page report with fixed headings is enough for most domestic claims. Use the same template every time so office staff can produce it from the job sheet without the engineer rewriting it at night.
| Heading | What to write | Why the handler needs it |
|---|---|---|
| Property and policyholder | Address, customer name, who was present | Matches your report to the claim |
| Attendance | Date and times of call, arrival, isolation, completion | Shows the escape was dealt with promptly |
| Cause of escape | The failed component and how it failed, in one or two sentences | Policies cover sudden escapes differently from wear and gradual seepage |
| Evidence of duration | What you observed, not a guessed date | Gradual damage is often treated differently |
| Trace and access | How the leak was located and what had to be opened up | Often a separate section or limit of cover |
| Repair carried out | Parts, method and test result | Separates the repair from consequential damage |
| Further work | Making good, drying, other trades needed | Lets the insurer appoint drying or building contractors |
Use plain, specific sentences. "The 15mm compression joint under the bath had pulled apart; olive not seated; water had run along the joist into the kitchen ceiling" tells a handler far more than "bath leak". If you could not find the cause, say what you tested and ruled out, and recommend specialist leak detection rather than guessing.
Trace and access: wording that matters
Many home policies treat the cost of finding a hidden leak and reinstating what was opened up, usually called trace and access, differently from the cost of repairing the pipe or fitting itself. Limits and exclusions vary, so you should never tell a customer what their policy covers. What you can do is keep the costs apart so the insurer can apply its own wording.
- Itemise locating the leak (testing, thermal imaging, acoustic work) separately from the repair.
- Itemise opening up (lifting floorboards, cutting plasterboard, removing tiles) separately from making good.
- Describe what you had to disturb and why, so the insurer can see the access was necessary.
- If damage was found during access that is unrelated to the leak, say so on a separate line.
The pattern matters because damp and leak damage can go unnoticed for a long time. The English Housing Survey found 1.4 million dwellings in England had a damp problem in 2024[4]. When you open a floor and find old staining as well as a fresh escape, record both honestly.
What to say to the customer
Script: "I can tell you what failed and give you a written report with photos for your insurer. I can't tell you whether your policy covers it; only they can. Ring them today, give them my report, and ask whether they want their own contractor or a loss adjuster to see the damage before anything is stripped out."
That last question prevents a common fight: the customer strips a soaked kitchen ceiling, then the insurer asks why the damage was not seen first. Make-safe work is always fine. Beyond that, let the customer get the insurer's agreement in writing before you remove or replace anything large.
Be clear about who pays you. In most domestic jobs your contract is with the customer, who claims the cost back. Put that on the invoice, take payment as you normally would for the repair, and do not wait months for an insurer you never agreed terms with.
Example: a burst under a kitchen floor
Example: a customer calls on a Sunday evening with water coming up through laminate. The engineer isolates at the stop tap, photographs the floor, and uses a thermal camera to trace a warm line from the boiler towards the sink. Two boards are lifted and a split in a buried section of pipe is found and replaced.
Example, continued: the report lists arrival and isolation times, the split as the cause, the thermal images as the trace method, the two boards as access and the pipe section as the repair, each on its own line. The customer's insurer accepts the report without sending an adjuster, and the firm's invoice is paid by the customer within the week.
When a loss adjuster or drying firm gets involved
On larger escapes the insurer may send a loss adjuster, appoint a drying company or bring in its own building contractor. None of that cancels your role. The adjuster will usually want to speak to whoever found the cause, so keep your phone number on the report and answer their questions the same day if you can.
Drying firms often need to know where water travelled and whether the leak is definitely stopped before they install equipment. Tell them which pipes you isolated, what you pressure tested and whether any part of the system is still drained down. If you have advised that a second fault needs attention, such as a corroded section close to the repair, put that in writing to the customer so it is not lost between contractors.
Why reports get queried
Claims handlers come back with questions for a handful of predictable reasons. Check every report against this list before it leaves the office:
- The cause is missing or written as a symptom, such as "water on floor", rather than the failed component.
- Times are missing, so nobody can tell how quickly the escape was stopped.
- Photos show the repair but not the failure or the damage before work started.
- Trace and access, repair and making good are bundled into one figure.
- The report suggests a date the leak started without evidence to support it.
- The customer's name or address differs from the policy, often on rented or inherited homes.
Honesty is not optional
Occasionally a customer asks you to write that a leak was sudden when it was clearly gradual, or to add damage that was there before. Say no, plainly and politely. Your name sits on that report, and the same insurers and loss adjusters will read the next one. A reputation for reports that hold up is worth more than one grateful customer.
Frequently asked questions
What should a plumber's report for an escape of water claim include?
Attendance times, the failed component and how it failed, what you saw about how long it had been leaking, how the leak was found, what was opened up, the repair, and any further work needed, with photos.
Can a plumber tell me whether my insurance covers a leak?
No. Only the insurer can apply the policy wording. Your plumber can give you a clear report and photos so the insurer can decide quickly.
What is trace and access?
It usually means finding a hidden leak and opening up and making good the building to reach it. Many policies treat it separately from repairing the pipe itself, so ask for these costs to be itemised.
Should I strip out wet ceilings before the insurer visits?
Make the area safe first, then ask the insurer before removing anything large. Photos of the damage before stripping help the claim either way.
References
Financial Ombudsman Service (2024). Buildings insurance complaints hit a 10-year high (opens in a new tab) ↑
Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (GOV.UK) (2021). Consumer protection study 2022: understanding the impacts and resolution of consumer problems (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 49 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK) (2024). English Housing Survey 2024 to 2025: Chapter 1, housing quality (opens in a new tab) ↑