Key takeaways
- Every consumer service contract includes a term that you will perform the service with reasonable care and skill[1].
- If no price or time was agreed, the customer pays a reasonable price and the work must be done within a reasonable time[2][3].
- When work falls short, the customer can require you to put it right at your own cost, or claim a price reduction[4][5].
- You cannot use your terms to exclude liability for care and skill[6].
The duties built into every job
When you agree to do work for a householder, the Consumer Rights Act 2015 writes several terms into the contract whether or not you mention them. They apply to a five-minute tap washer as much as to a full heating system, and they apply whether the agreement was a signed quote, a text message or a conversation on the doorstep.
| Duty | Where it comes from | What it means for a plumber | How to show you met it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reasonable care and skill | Section 49 | Work to the standard of a competent plumber, following regulations and manufacturer instructions | Commissioning records, photos, certificates, test results |
| Reasonable price | Section 51 | If no price or pricing method was agreed, the customer pays a reasonable price | A clear quote or day rate agreed before starting |
| Reasonable time | Section 52 | If no time was agreed, the work is done within a reasonable time | Agreed start and finish dates, updates when things change |
| Remedies | Sections 54 to 56 | If the service falls short, the customer can require repeat performance or a price reduction | A complaints routine that offers to put things right quickly |
The Act applies to contracts between a trader and a consumer. Work for landlords who are companies, letting agents acting for businesses, or builders is usually business-to-business and falls under different rules, though many of the same expectations apply in practice.
Reasonable care and skill in practice
Section 49 says every contract to supply a service is treated as including a term that the trader must perform the service with reasonable care and skill[1]. The standard is not perfection. It is what a reasonably competent plumber would do in the same circumstances, judged against industry practice, regulations, British Standards and manufacturer instructions.
That means the evidence of your care is usually your paperwork. A boiler commissioned without flue gas readings, a pressure test that was not recorded, or an unvented cylinder fitted without the discharge arrangements in the instructions are all hard to defend if a customer complains. Conversely, a well-documented job is easy to stand behind even when something fails later for reasons outside your control.
- Follow the manufacturer's installation instructions and keep them with the job file.
- Record commissioning and test results, not just a tick on a form.
- Photograph concealed work before it is covered.
- Note any limits you agreed with the customer, such as working around an existing fault you were not asked to fix.
Reasonable time and price when nothing was agreed
Emergency call-outs often start without a clear price or timetable. The Act fills that gap. Where the contract does not fix a price or a method for working it out, the consumer must pay a reasonable price, and no more[2]. Where it does not fix a time, the service must be performed within a reasonable time[3].
Reasonable is decided on the facts, so leaving it open invites a dispute. The fix is simple: state your call-out charge, hourly rate and any out-of-hours supplement before you arrive, by phone or text, and agree an approximate time for the visit. If the job grows once you are on site, explain the extra work and price before doing it. A customer who agreed a price in advance has much less room to argue that it was unreasonable.
When something goes wrong: the remedies
If a service does not conform to the contract, section 54 gives the consumer two core rights: the right to require repeat performance and the right to a price reduction[4]. These do not stop the consumer seeking other remedies, such as damages or treating the contract as at an end, but they cannot recover twice for the same loss[4].
Repeat performance first
The customer can require you to perform the service again, as far as needed to make it conform. You must do it within a reasonable time and without significant inconvenience to them, and you bear the necessary costs, including labour and materials.
Price reduction if repeat performance fails or is impossible
If putting it right is impossible, or you do not do it within a reasonable time or without significant inconvenience, the customer can claim an appropriate reduction in the price, up to the full amount.
Other remedies
In some cases a customer can claim damages for losses caused, such as water damage to ceilings, through negotiation, an ADR scheme or the courts.
The repeat performance rules come from section 55: the trader must redo the service within a reasonable time and without significant inconvenience, bearing any necessary costs, including labour and materials[5]. The consumer cannot require it if completing the service in line with the contract is impossible[5]. What is reasonable depends on the nature of the service and its purpose[5]. A failed heating repair in January calls for a faster return than a dripping outside tap in June.
What your terms cannot do
Some firms try to limit their exposure with clauses such as no liability for workmanship after one month. Section 57 stops that. A term is not binding on the consumer to the extent that it would exclude your liability for reasonable care and skill[6]. A term that restricts that liability is also not binding if it would stop the consumer, in an appropriate case, from recovering the price paid[6].
You can still set out sensible terms: what is included, how variations are priced, payment timings and what happens if the customer supplies their own parts. You just cannot use them to remove the basic statutory duties. Our guide to writing terms and conditions covers fair drafting.
Goods you supply as part of the job
Most plumbing jobs mix a service with goods: the boiler, cylinder, taps or valves you supply and fit. The Act treats the goods side separately. Goods must be of satisfactory quality, fit for purpose and as described, and the customer has distinct remedies if they are not, including repair or replacement. Where a fault appears, the first question is therefore whether the problem lies in the product, in your installation, or in both.
That distinction shapes your response. A boiler with a faulty component is usually a manufacturer warranty matter, though the customer may still look to you as the supplier. A boiler that fails because the flue was fitted badly is your workmanship. Keep product details, serial numbers and commissioning records for every job, so you can tell the two apart quickly and deal with the right party.
Why this matters commercially
Problems with trades are common and costly. A government study found that 25% of UK adults bought home and garden maintenance and repair services, which include plumbing and central heating, in the 12 months to April 2021, and 11% of those buyers had a consumer problem[7].
- Had a consumer problem 11%
Source: Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (GOV.UK), 2022[7]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Had a consumer problem | 11% |
£109
Median net monetised consumer detriment per problem in house and garden maintenance and repair, among the ten highest of any UK sector[7]
Behind those numbers are customers who tell friends, leave reviews and, increasingly, know their rights. Firms that handle complaints by offering to put things right quickly turn most of them into neutral or even positive stories.
Example: a leaking joint three weeks later
Example: a plumber in Southampton replaces a kitchen sink waste and supply pipes. Three weeks later the customer reports a slow drip from a compression joint under the sink, which has marked the cupboard base. The plumber returns the next morning, remakes the joint, dries the area and photographs the finished repair. No charge is made for the visit or materials, because this is repeat performance of work that did not conform.
The customer asks about the stained cupboard base. The plumber offers to replace the base panel at cost of materials only, which the customer accepts. The firm logs the complaint, the cause and the fix, and adds a step to its checklist: run water through new joints for ten minutes and recheck before leaving. The customer later leaves a review mentioning how quickly the problem was sorted.
Phrases that help, and ones that hurt
- Helps: Thanks for telling us. We will come back and put it right at no charge.
- Helps: Here is what we found, what caused it, and what we have done.
- Helps: If you are not happy with that, here is how to take it further.
- Hurts: That is outside our guarantee, so it will cost you.
- Hurts: It worked when we left, so it is not our problem.
- Hurts: Our terms say we are not liable for that.
The customer does not need to cite the Act to rely on it. Train your team to respond as if they had.
Frequently asked questions
Does the Consumer Rights Act apply to small plumbing jobs?
Yes. Any contract between a trader and a consumer to supply a service includes the duty to use reasonable care and skill, however small the job.
Can a customer refuse to pay if they think my price is too high?
If a price was agreed, that price applies. If no price or method was agreed, the customer must pay a reasonable price, so agreeing your rates before starting avoids disputes.
Do I have to come back and fix faulty work for free?
If the work did not conform to the contract, the customer can require repeat performance, and you must bear the necessary costs, including labour and materials.
Can my terms limit my liability for workmanship?
Not for reasonable care and skill. A term that excludes that liability is not binding on the consumer, and limits that stop them recovering the price paid are not binding either.
References
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 49 (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 51 (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 52 (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 54: consumer's rights to enforce terms about services (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 55: right to repeat performance (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 57: liability that cannot be excluded or restricted (opens in a new tab) ↑
Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (GOV.UK) (2022). Consumer protection study 2022: understanding the impacts and resolution of consumer problems (opens in a new tab) ↑