Tax finance admin

Taking on subcontractors: your CIS contractor duties

What a plumbing firm must do under CIS once it pays subcontractors: verifying, deducting, statements, paying HMRC, monthly returns, penalties and records.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. When a plumbing firm becomes a contractor
  2. The monthly cycle at a glance
  3. Verifying a new subcontractor
  4. Working out the deduction
  5. Monthly returns, nil returns and penalties
  6. Status: are they really self-employed?
  7. Records to keep
  8. Mistakes small contractors make
  9. Example: a first year as a contractor
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References

Key takeaways

  • Paying another trade to do construction work for you makes you a CIS contractor, even if you are a subcontractor yourself[1].
  • Verify every new subcontractor with HMRC before the first payment; HMRC tells you whether to deduct 20%, 30% or nothing[2].
  • Pay deductions to HMRC by the 22nd of each month and file the monthly return by the 19th, even when it is a nil return[2].
  • A late return costs £100 from day one, and getting a subcontractor's employment status wrong can cost up to £3,000[2].
  • Keep CIS records for at least 3 years after the end of the tax year they relate to[2].

When a plumbing firm becomes a contractor

You must register as a CIS contractor if you pay subcontractors for construction work[1]. For a plumbing or heating firm that usually happens the day you bring in a self-employed plumber to help on a busy week, sublet an electrical connection to an electrician, or pay a labour-only fitter by the job. If you also work for builders as a subcontractor, you register as both[1].

Most firms in this trade are small: about 95% of registered plumbing, heating and air-conditioning enterprises have fewer than 10 employees[3]. That means the person doing the CIS admin is often the owner, at night. Build a routine once and it takes about an hour a month.

Businesses that do not do construction work become deemed contractors once they spend more than £3 million on construction in 12 months[1]. That rule is aimed at housing associations and councils, not at trade firms.

The monthly cycle at a glance

  1. Verify before the first payment

    Check each new subcontractor with HMRC through the free CIS online service or commercial software. HMRC tells you the deduction rate[2].

  2. Deduct when you pay

    Take the CIS percentage from the labour element of each invoice, after removing VAT and materials[4].

  3. Issue statements

    Give each subcontractor a payment and deduction statement within 14 days of the end of each tax month[4].

  4. Pay HMRC

    Pay the month's deductions by the 22nd, or the 19th if you pay by post, alongside any PAYE and National Insurance[2].

  5. File the return

    Send the monthly return by the 19th following the end of the tax month, declaring the subcontractors are not employees[2].

Tax months run from the 6th of one month to the 5th of the next. So for the month 6 May to 5 June, statements and the return are due by 19 June[2].

Verifying a new subcontractor

You need your own UTR, your HMRC accounts office reference and your employer reference. From the subcontractor you need their UTR plus their National Insurance number if they are a sole trader, or company name, company UTR and registration number if they trade through a company[2]. HMRC will not verify temporary National Insurance numbers, and the details must match exactly what the subcontractor registered with.

You must also re-verify subcontractors you have used before if they have not appeared on one of your CIS returns in the current or last 2 tax years[2]. Collect the details before anyone sets foot on site with a simple onboarding message:

Script: 'Before your first job with us we need to verify you for CIS. Please send your full legal name or company name as registered with HMRC, your UTR, and your National Insurance number or company number. We cannot pay you until HMRC has confirmed your rate.'

Working out the deduction

Start with the gross invoice. Take away VAT, materials the subcontractor paid for, consumable stores, fuel (except for travelling), plant hired for the job and any prefabricated materials. Then apply the rate HMRC gave you: 20% for registered subcontractors, 30% for unregistered ones and nothing for those with gross payment status[4]. You can ask for receipts for materials, and estimate them if the subcontractor has none.

Example (fictional) CIS calculation on a subcontractor invoice, following HMRC's deduction rules.
Invoice lineExample amountDeducted?
Labour, 4 days second fix£1,200Yes, at the verified rate
Copper, fittings and valves bought by the subcontractor£380No, materials paid for directly
Hired pipe freezing kit for the job£45No, plant hire
VAT£325No
Deduction at 20%£240Pay to HMRC by the 22nd

Monthly returns, nil returns and penalties

File a return every month. If you paid no subcontractors, either file a nil return or tell HMRC you have temporarily stopped using subcontractors with an inactivity request[2]. You can ask for the scheme to be made inactive for up to 6 months if you know there will be no payments[4]. Forgetting a quiet month is the most common way small firms collect penalties.

Penalty for a late CIS monthly returnAt 6 and 12 months the penalty is £300 or 5% of the CIS deductions on the return, whichever is higher
Penalty for a late CIS monthly returnColumn chart. 1 day late: £100; 2 months late: £200; 6 months late: £300; 12 months late: £300.£0£100£200£3001 day late: £100£1001 day late2 months late: £200£2002 months late6 months late: £300£3006 months late12 months late: £300£30012 months latePenalty for a late CIS monthly returnColumn chart. 1 day late: £100; 2 months late: £200; 6 months late: £300; 12 months late: £300.£0£100£200£3001 day late: £100£1001 daylate2 months late: £200£2002 monthslate6 months late: £300£3006 monthslate12 months late: £300£30012monthslate

Source: GOV.UK, 2026[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
1 day late£100
2 months late£200
6 months late£300
12 months late£300

Penalties rise with lateness, and for returns more than 12 months late HMRC can add up to £3,000 or 100% of the deductions on the return, whichever is higher[2]. You can appeal within 30 days of the penalty notice if you have a reasonable excuse, online or in writing, but not by phone.

Status: are they really self-employed?

Each monthly return includes your declaration that the people listed are not employees. A wrong employment status can bring a penalty of up to £3,000[2], and both of you may face unpaid tax if the status is wrong[5]. CIS registration does not make someone self-employed. What matters is how the work is actually done.

  • Signs of self-employment: they quote or bid for jobs, work without direct supervision, invoice you, pay their own tax and do not get holiday or sick pay[5].
  • Warning signs: they work only for you, on your hours, in your van, with your tools, are told how to do each task and cannot send someone else.
  • Use HMRC's employment status check for each engagement and keep the result on file.
  • If the honest answer is employee, put them on payroll. Our guide to what an employee really costs helps you budget for it.

Records to keep

Keep the gross amount of each subcontractor invoice excluding VAT, the deductions you made and, where you made deductions, the materials cost invoiced to you. Keep them for at least 3 years after the end of the tax year they relate to. HMRC can ask to see them at any time and can fine you up to £3,000 if you cannot produce them[2].

Labour-only subcontractors are an allowable cost of your business, so the same records support your own expense claims. See allowable expenses for plumbers.

Mistakes small contractors make

  • Paying a new subcontractor on the day before verifying them, then guessing the rate. If you deduct too little, HMRC can ask you for the shortfall.
  • Deducting from the whole invoice, including materials and VAT, which breaches the rules and sours the relationship[4].
  • Skipping the return in a quiet month instead of filing a nil return or an inactivity request[2].
  • Sending statements late or not at all. Subcontractors need them to claim their deductions back, and the 14-day deadline is set by HMRC[4].
  • Paying deductions on the 22nd by a method that takes days to clear. Pay early enough that the money reaches HMRC on time[2].
  • Keeping CIS records only in the subcontractor's emails. Save invoices, statements and verification references in one folder per tax year.

Many of these come from doing CIS in a rush at the end of the month. Put a fixed slot in the diary, ideally between the 10th and the 15th, so there is time to chase missing invoices before the deadlines.

Example: a first year as a contractor

Example (fictional): a heating engineer in Bristol takes on two self-employed plumbers for a run of social housing boiler swaps. She registers as a contractor, verifies both before their first day, and sets a reminder for the 15th of each month to reconcile invoices, the 18th to file and the 20th to pay.

In August the work pauses for three weeks and nobody is paid. She files a nil return rather than skipping the month. In October one plumber stops invoicing her, starts using her van full time and asks for holiday. She runs the status check again, decides he is now in substance an employee and moves him onto payroll from November.

Example: by the end of the year her records are simple. Each subcontractor has a folder with their verification reference, every invoice, every statement she issued and the status check she ran. When her accountant prepares the year-end accounts, the labour-only costs reconcile to the CIS returns to the penny, and nothing has to be reconstructed from bank statements.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need to register as a contractor if I only use one subcontractor occasionally?

Yes. If you pay a subcontractor for construction work, you must register as a contractor, verify them and file monthly returns for the months you are active. Ask HMRC to make the scheme inactive when you expect no payments.

What happens if I forget to verify a subcontractor?

You may deduct at the wrong rate and owe HMRC the difference. Verify before the first payment; HMRC will tell you whether to deduct 20%, 30% or nothing.

Can I pay CIS deductions quarterly?

HMRC lets you pay monthly or quarterly to cover PAYE, National Insurance and CIS deductions, depending on your scheme. Monthly returns are still due every month.

Does CIS make my subcontractor self-employed?

No. Employment status depends on how the work is done. Check status for each engagement and keep the result.

References

  1. GOV.UK (2026). What is the Construction Industry Scheme (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. GOV.UK (2026). What you must do as a Construction Industry Scheme (CIS) contractor (full guide) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Office for National Statistics (Nomis) (2026). UK Business Counts - enterprises by industry and employment size band (SIC 2007 class 43.22), via Nomis (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. GOV.UK (2026). What you must do as a CIS subcontractor: get paid (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. GOV.UK (2026). Employment status: self-employed and contractor (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo