Tax finance admin

Buying materials better to protect margin

How plumbing and heating firms cut materials leakage: know your spend, consolidate merchants, use buying groups well and run returns properly.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Where materials margin actually goes
  2. Know your spend before you negotiate
  3. One main merchant, two, or a buying group
  4. Negotiating trade terms with your merchant
  5. Returns: the easiest money you are not collecting
  6. Credit, cash flow and materials
  7. A worked example of tighter buying
  8. A monthly materials review in 20 minutes
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References

Key takeaways

  • Most materials margin is lost to small leaks: unclaimed returns, emergency counter buys, duplicate orders and price creep on account.
  • Pull twelve months of merchant invoices before negotiating; your top 30 lines usually drive most of the spend.
  • Late payment is a major obstacle for 45% of construction SME employers, so materials terms and customer deposits need to match[1].
  • A buying group helps when its rebates beat the terms you can win alone and the supplier list fits the brands you fit.

Where materials margin actually goes

Ask most heating engineers where their materials margin goes and they will say the merchant price. In practice the list price is only part of it. The bigger losses are quieter: a box of fittings bought at the counter at full price because the van ran out, a cylinder ordered twice because two engineers both rang it in, a returns slip that never got processed, and a trade price that crept up a few per cent at a time without anyone noticing.

These leaks matter because materials often pass straight through to the customer at a fixed quote. If you quoted a boiler swap on last month's prices and bought on this month's, the difference comes out of your margin, not the customer's pocket. Profitability in the sector is common but not guaranteed: 80% of construction SME employers reported a profit or surplus in their last financial year, which means one in five did not[1].

  • Counter buys at full trade price because stock planning failed.
  • Duplicate or wrong items that sit in the van instead of going back.
  • Returns raised but never credited to the account.
  • Price changes on account not checked against the quote.
  • Materials used on call-outs that were never added to the invoice.

Know your spend before you negotiate

You cannot negotiate well with a merchant if you do not know what you buy. Most merchants can send a line-level export of your purchases. Get one from each account you hold and spend an evening with it.

  1. Export twelve months of invoices

    Ask each merchant for a spreadsheet of every line bought in the last year: product code, description, quantity, unit price and date. Ask for credits and returns as a separate list.

  2. Group lines into categories

    Boilers and cylinders, radiators and valves, copper and fittings, plastic and waste, controls, consumables (PTFE, flux, solder, sealants) and tools. Keep it to eight or so groups.

  3. Find your top lines

    Sort by total spend. In most heating businesses a short list of products, often the boiler range you fit, the cylinders and a handful of fitting sizes, makes up most of the money.

  4. Check price movement

    For your top lines, compare the first and last price paid in the year. Flag anything that rose without a notice from the merchant.

  5. Count counter buys

    Mark purchases made on the same day as a job at a branch away from your main merchant. These are your emergency buys and they show where van stock is failing.

If you are VAT-registered, compare prices net of VAT. If you are not registered, the VAT is a real cost to you, so compare gross. Registration becomes compulsory once taxable turnover in the last 12 months goes over the threshold[2].

One main merchant, two, or a buying group

There is no single right answer. The choice depends on how much you spend, how far you travel and how loyal you are to particular brands.

Choosing a purchasing set-up for a small heating business
ApproachWorks best whenWatch out for
One main merchantSpend is concentrated in one area and you want one account, one statement and a named rep who knows your jobs.Losing leverage over time; prices drift because nobody checks.
Two merchants, split by categoryYou can get a sharper deal on boilers from one and on plumbing sundries from the other.More admin, two statements to reconcile, and engineers using the wrong account.
Buying group membershipYou fit mainstream brands that the group has deals with, and you can track rebates.Membership fees, rebates paid in arrears, and supplier lists that do not include your preferred makes.
Manufacturer direct or installer schemesYou fit one boiler brand in volume and want extended warranties or loyalty points.Locking yourself to one brand when customers ask for others.

A simple test for a buying group: take your top lines from the spend export, ask the group for the price or rebate on each, and compare the total against your best current terms. If the saving does not clearly beat the membership cost and the extra admin, do not join.

Negotiating trade terms with your merchant

Branch managers have more room on price than the counter staff, and they respond to specifics. Go in with your spend export and a short ask, not a general request for a better deal.

A script that works: "We spent this much with you last year, mostly on these lines. I want to keep the account here and grow it, but I am being offered better prices on our top boilers and cylinders elsewhere. Can you match these numbers on these lines, and can you confirm price changes to me by email before they hit the account?" Then stop talking and let them answer.

  • Ask for fixed prices on your top lines for a set period, not a general percentage.
  • Ask for written notice of price increases, so quotes can be updated.
  • Ask about delivery to site for boiler and cylinder jobs to save engineer time.
  • Ask for a named contact who handles returns and credits.
  • Ask how the account limit is reviewed if your spend grows.

Returns: the easiest money you are not collecting

Unreturned stock is cash sitting in vans. Fix it with a routine, not good intentions.

  1. Give each van a returns crate. Anything unused at the end of a job goes in it, with the job reference written on the box.
  2. Pick one day a week for returns. One person takes the crates to the branch and gets a credit note for each item.
  3. Match every credit note to the account statement at month end. Chase any return that has not appeared.
  4. Check the merchant's returns window. Many branches will not take items back after a set time or without packaging, so speed matters.

Example: a fictional three-van business finds a crate of valves, a spare pump and two unused radiators across its vans. Returned within the merchant window, they become a credit. Left for three months, they become van clutter.

Credit, cash flow and materials

Buying materials on a trade account means you usually pay the merchant at the end of the following month. That only helps if your customers pay you before the merchant wants paying. For many trades the reverse is happening. Late payment was a major obstacle for 45% of construction SME employers in 2025, up from 36% the year before, the highest of any sector[1]. Across all SME employers who give trade credit, 63% said late payment was a problem[1].

Construction SME employers naming late payment as a major obstacle
Construction SME employers naming late payment as a major obstacleComparison. 2024: 36%; 2025: 45%.36%20242024: 36%45%20252025: 45%Construction SME employers naming late payment as a major obstacleComparison. 2024: 36%; 2025: 45%.36%20242024: 36%45%20252025: 45%

Source: Department for Business and Trade (GOV.UK), 2025[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
202436%
202545%

Many firms bridge the gap with cards. 47% of construction SME employers used credit cards as a source of finance in 2025[1]. That works for a few weeks but becomes expensive if it turns into a habit.

  • Take a deposit on installs that covers the main equipment before you order it.
  • Order boilers and cylinders for delivery close to the install date, not weeks ahead.
  • Invoice materials on the day the job finishes, not at the end of the week.
  • For business customers such as letting agents and contractors, you can charge statutory interest on late payments at 8% plus the Bank of England base rate[3].

If you work as a subcontractor under the Construction Industry Scheme, show materials as a separate line on every invoice. The contractor deducts 20% from a registered subcontractor's payments, or 30% if you are not registered, but materials you have paid for directly are not subject to the deduction[4]. Lumping labour and materials together means tax is taken from money that was only ever passing through to your merchant.

A worked example of tighter buying

Example (fictional figures): a two-engineer heating firm in the Midlands spends about £14,000 a month across two merchants. The spend export shows its main boiler range, two cylinder sizes and 15mm and 22mm fittings make up most of it. Counter buys at a second branch average six a month.

The owner asks the main merchant to fix prices on the top lines for six months and to email any changes. The merchant agrees to most of the list. The firm sets up van stock lists so engineers restock from the main account on a Friday, and starts a weekly returns run. After a quarter, counter buys have dropped to one or two a month and credits from returns show on every statement.

None of this needed a new supplier. It needed data, a clear ask and two routines that someone owns.

A monthly materials review in 20 minutes

  • Reconcile each merchant statement against job sheets: every line should belong to a job.
  • Check that every return raised has a matching credit.
  • Spot-check the price of your top five lines against what you are quoting.
  • Count counter buys and ask why each one happened.
  • Review deposits taken against equipment ordered for next month.

Pair this with your pricing rules. If you add a markup to materials, the markup only protects you if the cost you base it on is current. See how to set a materials markup and setting up merchant trade accounts for the next steps.

Frequently asked questions

Is it worth joining a plumbing buying group?

Only if the group's prices or rebates on the products you actually fit beat the terms you can get alone, after the membership cost. Test it with your own top lines from a twelve-month spend export.

How do I stop engineers buying at the counter?

Give each van a standard stock list, restock on a fixed day, and review every counter buy at month end. Most counter buys point to a gap in the van list rather than a careless engineer.

Should I pay for materials by card to get points?

Card points rarely outweigh the interest if the balance is carried. Many construction SMEs use cards for finance[1], but a trade account with customer deposits is usually cheaper.

Can I charge interest if a business customer pays late?

Yes. For business-to-business debts you can claim statutory interest of 8% plus the Bank of England base rate[3].

References

  1. Department for Business and Trade (GOV.UK) (2025). Longitudinal Small Business Survey 2025: SME employers (businesses with 1 to 249 employees) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. GOV.UK (2026). When to register for VAT (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. GOV.UK (2026). Late commercial payments: charging interest (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. GOV.UK (2026). What you must do as a CIS subcontractor: get paid (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo