Key takeaways
- Which? Trusted Traders assesses firms with a credit check, customer references, a review of business procedures and an interview[1].
- TrustATrader says its traders show proof of qualifications, trade association membership and public liability insurance, and limits memberships per area[2].
- Both are vetting-led schemes rather than pay-per-lead marketplaces; the badge is part of the value.
- Choose on the customers you want, the work involved in passing the checks and how complaints are handled.
Why vetting schemes exist
Homeowners letting a stranger into their home to work on gas or water want some assurance beyond a website. Their caution is understandable: in a government study, 11% of people who bought home maintenance and repair services, including plumbing and central heating, had a consumer problem[3]. Vetting schemes promise a check that the trader is real, competent and fair, and they display that check as a badge and a set of reviews.
For a plumbing and heating firm, the attraction is twofold. A recognised badge can lift your conversion on every channel, not only on the scheme's own website. And some customers search the scheme directly, so it can send enquiries as well. Against that, there is a fee, a vetting process that takes time, and ongoing obligations around complaints and reviews.
Which? Trusted Traders: how assessment works
Which? Trusted Traders says every trader on its site has passed an assessment set by its trading standards professionals, and that every customer review shown is verified as genuine by its moderators[4]. Its description of the assessment lists five parts[1]:
- A credit check, to validate the financial health of the business.
- Customer references, collected by contacting a selection of customers from your most recent work.
- A review of business and administrative procedures, to make sure they have consumer interests in mind.
- An interview and assessment, conducted face to face or by video call at your business premises.
- A written report with feedback from the assessor.
Complaints have a defined route. Which? describes a twelve-month limit for reporting, a 28-day window for the trader to respond and an 8-week period for agreeing a resolution[1].
TrustATrader: what it says it checks
TrustATrader states that all its traders provide proof of qualifications and membership of trade associations and hold public liability insurance, and that a trader who falls below its standards loses their place[2]. For trades, it says memberships are limited per area so each member gets a fair share of leads, and that traders do not pay commission on leads from the site[2]. Its home page in November 2026 showed an average trader rating of 4.95 out of 5 for the year[2].
Ask TrustATrader for the current membership fee, contract length, the number of members in your trade and area, and how reviews are collected and checked, as its public pages do not set these out in detail.
Side by side
| Factor | Which? Trusted Traders | TrustATrader |
|---|---|---|
| Main promise | Assessment set by trading standards professionals; endorsed by Which? | Proof of qualifications, trade association membership and insurance |
| Vetting steps described | Credit check, customer references, procedures review, interview, report | Qualification, membership and insurance evidence; removal below standards |
| Reviews | Verified as genuine by moderators | Full past customer reviews shown |
| Competition | Ask how many members in your trade and area | Memberships limited per area |
| Lead charges | Ask for current fee structure | No commission on leads, per its home page |
| Complaints | Defined process with response and resolution periods | Ask for the current process |
Neither scheme publishes a single price for every trade and area on the pages we checked, so ask each for a written quote with the contract length, notice period and renewal terms before you compare.
Preparing for vetting
Gather your credentials
Gas Safe registration, any competent person scheme membership, trade association membership, qualifications and public liability insurance documents.
Tidy your paperwork
Make sure your quotes, terms, invoices and complaints process are clear and consistent. Assessors look at how you deal with customers, not only at your technical skill.
Line up references
Let recent customers know they may be contacted, and choose a fair spread of jobs rather than only your favourites.
Write down your complaints process
Who handles a complaint, how fast you acknowledge it, how you investigate and how you put things right.
Check your finances
If a credit check is involved, make sure filings with Companies House or HMRC are up to date and any disputes are resolved.
Your terms should reflect the law. Under the Consumer Rights Act 2015, every service contract includes a term that the trader must perform the service with reasonable care and skill[5]. A complaints process that ignores that will not impress an assessor or a customer.
Questions to ask both schemes
Put the same questions to each scheme, in writing, and compare the answers side by side. Vague answers are a warning sign; a good scheme will be clear about what you get and what you must do in return.
- What is the total first-year cost, including any assessment or joining fee and VAT, and what does renewal cost?
- How long is the contract, what is the notice period and does it renew automatically?
- How many plumbing and heating members are listed in my postcode areas today?
- How do customers find members, and in what order are results shown?
- How are reviews collected and checked, and can I reply to them?
- What happens if a customer complains, and what is expected of me at each stage?
- How often am I reassessed, and what could lead to removal?
- What may I do with the badge and logo, and what must I remove if I leave?
Which one suits your firm?
- Which? Trusted Traders may suit firms that want a strong consumer brand behind them, do higher-value work such as replacements and bathrooms, and are comfortable with a formal assessment and complaints process.
- TrustATrader may suit firms that want a listing with limited competition per area and no commission on leads, and that can show qualifications and insurance easily.
- Neither may be needed if you already have strong Google reviews, a clear website and a full diary from direct enquiries. A badge helps most when trust is your bottleneck.
Example: a fictional heating firm in Exeter that mainly fits boilers decides the Which? badge would help with older homeowners comparing replacement quotes. It joins, adds the badge to its quote template and website, and tracks whether its replacement win rate changes over the next six months. A neighbouring plumbing firm doing mostly small repairs decides its Google reviews already do the job and spends nothing on either.
Using the badge well, and honestly
A badge only helps if customers see it at the moment they are deciding. Put it on your quote template, your website header or contact page, your email signature and your van if the scheme allows. Link it to your profile so customers can check it is real and read the reviews behind it.
Be careful with what you claim. Use the exact wording the scheme permits, keep the badge current, and remove it from your website, quotes and vans promptly if you leave or are removed. Showing a badge you no longer hold, or implying an endorsement you do not have, misleads customers and is the kind of claim consumer law treats seriously. The same applies to trade association logos and accreditation marks.
Finally, make sure your behaviour matches the badge. A scheme listing that promises fair dealing sits badly next to unanswered complaints or surprise charges. Your complaints process and your quotes are part of the reputation the badge is meant to signal.
Measuring the value
Track two things separately: enquiries that come directly from the scheme's website, and changes in your win rate on quotes from other channels after adding the badge. The first is easy to count; the second needs a before-and-after comparison over a few months. If neither moves, the membership is mainly a cost.
For lead marketplaces rather than vetting schemes, see MyBuilder vs Rated People vs Bark and is Checkatrade worth it for a plumber?. For manufacturer-backed listings, read getting found in manufacturer installer finders. Whatever you join, qualifying leads before you drive out keeps the enquiries it brings worth your time, and the guide on rogue emergency plumbers and your reputation explains why visible vetting matters in this trade.
Frequently asked questions
Is Which? Trusted Traders worth it for a plumber?
It can be if trust is what stops customers choosing you, especially for higher-value work. Its assessment includes a credit check, references, a procedures review and an interview[1]. Track direct enquiries and quote win rates to judge it.
Does TrustATrader charge commission on leads?
Its home page says traders never pay commission on leads from the site and that memberships are limited per area[2]. Ask for the current membership fee and terms in writing.
How long does Which? Trusted Traders give to resolve a complaint?
Which? describes a 28-day window for the trader to respond and an 8-week period for agreeing a resolution, with complaints reported within twelve months[1].
Can I belong to more than one scheme?
Usually yes, but each costs money and time. Join the one that best matches your customers first, measure it, then decide whether a second adds anything.
References
Which? Trusted Traders (2026). How we assess traders (opens in a new tab) ↑
TrustATrader (2026). Find Trusted Traders and Local Tradesmen (opens in a new tab) ↑
Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (GOV.UK) (2021). Consumer protection study 2022: understanding the impacts and resolution of consumer problems (opens in a new tab) ↑
Which? Trusted Traders (2026). Find traders near you with Which? Trusted Traders (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 49 (opens in a new tab) ↑