Marketing leads

MyBuilder vs Rated People vs Bark for plumbers

Compare MyBuilder, Rated People and Bark for a plumbing or heating firm: lead models, competition per lead, fit by job type and a fair test plan.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Three platforms, one question
  2. What is changing in this market
  3. The things that actually differ
  4. How competition changes the maths
  5. Fit by job type
  6. A fair three-month test
  7. A reply that wins shared jobs
  8. Turning platform customers into your own customers
  9. Example: comparing two platforms on cost per job
  10. When to step back from lead platforms
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • Lead platforms differ mainly in when you pay, how many trades see the same job and how much control you have over job types and areas.
  • Bark says it charges a fee for each introduction, with no commission[1]; check each platform's current terms in writing.
  • Rated People's help centre says Checkatrade acquired its assets on 18 September 2026[2], so terms may change.
  • About 71,200 UK plumbers and heating installers are self-employed[3]; many compete for the same posted jobs, so speed and fit decide who wins.

Three platforms, one question

MyBuilder, Rated People and Bark all connect homeowners who describe a job with tradespeople who want work. For a plumbing or heating firm, the question is not which one is best in general but which one, if any, brings you the jobs you want at a cost per booked job you can live with. The answer depends on your area, the type of work, how fast you respond and how much competition you face on each job.

This guide does not rank the platforms, because their fees and rules change and differ by trade and area. Instead it explains what to compare, the questions to ask each one and a fair way to test them against each other and against your other channels.

What is changing in this market

Ownership is shifting. Rated People's help centre states that Checkatrade acquired its assets on 18 September 2026, and directs questions about matters before that date to a separate address[2]. When platforms combine, lead routing, pricing, profiles and reviews can all change. If you use Rated People, check your current terms and ask what is changing before you buy more leads or renew a plan.

Bark describes its model for professionals as a small fee for each introduction, with no commission or hidden fees, and says it will send you all leads matching what you do[1]. MyBuilder sets out its own tradesperson fees and process on its site. Read each platform's current terms for plumbing and heating before comparing, and keep a copy.

The things that actually differ

What to compare across lead platforms for plumbing and heating
FactorWhy it mattersWhat to confirm with each platform
When you payPaying to see a lead, to contact a customer or only when chosen changes your riskAt what exact point am I charged, and how much?
Competition per jobThe more trades see the same job, the lower your win rateHow many trades can respond to or buy each job?
Job types and areasControl stops you paying for work you will declineCan I set job types, minimum job size and postcodes?
Refunds and creditsSome leads will be fake, duplicates or out of scopeWhat is the refund or credit process, and the time limit?
SubscriptionsA plan can lower lead costs but adds a fixed commitmentIs there a plan, what does it include and what is the notice period?
ReviewsReviews on the platform affect how often you are chosenCan I import or show reviews, and what happens to them if I leave?

Write the answers for each platform side by side. Where an answer is unclear, assume the less favourable version until you have it in writing.

How competition changes the maths

Lead platforms suit the way much of the trade works. About 148,600 people worked as plumbers and heating installers in the UK in the year to June 2026[4], of whom about 71,200 were self-employed and 77,400 employees[3][5]. Many self-employed plumbers look for work on the same platforms, so a posted job for a radiator valve in a busy town can attract several responses within minutes.

UK plumbers and heating installers by employment type, July 2025 to June 2026ONS Annual Population Survey via Nomis (rounded)
UK plumbers and heating installers by employment type, July 2025 to June 2026Comparison. Self-employed: 71,200; Employees: 77,400.71,200Self-employedSelf-employed: 71,20077,400EmployeesEmployees: 77,400UK plumbers and heating installers by employment type, July 2025 to June 2026Comparison. Self-employed: 71,200; Employees: 77,400.71,200Self-employedSelf-employed: 71,20077,400EmployeesEmployees: 77,400

Source: Office for National Statistics (Nomis), 2026[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
Self-employed71,200
Employees77,400

That has two effects. First, your win rate on shared jobs is lower than on a direct call from someone who found you on Google, so your cost per booked job is higher than the lead price suggests. Second, speed matters more than almost anything else: the first trade to respond with a clear, friendly message often wins, especially for small urgent jobs.

Fit by job type

  • Small repairs and odd jobs (dripping taps, toilet repairs, radiator valves): high competition, low value per job. Worth it only if leads are cheap and you can respond quickly and combine jobs in one area.
  • Boiler repairs and servicing: moderate value, often urgent. Platform leads can work if you have Gas Safe engineers available at short notice.
  • Boiler replacements and system upgrades: higher value, longer decisions. Expect homeowners to collect several quotes; your survey and written quote win the job.
  • Bathroom installations: high value and often project-managed. Check whether the platform lets you filter by size, and be ready for detailed questions before a visit.
  • Heat pumps: specialist work with grant requirements. Only pursue if you are certified and can explain the process clearly.

Rule of thumb: the smaller and more urgent the job, the more speed decides who wins. The bigger the job, the more your written quote, reviews and photos decide.

A fair three-month test

  1. Pick one platform at a time

    Testing three at once makes it hard to see which one worked and spreads your response time thin.

  2. Set filters tightly

    Choose only the job types and postcodes you want. Set a minimum job size if the platform allows it.

  3. Fix a budget

    Decide the most you will spend over the test, including any plan fee, and stop when you reach it.

  4. Respond with a template

    Prepare a short reply for each job type that confirms what you understood, asks one useful question and offers a time to talk or visit.

  5. Log every lead

    Record cost, response time, outcome and job value for each lead, plus any refund requests and results.

  6. Review at the end

    Work out cost per booked job and compare with your other channels and with your ceiling for that job type.

A reply that wins shared jobs

Script: 'Hi Priya, thanks for posting. From your description it sounds like the diverter valve on your combi, which we repair often. Could you send a photo of the boiler's data badge so I can check parts? I can come Thursday morning between 8 and 10. We are Gas Safe registered and our reviews are on our Google profile. Jo, Harper Heating.'

It works because it is specific, shows you read the job, asks for one thing that helps you prepare and offers a real time. Avoid generic replies pasted to every lead; homeowners can tell.

Turning platform customers into your own customers

The real value of a platform job is often the second job. A homeowner who finds you through a lead site for a dripping tap may need a boiler service next autumn and a replacement in three years. If they have to go back to the platform to find you, you pay again, and you compete again. Make it easy for them to come straight to you.

  • Leave a card or invoice with your own phone number, website and Google review link after every job, as you would for any customer.
  • Ask, at the end of the job, whether they would like a reminder when their boiler service is due. Record their consent if they say yes.
  • Ask happy customers for a review on both the platform and your Google profile, using only genuine customers and no incentives.
  • Check each platform's terms on contacting customers outside it; some restrict this, and breaking the rules can cost you the account.

Over a year, track how many platform customers came back to you directly. If a platform produces customers who return, a higher cost per first job can still be good value.

Example: comparing two platforms on cost per job

Example: a fictional plumber in Nottingham tests one platform from February to April and another from May to July. On the first, small repair leads are cheap but shared widely, and only one in six turns into a job. On the second, fewer leads arrive but more are boiler work, and one in three books. Cost per booked job is lower on the second, despite a higher price per lead. The plumber keeps the second, drops the first and moves part of the budget to Search ads for boiler replacements.

Before committing to any directory, read is Checkatrade worth it for a plumber? for the return worksheet and TrustATrader and Which? Trusted Traders compared for vetting-led schemes. If you fit boilers for a particular manufacturer, getting found in manufacturer installer finders can bring in replacement leads without a per-lead fee. Fit all of it into your one-page marketing plan.

When to step back from lead platforms

Lead platforms are useful for filling gaps, starting out or moving into a new area. They are less useful once your diary is steadily full from direct enquiries and repeat customers. Consider reducing or stopping when most of your work comes from your own profile, referrals and servicing customers, when platform cost per booked job is higher than your other channels for two quarters running, or when you are paying for leads you no longer have time to answer well.

Frequently asked questions

Which is better for plumbers: MyBuilder, Rated People or Bark?

None is best for everyone. Compare when you pay, how many trades see each job, the control you have over job types and areas, and refund terms. Then test one at a time and judge on cost per booked job.

How does Bark charge tradespeople?

Bark says it charges a small fee for each introduction and takes no commission[1]. Check its current pricing page for the cost in your category.

Is Rated People part of Checkatrade?

Rated People's help centre says Checkatrade acquired its assets on 18 September 2026[2]. Check your terms, as lead routing and pricing may change.

How quickly should I reply to platform leads?

As fast as you reasonably can, ideally within minutes during working hours. On shared jobs, the first clear and specific reply often wins.

References

  1. Bark (2026). How Bark.com works for Professionals (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Rated People (2026). Help Centre (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Office for National Statistics (Nomis) (2026). Annual Population Survey - regional - occupation (SOC2020) by sex by employment type, via Nomis (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Office for National Statistics (Nomis) (2026). Annual Population Survey - regional - occupation (SOC2020) by sex by employment type, via Nomis (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Office for National Statistics (Nomis) (2026). Annual Population Survey - regional - occupation (SOC2020) by sex by employment type, via Nomis (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo