Key takeaways
- A bonus scheme changes behaviour, so design it around the behaviour you want: right first time, safe work and happy customers.
- Sales commission on boiler replacements needs strong safeguards; services must still be performed with reasonable care and skill[1].
- Never pay engineers per review: commissioning reviews that hide an incentive is banned outright under the DMCC Act 2024[2].
- Bonuses are pay: they carry PAYE, employer National Insurance and usually pension contributions[3].
Why bonus design matters in a heating firm
Bonuses work. That is the problem. Pay an engineer for every boiler they recommend replacing and you will get more replacement recommendations, including some that a repair would have fixed. Pay for jobs completed per day and you may get faster jobs with more callbacks. Every scheme sends a message about what the business values, and engineers read it accurately.
There is also a legal and reputational side. Every contract to supply a service includes a term that the trader will perform it with reasonable care and skill[1]. Home repair is a sector where customers already report problems: 25% of UK adults bought home and garden maintenance and repair services in a year, and 11% of those had a consumer problem[4]. A bonus scheme that nudges engineers towards unnecessary work puts your reputation, reviews and repeat business at risk.
- Had a consumer problem 11%
Source: Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (GOV.UK), 2021[4]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Had a consumer problem | 11% |
The main types of scheme compared
| Scheme | How it works | What it encourages | Main risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Productivity bonus | Payment for billable hours or jobs above a target | Efficiency and full diaries | Rushed work and callbacks if quality is not measured |
| Sales commission | A share of the value of replacement or upgrade sales | Identifying genuine upgrade opportunities | Pressure selling and unnecessary replacements |
| Lead bonus | Flat payment when an engineer passes a lead that becomes a sale | Spotting needs without the engineer selling | Lower, but still needs honest recommendations |
| Quality bonus | Payment for low callback rates, complete paperwork and good audits | Right first time, safe, documented work | Needs reliable measurement |
| Team or profit share | Shared pot based on company results | Cooperation and shared goals | Weak link to individual effort |
| Skills-based pay | Higher base pay for each new qualification | Training and flexibility | Fixed cost even in a quiet year |
For most small firms, the strongest combination is a modest productivity or team element, gated by quality measures, plus skills-based pay for new qualifications. Pure sales commission is the hardest to run well.
Whichever type you choose, think about fairness between roles. An engineer who mostly does servicing will never generate the same sales leads as one who does breakdowns on older boilers. An installer may have no direct customer contact at the point of sale. If the scheme only rewards one kind of work, the others will feel left out, and the jobs nobody is rewarded for, such as training an apprentice or tidying the unit, will quietly stop getting done.
Design principles that keep quality first
- Gate every payment on quality. No productivity or sales bonus is paid for a job that had a callback within a set period, an incomplete certificate or a failed audit.
- Measure what the engineer controls. Callback rates, paperwork completion, first-time fix rate and customer feedback are fairer measures than total revenue, which depends on the jobs you give them.
- Keep it simple. An engineer should be able to work out their bonus on the back of a job sheet.
- Pay it soon. A monthly or quarterly bonus changes behaviour; an annual one is quickly forgotten.
- Cap it. A cap stops one unusual month from driving behaviour and protects you if the scheme has a flaw.
- Put it in writing, including that the scheme is discretionary and can be reviewed, so you can change it if it does not work.
If you pay commission on sales
Many firms do pay engineers something when a repair visit leads to a boiler replacement, because the engineer has done the work of diagnosing the system and earning the customer's trust. If you do, build in safeguards.
- Use a flat lead payment rather than a percentage of the sale, so the engineer gains nothing from upselling a bigger boiler.
- Require a written reason for every replacement recommendation, with photos and test readings.
- Have a second person review a sample of recommendations each month.
- Never link payment to declaring an appliance unsafe. Safety decisions must follow your unsafe situations procedure and nothing else.
- Give customers a repair option with a price wherever a repair is reasonable, and let them choose.
If a pattern of unnecessary replacements ever appears, stop the commission while you investigate. One complaint that reaches social media or the local news can cost more than years of extra sales.
Reviews and incentives: what the law says
It is tempting to pay engineers for each five-star review they collect. Do not. Under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, submitting or commissioning a fake consumer review, or one that hides an incentive, is treated as unfair in all circumstances[2]. Businesses that publish reviews are responsible for preventing and removing fake reviews and concealed incentivised reviews[5].
An engineer under pressure to collect reviews may offer customers discounts, write reviews for them, or only ask happy customers in a way that misleads. Reward the things that produce good reviews, such as tidy work, clear explanations and arriving on time, and ask every customer for honest feedback in the same way.
Tax, pay and pension treatment
Bonuses and commission are earnings. They go through payroll with income tax and employee National Insurance, and the employer pays 15% secondary National Insurance on earnings above £5,000 a year[3]. Bonuses usually count towards qualifying earnings for workplace pension contributions too. Budget for the full cost, not just the headline bonus.
Regular bonuses and commission can also affect holiday pay, because holiday pay should reflect normal earnings. Take advice if your engineers earn a significant part of their pay from commission or overtime.
A worked example scheme
Example (fictional business and figures): a six-engineer firm pays a base salary around the market median, which for full-time employees in the occupation nationally was £39,179 in 2026[6]. On top, it runs a quarterly bonus pot. Each engineer earns points for billable hours above a target, for complete and accurate certificates, and for jobs with no callback within 30 days. Any job with a callback scores zero. Engineers also receive a flat payment when a lead they pass on becomes an installation, whatever the size of the job.
In this example, the owner reviews a sample of replacement recommendations each month with the senior engineer. Over the first year, callbacks fall and paperwork improves because those are what the points reward. Sales leads continue at a steady rate, but the firm has no complaints about unnecessary replacements.
Signs a scheme is going wrong
- Replacement recommendations rise faster than the age of the boilers you are seeing would explain.
- Callbacks increase in the months after a productivity target is introduced.
- Engineers argue about who gets credit for a lead or a job.
- Paperwork is completed quickly but with copied readings or missing photos.
- The best engineer earns little bonus because they are given the hardest jobs.
- Customers mention feeling pressured in feedback or reviews.
Any one of these is a reason to pause and review. Talk to the engineers involved before assuming bad faith; often the scheme is rewarding something you did not intend, and they are simply responding to it.
Rewards that are not cash
Money is not the only lever, and in a small firm it is often not the most effective one. Engineers value things that make the working week better: first choice of holiday dates, a newer van, a tool budget they control, a day off after a heavy on-call week, paid training in an area they find interesting, or the chance to lead a particular type of job. These can be tied to the same quality measures as a cash bonus.
Recognition matters too. Telling the whole team when an engineer gets a thank-you message from a customer, or when someone passes a difficult assessment, costs nothing. Combined with fair base pay, it does more for retention than a complicated commission plan.
Introducing a scheme
Decide the goal
Pick one or two behaviours to improve, such as callbacks or billable hours.
Check your data
Make sure you can measure them reliably from job sheets or software before linking money to them.
Talk to the team
Explain the aim, ask for their views and listen for ways the scheme could be gamed.
Write the rules
Targets, gates, cap, payment timing, and that the scheme is discretionary and reviewable.
Run a trial quarter
Calculate what would have been paid without paying it, and check the results feel fair.
Launch and review
Pay on time, publish the results to the team, and review the scheme after a year.
See also what to pay plumbers and gas engineers and the call statistics to watch in a heating firm.
Frequently asked questions
Should heating engineers be paid commission on boiler sales?
It can work with safeguards: a flat lead payment rather than a percentage, written reasons for every replacement and regular review. Pure percentage commission encourages upselling.
Can I pay engineers for customer reviews?
No. Commissioning reviews that hide an incentive is treated as unfair in all circumstances under the DMCC Act 2024[2].
Do bonuses count for National Insurance?
Yes. Bonuses are earnings and carry employer National Insurance at 15% above the secondary threshold[3].
What is a fair bonus measure for engineers?
Measures the engineer controls, such as callback rate, paperwork completion and billable hours, gated so that poor-quality jobs earn nothing.
References
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 49 (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2025). Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, Schedule 20 (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (2026). Rates and thresholds for employers 2026 to 2027 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (GOV.UK) (2021). Consumer protection study 2022: understanding the impacts and resolution of consumer problems (opens in a new tab) ↑
Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) (2025). Short guide for businesses: publishing consumer reviews and complying with consumer protection law (opens in a new tab) ↑
Office for National Statistics (2026). Annual Survey of Hours and Earnings 2026 provisional, Table 14 (occupation by 4-digit SOC 2020) (opens in a new tab) ↑