Key takeaways
- The deciding question is not who answers the phone but who can book the job, price it and calm an angry customer.
- An office hire costs more than the wage: employer National Insurance is 15% above £5,000 a year[1], plus pension, holiday and cover.
- Employment Allowance of up to £10,500 can absorb much of the National Insurance bill for an eligible small employer[2].
- Answering services are strong on overflow and out-of-hours messages, weaker on diary decisions unless you give them access and rules.
- Many firms end up with both: a person for the day and a service, or an AI employee, for overflow, lunch and evenings.
The real question: who books the job?
Most heating firms reach this decision the same way. The owner is missing calls on jobs, the partner who used to answer has had enough, and someone suggests 'getting a receptionist'. Before comparing costs, write down what the person or service must actually do. Taking a name and number is one job. Checking the diary, booking a boiler service, explaining a call-out charge, chasing an unpaid invoice and dealing with a landlord's works order are very different jobs. An answering service can do the first well. Only someone with access, knowledge and authority can do the rest.
Side by side
| Factor | Answering service | Office staff hire |
|---|---|---|
| Cost shape | Pay for calls or a bundle; scales with volume | Fixed salary plus employer costs, whatever the call volume |
| Hours | Often early to late, sometimes round the clock | Contracted hours, usually office hours |
| Booking jobs | Possible with diary access and clear rules; often message-taking only | Yes, with judgement about travel, parts and priorities |
| Knowledge of your work | Script-based; limited to what you write down | Grows over months; knows customers and engineers |
| Other admin | None | Invoices, certificates, supplier orders, chasing payment |
| Cover gaps | Built in; another agent picks up | Holidays, sickness and lunch need a plan |
| Data protection | They process data for you; you need a written processor contract | Your own staff under your policies |
| Time to set up | Days | Weeks to recruit, then months to train |
What an office hire really costs
£12.71
National Living Wage per hour for workers aged 21 and over from April 2026[3]
The wage is the floor, not the total. The National Living Wage for workers aged 21 and over is £12.71 an hour from April 2026, rising to £13.21 from April 2027[3]. On top, employers pay 15% secondary Class 1 National Insurance on earnings above £5,000 a year[1], at least 3% employer pension contributions under auto-enrolment[4], and holiday pay for 5.6 weeks a year[5]. If the person is ill, Statutory Sick Pay is £123.25 a week or 80% of average weekly earnings, whichever is lower[6], and you still need the phone covered.
Example: a fictional heating firm hires an administrator for 37.5 hours a week at the National Living Wage. That is about £476 a week, or roughly £24,780 a year. Employer National Insurance on the part above £5,000 comes to about £2,970. If the firm is eligible for Employment Allowance, which is £10,500 for 2026 to 2027[2], that National Insurance may be fully absorbed. Pension, recruitment, a desk, a phone system and training time sit on top. In this example the total first-year cost is comfortably above the headline wage, but the firm also gets invoicing, certificate filing and supplier calls done.
Source: Department for Business and Trade (GOV.UK), 2025[7]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| 2024 | 31% |
| 2025 | 38% |
Wage costs worry many small employers. 38% of UK SME employers named the National Living Wage as a major obstacle in 2025, up 7 percentage points on 2024[7]. That is a reason to be clear about the workload before hiring, not a reason to avoid it.
Call quality: messages or bookings
The usual complaint about answering services is not rudeness. It is that every call becomes a message, and the office spends the next morning ringing people back to do the actual booking. If you choose a service, push for more than message-taking:
- Give them read access to the diary or a clear set of bookable slots for routine work such as boiler services and landlord safety checks.
- Write a one-page triage script: which words make a call urgent, who to call, and what to tell the customer.
- Ask for call recordings or transcripts so you can check how calls were handled.
- Agree what they must never do: quote prices beyond your published call-out charge, give technical advice or promise an arrival time.
A good office hire does all of this without a script after a few months, and also knows which regular customers always want the same engineer. That local knowledge is the strongest case for a person.
Cover gaps: lunch, holidays and sickness
A single office worker is one person. They take lunch, holidays and the occasional sick day, and the phones ring anyway. Before you hire, decide who answers when they are away. Many firms pair an office hire with an answering service for overflow and evenings, which also solves the problem of calls arriving while the administrator is already on the line.
There is now a third option between the two. An AI employee such as Ava answers in your firm's name, takes down the job details, follows your on-call rota for urgent calls and books routine visits into a tested diary, then sends the office a summary with the recording. It does not chase invoices or file certificates, so it complements an office hire rather than replacing one.
Decision criteria
Choose an answering service if
Most of the problem is overflow and out-of-hours calls, you have little admin beyond the phone, and you are happy to write scripts and check recordings.
Hire office staff if
You have a steady stream of admin beyond calls (invoices, certificates, landlord paperwork, supplier orders) and enough calls in office hours to fill a day.
Do both if
You hire someone for the day but still lose calls at lunch, after 5pm and at weekends, or when your administrator is already on another call.
Revisit the decision if
Call volume changes sharply, you take on a social housing or letting agent contract, or you start offering emergency cover.
Training either option on your work
Whichever route you choose, the first month decides whether it works. A new administrator and a new answering service both need the same raw material from you, and writing it once saves hours of corrections later.
- A coverage map or postcode list, with the areas you avoid at rush hour.
- A list of job types you do and do not take, in customers' words.
- Your urgency rules: which situations go to the on-call engineer and which wait for the morning.
- What may be said about charges, if anything, and the exact wording for it.
- Who to transfer to for complaints, invoices and supplier calls.
- Ten real call recordings or written examples, good and bad, so they can hear what you mean.
Sit in on, or listen back to, the first twenty calls. Most problems show up early: a postcode area that confuses people, a question customers ask that nobody prepared for, or an urgency rule that is too vague.
Measuring whichever option you choose
Agree three or four measures before you start so the decision can be reviewed on facts rather than impressions. Useful ones are the share of calls answered by a person or service rather than voicemail, the share of calls that ended with a booking or a clear next step, the time from message to call-back for anything not booked, and complaints about how a call was handled. Review them monthly for the first quarter. If the answering service turns most calls into messages, fix the script or the diary access. If the administrator is answering calls well but invoices are slipping, the job is bigger than one person and the overflow question comes back.
Questions to ask before you decide
- How many calls do we get in office hours and outside them? Pull a month of call logs before deciding.
- How many of those calls need a booking rather than a message?
- What admin is being done badly or late today, and by whom?
- Who covers the phone when the chosen person or service is unavailable?
- If we use a service, will it sign a data processing agreement and give us recordings?
Example: a five-engineer firm decides
Example: a fictional five-engineer firm in Nottingham logs a month of calls and finds about two-thirds arrive in office hours, with many needing a booking, and the rest arrive at lunch, early evening and weekends. The owner also spends Sunday evenings on invoices. They hire a part-time administrator for weekday mornings and afternoons and keep an answering service for overflow and evenings, with diary access for routine bookings. After three months they review recordings and move landlord calls entirely to the administrator, who knows the agents by name. For the next step, compare providers using the checklist in virtual receptionist services for trades.
Frequently asked questions
Is an answering service cheaper than a receptionist?
Usually for low or uneven call volumes, because you pay for calls rather than a salary. For a full day of calls plus admin, a hire can be better value. Count your calls first.
Can an answering service book jobs into my diary?
Some can, if you give them diary access and clear rules on what is bookable. Many default to message-taking, so ask specifically.
What employer costs come on top of an office wage?
Employer National Insurance above the secondary threshold, at least 3% pension contributions, paid holiday, sick pay and cover, recruitment and equipment.
Do I need a contract with an answering service for data protection?
Yes. They process customer data on your behalf, so UK GDPR requires a written contract that covers instructions, security and deletion.
References
GOV.UK (2026). Rates and thresholds for employers 2026 to 2027 (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (2026). Rates and thresholds for employers 2026 to 2027 (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (2026). National Minimum Wage and National Living Wage rates (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (2026). Workplace pensions: what you, your employer and the government pay (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (2026). Holiday entitlement (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (2026). Rates and thresholds for employers 2026 to 2027 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Department for Business and Trade (GOV.UK) (2025). Longitudinal Small Business Survey 2025: SME employers (businesses with 1 to 249 employees) (opens in a new tab) ↑