Technology AI

Using AI to draft review replies

Draft review replies faster with AI without sounding like a robot: prompts, a reply checklist, rules on fake reviews and worked examples for heating firms.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Why replies are worth the effort
  2. The legal line you must not cross
  3. A five-step reply routine
  4. What each reply should do
  5. Prompts that keep replies personal
  6. Handling a bad review step by step
  7. Practical checks before you post
  8. Asking for reviews the right way
  9. Setting up a house style
  10. How this fits your wider AI use
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • Use AI to draft replies, never to write or commission reviews: fake reviews and hidden incentives are banned outright[1].
  • Give the tool the facts of the job and your house style; the personal detail is what makes a reply read as genuine.
  • Reply to bad reviews within a day or two, take the detail offline and never argue about the job in public.
  • Replies on Google Business Profile are public and checked against Google's policies before they appear[2].
  • A named person in the business approves every reply before it is posted.

Why replies are worth the effort

A review reply is read by the next customer, not just the one who wrote the review. For a plumbing and heating firm, where most new work comes from people who have never met you, a calm, specific reply to a bad review can do more for trust than a dozen five-star ratings.

Problems are common enough that every firm will get some critical reviews. In a government consumer study, 25% of UK adults had bought home maintenance and repair services, which include plumbing and central heating, in the previous year, and 11% of those buyers had a consumer problem[3]. The same sector had a median net cost to consumers of £109 per problem, among the highest of any sector studied[4].

Buyers of home maintenance and repair services who had a consumer problemUK adults who bought these services in the 12 months to April 2021
Buyers of home maintenance and repair services who had a consumer problemDonut chart. Had a consumer problem: 11%.Had a consumer problem: 11%11%
  • Had a consumer problem 11%

Source: Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (GOV.UK), 2021[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
Had a consumer problem11%

Marketing is one of the most common business uses of AI in the UK[5], and review replies are an obvious place to start. The trick is to use the tool for the first draft and keep the judgement for yourself.

Since 6 April 2025, submitting or commissioning a fake consumer review, or a review that hides the fact it was incentivised, has been treated as unfair in all circumstances under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024[1]. A fake review is one that claims to be based on a genuine experience but is not[6].

That rules out several things some firms have been tempted to try with AI: having a tool write reviews for friends to post, generating reviews in bulk, or offering a discount for a five-star rating without saying so. If you publish reviews yourself, for example a testimonials page on your website, you are responsible for preventing and removing fake and concealed incentivised reviews[7], and you cannot hand that duty entirely to a third-party monitoring service[8].

AI is fine for replying to genuine reviews and for reminding happy customers that they can leave one. It must never write the review.

A five-step reply routine

  1. Read the review and find the job

    Look up the customer, date and engineer in your job system. Note what was done and anything that went wrong.

  2. Decide the type

    Praise, mixed, complaint, or not a customer at all. The type sets the aim of the reply.

  3. Draft with the job facts

    Give the tool the review text, two or three facts from the job and your style notes. Ask for a draft under 80 words.

  4. Edit for the person

    Add the engineer's first name if they are happy for it to be used, the specific work, and remove anything generic or over-polite.

  5. Approve and post

    One named person approves every reply. For complaints, also log the review in your complaints record.

What each reply should do

Aim, content and pitfalls for each type of review reply
Review typeAim of the replyIncludeAvoid
Five-star praiseThank and reinforceThe job done and the engineer by first nameCopy-paste thanks used on every review
Mixed (good work, poor communication)Show you heard the criticismWhat you are changing, brieflyExplaining why it was not your fault
Complaint about the workMove it to a private conversationAn apology for the experience, a direct contact nameJob details, prices or blame in public
Complaint about priceExplain the basis calmlyThat prices were agreed before work started, if trueQuoting the customer's invoice
Not a customerSay so politelyThat you cannot find a record and invite contactAccusing the reviewer of lying

Prompts that keep replies personal

Most AI-written replies fail because the tool is given nothing to work with. Feed it facts. These templates work in most tools.

  • Praise: Write a reply under 60 words to this review. The job was [work done] on [day]. The engineer was [first name]. Tone: warm, plain British English, no exclamation marks, no emojis. Do not invent any detail.
  • Mixed: Write a reply under 80 words. Thank them for the comments on the work. Acknowledge that [problem, such as arrival time not confirmed]. Say we now [change]. Do not make excuses.
  • Complaint: Write a reply under 70 words. Apologise that their experience fell short, without admitting specific fault. Invite them to call [name] on [business number]. Do not mention prices, job details or the customer's name.

Keep a short style sheet the tool sees every time: how you sign off, words you never use, whether you use first names, and a ban on stock phrases. Two lines of style notes do more than any setting.

Handling a bad review step by step

A critical review stings, especially about a boiler you spent two hours on. Write nothing for an hour. Then check the job record and talk to the engineer before you draft. If the customer has a point, the public reply should acknowledge it and say what happens next. If they do not, the reply should still be calm, because readers judge you by tone more than by who was right.

Example (fictional) review: Engineer turned up two hours late, no call, and the boiler went off again the next day. Example reply: We are sorry the visit did not go as it should. You should have had a call when the engineer was delayed, and we have changed how we update customers on the day. Please call Sam on our office number so we can come back and look at the boiler again at no charge for the return visit.

Notice what the reply does not say: no job details, no defence of the engineer, no argument about whether the second fault was related. Those belong in the private conversation that follows.

Practical checks before you post

  • Does the reply mention something only this job could have? If not, add it.
  • Is any personal information included, such as the street, the fault in detail or what they paid? Remove it.
  • Would you be comfortable reading it aloud to the customer?
  • Does it promise anything you cannot deliver, such as a free repair you have not agreed?
  • Is it under 80 words for praise and under 100 for a complaint?

On Google Business Profile, approved replies appear publicly under the review, posted as the business, and you can edit or delete your reply later[2]. That makes it tempting to post quickly and fix afterwards. Do not: the first version is the one the customer reads.

Asking for reviews the right way

Replies only matter if reviews keep arriving. The safest way to ask is to ask everyone, the same way, with no reward linked to what they write. A short message after each completed job, sent by a person or your job system, does the job.

Example (fictional) request: Thanks for having us today. If you have a minute, an honest review helps other people in the area choose a heating engineer. Here is the link. If anything was not right, please reply to this message first so we can put it right.

  • Ask every customer, not just the ones you expect to be happy. Selective asking skews your reviews and can mislead readers.
  • Never offer a discount, prize draw entry or free service in return for a review unless you are prepared to say so openly, and never in return for a positive one.
  • Do not post reviews on behalf of customers, even if they tell you what to write.
  • Keep a simple record of when requests were sent, in case your review practices are ever questioned.

Setting up a house style

Write down five rules for every reply and paste them into the tool each time. A typical set for a family heating firm: sign off with a first name and the business name; use plain British English with no exclamation marks; thank the customer in the first sentence; never mention prices or the customer's address; for any complaint, give a named contact and ask them to call. With these in place, drafts come back close to finished and editing takes a minute rather than five.

Review your replies every quarter. Read the last twenty in one go. If they all sound the same, the style sheet is too rigid; if they all sound different, it is being ignored.

How this fits your wider AI use

Review replies are a good training ground because every output is short and checked. The same discipline applies to AI-written job notes and to the wider risks of AI in a trade business. If customers ask whether they are talking to a person when they call, see how customers feel about AI voices.

Frequently asked questions

Is it legal to use AI to reply to reviews?

Yes. The legal problems arise with writing or commissioning fake reviews, or hiding incentives[1]. Replying to genuine reviews with an AI-assisted draft is fine, as long as a person checks it.

Can we offer customers something for leaving a review?

Concealed incentivised reviews are banned[1]. Asking every customer for honest feedback, with no reward linked to a rating, is the safe approach.

Should we reply to every review?

Reply to every critical review and to most positive ones. Short, specific thanks are enough for praise; complaints need a careful reply and a private follow-up.

Can we delete a bad review?

You can edit or delete your own reply[2]. You can flag a review that breaks the platform's policies, but a genuine negative review is best answered, not hidden.

References

  1. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2025). Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, Schedule 20 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Google Business Profile Help (2026). Reply to reviews on your Business Profile (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (GOV.UK) (2021). Consumer protection study 2022: understanding the impacts and resolution of consumer problems (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (GOV.UK) (2021). Consumer protection study 2022: understanding the impacts and resolution of consumer problems (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Department for Science, Innovation and Technology (GOV.UK) (2025). AI adoption survey report 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2024). Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, Schedule 20 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) (2025). Short guide for businesses: publishing consumer reviews and complying with consumer protection law (opens in a new tab) ↑

  8. Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) (2025). Short guide for businesses: publishing consumer reviews and complying with consumer protection law (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo